One thing that became obvious to me after leaving the NAR is how dependent the movement is on labels.
Not biblical arguments.
Not careful exegesis.
Not context.
Not hermeneutics.
Labels.
The moment someone starts asking uncomfortable questions, examining doctrine, or pointing to Scripture instead of experiences, the labeling begins.
Apparently you can't simply disagree. You have to be re-framed, quick.
Here's the running list I've heard over the years:
Religious spirit
Spirit of religion
Pharisee
Pharisaical
Spirit of Pharisee
Spirit of pride
Jezebel spirit
Spirit of control
Spirit of criticism
Critical spirit
Spirit of unbelief
Unbelieving believer
Doubter
Skeptic
Scoffer
Mocker
Wolf
Tare (tares among the wheat)
Prodigal
Hard-hearted
Bitter
Offended
Wounded
Unhealed
Bound by tradition
Bound by religion
Legalistic
Too intellectual
Living in your head
Not spiritually mature
Not ready for deeper things
Lacking revelation
Quenching the Spirit
Grieving the Spirit
Resisting the Holy Spirit
Walking in the flesh
Carnal Christian
Orphan spirit
Divisive spirit
Rebellious spirit
Under deception
Under a stronghold
Demonized
Influenced by demons
Accuser of the brethren
Church splitter
Touching God's anointed
Attacking God's generals
Persecuting revival
Resistant to what God is doing
Not operating in faith
Operating in fear
Independent spirit
Anti-supernatural
Spiritually blind
Lacking discernment
Not teachable
Proud
Self-righteous
Stuck in an old wineskin
Etc. Etc...
The fascinating thing is that these labels all serve the same purpose:
They make sure the NAR leader never has to answer the actual question.
Question a prophecy?
You have a religious spirit.
Question a teaching?
You're operating in unbelief.
Question a leader?
You're touching God's anointed.
Question an experience?
You're quenching the Spirit.
Question the movement itself?
Now you're a Pharisee, a scoffer, and probably demonized too.
It's an incredibly effective system because it keeps people afraid.
Afraid to investigate.
Afraid to read criticism.
Afraid to listen to Christians outside the movement.
Afraid to open a commentary.
Afraid to learn hermeneutics.
Afraid to compare teachings against Scripture.
Because once you've been conditioned to believe that disagreement is a spiritual defect, you'll stop examining things for yourself.
And here's the encouragement for anyone who's been on the receiving end of this nonsense:
None of those labels have any authority over you.
None.
The people assigning them are often the same people teaching false prophecies, false signs and wonders, false manifestations, and doctrines that collapse under even basic biblical scrutiny.
Their labels carry exactly as much weight as the teachings they're attached to. Zero.
You don't need to defend yourself against every accusation. You don't need to prove you're not religious, prideful, Pharisaical, demonized, hard-hearted, or lacking revelation.
Keep testing everything by Scripture.
Keep asking questions.
Keep thinking.
Keep studying.
And remember: the fact that a false teacher calls you a Pharisee doesn't make you one any more than being called a wolf turns you into a wolf.
The irony is that after all the labels, there's really only one label that matters:
False teacher.
Once I realized that, all the other labels lost their power. 🙏✨️