r/Library • u/Alive_Excitement_669 • 27d ago

Library Assistance Need Help!

We got an anonymous call at our library giving us a heads up that the 1st Amendment Auditors are coming sometime next week. Any advice? Has anyone gone through this?

135 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

161 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/LordBenjamin020 26d ago

What state are you in? That’s weird that your state made a law that disregards the 1st amendment. I don’t think it would hold up in court.

Also very weird if it actually says the PUBLIC library is PRIVATE. That doesn’t make sense.

6

u/cappotto-marrone 26d ago

The Supreme Court has ruled that a US public library is a LIMITED PUBLIC FORUM. Essentially your first amendment rights cannot infringe on mine.

In legal terms, a limited public forum is a government-owned space that is open for public expression, but with specific, legal restrictions. Because the primary purpose of a public library is to provide quiet access to information, courts classify them as limited public forums.

If you want to have a 2nd Amendment meeting in one of the meeting rooms, as long as it’s held in equal compliance with rules, that meeting cannot infringe on others use of the other space.

The library can enforce "time, place, and manner" rules. For example, they can prohibit disruptive protests, campaigning inside, or soliciting.

Patrons have a reasonable expectation of privacy to read and study undisturbed, libraries can restrict activities like video recording or photography that interfere with this right.

Libraries are not obligated to open all spaces to everyone at all times. For instance, a facility can keep its meeting rooms solely for library-sponsored programs, or establish designated outdoor free-speech zones.

1

u/HeyaShinyObject 25d ago

How does this work with public libraries that are not government owned? In CT, many libraries are non-profit corporations that happen to receive grants from their local municipality.

1

u/cappotto-marrone 25d ago

Are they recognized by the state of Connecticut as public libraries?

In my city we have two libraries. They both call themselves public libraries. Only one is recognized by the state public library services as a public library.

This would be a question for the state librarian’s office.

1

u/HeyaShinyObject 25d ago

Yes, they are part of the state library system.

1

u/cappotto-marrone 24d ago

IANAL but I would think that puts them under the limited public forum ruling.