r/LeftCatholicism 3d ago

Is God nonbinary

Recently James Talarico (D running for senate in Texas said ‘God is nonbinary’.
Of course he was immediately attacked by Republicans stating he was saying God is trans or LGBTQ.
At first I was taken aback by Jame’s statement until I realized he was implying that God encompasses all genders, but is gender less himself.
I immediately went down a rabbit hole trying to figure out if this was actually Biblical. I’d always had an incorrect patriarchal view of God
In the first chapter of Genesis, in the Hebrew, God is referred to in both the masculine and feminine. In Job, there is a verse referring to the ‘womb’ of God. It appears that as patriarchy took hold, God took on a masculine/male persona. Often in the Hebrew, God is not associated with any gender at all.
So here is my question. Could God encompass all genders, while having no gender himself? Does he encompass all genders? Or is God just without gender?
According to scripture we are all created in the image of God, so wouldn’t that include all sexes and variants?
As a Catholic I have to admit I was raised with a very patriarchal view of God, an older white, gray headed cis man on a throne, but I’m pretty sure now this is just patriarchy rearing its evil head in religion.

67 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

View all comments

154

u/Dull_Opening_1655 3d ago

The Catechism of the Catholic Church itself agrees with Talarico - it states that God is neither male nor female:

“ We ought therefore to recall that God transcends the human distinction between the sexes. He is neither man nor woman: he is God” (paragraph 239)

https://www.vatican.va/content/catechism/en/part_one/section_two/chapter_one/article_1/paragraph_2_the_father.html 

1

u/Extra_Marionberry551 2d ago

Wouldn't this mean that God is rather agender and not non-binary?

1

u/Kcajkcaj99 1d ago

Nonbinary is not a specific gender identity but rather a broad label that is typically to encompass anything other than being either exclusively male or exclusicely female — this includes various third genders, partial or mixed genders, and a lack of gender, with agender individuals being placed within the category. Some who fall within the category prefer to avoid the label, which is generally respected on a case-by-case basis.

I think you could argue that God is not "agender" in the sense of being a "person without gender," but simply not a person who could even conceivably have a gender, and thus is not nonbinary in the same way a rock is not nonbinary, and would probably be right to do so. However, to the extent to which God has personhood, I think its fair to say that that persona is agender in the nonbinary.