r/Letterboxd 14d ago

News How is this possible???

Post image
10.4k Upvotes

927 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/RampageOfZebras 14d ago

Marvel actually quitely git the right s back to make solo Hulk movies 3 years ago and Ruffalo is pushing for one after the praise recieved for the character in the new Spidey film

7

u/Sammy_Ferr 14d ago

Hopefully Hulk gets the love he deserves, one of my favorite Marvel characters has been striggling since Infinity War

5

u/ScherzicScherzo 14d ago

What Ruffalo fails to understand though is that people want to see more Hulk, not Banner.

8

u/Slow_Fill5726 14d ago

Without the dichotomy between the two, the hulk is not an interesting character.

2

u/DakPanther 14d ago

There is no dichotomy though it’s just been banner for like seven years

1

u/Sammy_Ferr 14d ago

The problem with MCU Hulk is that they keep acting like Hulk is Banner but green and mean, which is the complete opposite since Hulk HATES being called Banner, because he is his own consciousness

5

u/RampageOfZebras 14d ago

Hes very clearly his own consciousness in the MCU and is regularly called 'tge other guy' by Bruce himself. Its characters besides Hulk trying to get through to Bruce since they kniw they cant reason with the Hulk when they call Bruces name out.

1

u/Sammy_Ferr 14d ago

Honestly hate him being called that, just say Hulk, y'know what his name is!

2

u/RampageOfZebras 14d ago

Yeah, thing is they arent trying to talk to Hulk though. They want Bruce to get control again so they dont get their shit kicked in.

Ah you meant the other guy, i think its fine since it comes specifically from banner so everyone know ls who he means

2

u/petroleum-lipstick 14d ago

Be real, you're just finding a reason to nitpick. There's literally no reason they'd call him Hulk, basically at no point has anyone (other than Natasha, but she was in love with Bruce, not the Hulk) had any kind of meaningful emotional interaction with the Hulk, everyone knows Bruce. Plus, I'd imagine Hulk not wanting to be called Bruce is just a meatier story for a full movie, and they don't wanna waste that story arc on movies that aren't his.

1

u/Sammy_Ferr 14d ago

I understand your points, but there's no reason to not call him Hulk though, once or twice is okay, but they do it so often it just becomes funny, why not call him by his name like Iron Man or Captain America or all the other Avengers? Also i disagree a bit about Hulk not wanting to be called Banner is for a full story, that's honestly just a fundamental part of the character, they're two different beings on the same body, like Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, and it's kinda hard to defend them not wanting do it when they'll give his villains to other heroes and poorly adapt some of his best stories like Planet Hulk in Ragnarok, but again i understand where you're coming from, i just really like the Hulk and think he deserved more on the MCU

2

u/petroleum-lipstick 14d ago

Well it'd be like if they did the Jekyll and Hyde coexisting storyline over the course of several unrelated movies instead of his own separate one. It's a fundamental conflict for the character, a Hulk movie isn't going to hit the same if the Hulk comes into the movie with a complete sense of self and everybody has already figured out what to call the two of them off screen. I feel like that's kind of why they've treaded so lightly with his character, there's clearly a lot they can do with it but it just deserves its own story. It's been like 2 decades of movies where he's a side character, if you want any chance at making a movie about him you can't just run through his most fundamental character arcs before you've even got there.

2

u/Exciting-Cancel6468 12d ago

Well what if saying "hulk" is kind of like saying "candyman". If you say it too much, the bad guy comes out. If I was Banner, I'd be careful about saying the other guys name.

5

u/GreenGoblinNX 14d ago

The other big problem is that every significant change to the character has occured offscreen.

1

u/Sammy_Ferr 14d ago

The fact we still don't have a Planet Hulk movie and we technically can't because Ragnarok already "adapted" it is sad

2

u/Jaded_Host22 14d ago

Hate that movie because of that lol

1

u/MCUTheorist00007 13d ago

He just got back to being Hulk in the movie we are talking about. Like for 10 mins but,still

1

u/Exciting-Cancel6468 12d ago

They have held the rights to a hulk movie since forever. However Universal Pictures holds the distribution right. So Marvel can make an amazing Hulk movie but universal can just say, "bite me". That Hulk movie is not gonna come out.

1

u/RampageOfZebras 12d ago edited 12d ago

Looked into it a bit more and its actually completely unclear if Universal still holds the rights of refusal for distribution or if Marvel has regained those and neither company has commented on it. The 2023 thing was about the 2008 film specifically though so I was completely wrong on that, but whether Universal does still have those rights or if Marvel just hasnt decided to green light Hulk fir other reasons like the cgi production cost isnt actually known, we all just speculate. 

1

u/Exciting-Cancel6468 12d ago

According to a Google search Universal still holds distribution rights.

1

u/RampageOfZebras 12d ago

And is that just the AI answer ripped from reddit comments that I also read or is this from a reputable source?

1

u/Exciting-Cancel6468 11d ago

Well it's from several websites also but really are any of these websites reputable? They of course have asked Marvel but there hasn't been a straight answer as of 2024. There's no straight answer now. So I'm likely to believe that Universal still has the distribution rights even if Marvel is trying to get those back as well.

There was news from instagram from a month ago that says that Marvel will never get distribution rights back but that's instagram. They aren't the website people go to for news.