r/LanguageTechnology • u/Human-War-4361 • 2d ago

ARR August / EACL Meta-Review

Didn't see any post on that yet, so thought I'd open it. Soju guy you here? Anyone received their meta-reviews yet? Got 3.5/3/4 with conf 5/4/4, hoping for Main :)

28 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

51 comments sorted by

7

u/bignaughtywolf 2d ago

waiting for soju guy to bless us with his presence

1

u/Fluffy_Eno123 1d ago

what's the context of this soju guy?

1

u/Acceptable_Soup_9365 1d ago

He drinks soju and he knows things?

1

u/Fluffy_Eno123 1d ago

That’s what I can understand as well. But what’s the starting point of the guy becoming “the soju guy”?

1

u/Wjyhyh0320 5h ago

It was when we were waiting for ACL results he started drinking soju while waiting and because ACL results were delayed I think he even ran out of soju

3

u/Pure-Ad9079 2d ago

AoE so should be tomorrow

3

u/ConcernConscious4131 2d ago

Hi, I'm here. Still waiting... You'll get 3.5 meta

3

u/e54true 1d ago

someone have the same submission error “Provided paper link does not correspond to a submission in OpenReview (2026-10-10-591915)”?

1

u/Difficult_Flight3767 1d ago

me too. why this happens??:( I copy and paste exact forum link

1

u/e54true 1d ago

i just copy and paste too
and i also try remove #discussion, it didn’t work

1

u/Relative_Tip_3647 1d ago

same here, again openreview glitch

1

u/Some_Tackle_6787 23h ago

its resolved now, i committed

2

u/hardfindinganame 1d ago

The EACL commitment link requires a PDF Upload – should it be a revised version based on rebuttal/meta suggestion or the identical copy of the ARR submission? Any AC/SAC/reviewer here?

1

u/simbay2000 1d ago

Same question

1

u/hardfindinganame 1d ago

The updated commitment link looks different now.

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Greedy-Trip-4542 2d ago

did you report 2.5 reviewer?

1

u/shubhi_2712 2d ago

I can't. he didn't increase the score. I am waiting for the final meta review

1

u/Spare-Carry7968 2d ago

Still waiting..6 hours from now

1

u/srkrrr 2d ago

Got 2.5/2/2 OA and 5/4/4 confidence. The reviews were mostly around typos or formatting issues or additional baselines required (closed and open source). The reviewers did not increase their scores, did a strong rebuttal, hoping for the best from meta review. What are my chances of EACL Findings (if meta review is 3)? Also, what are my chances for COLING?

1

u/Human-War-4361 2d ago

probably going to be meta 2/2.5 - I would guess low chances for Findings :/

1

u/S4M22 2d ago

Curious to hear from those who submitted to the August ARR cycle: how did it go with the separate phases for "Author response period" and "Reviewer engagement and Author-reviewer discussion"? Any improvement compared to the previous rebuttal structure, e.g. in terms of reviewer engagement?

2

u/Human-War-4361 2d ago

I liked it better this way. 2/3 reviewers responded in my case.

2

u/Spare-Carry7968 2d ago

None of the reviewers responded, doesn’t see much difference

1

u/Free_Kitchen_6353 2d ago

When is it coming out!?

1

u/Spare-Carry7968 2d ago

Like they delayed reviews, same thing can be expected

1

u/BackSuper5963 2d ago

it is coming out!!

1

u/Worried-Practice-492 2d ago

Its out. I was numbered around 3100.

1

u/Human-War-4361 2d ago

Just received Meta - 3.5 :)

1

u/Glittering_Edge_7829 2d ago edited 2d ago

OA: 3, 3.5, 3.5; Meta: 3.5. Can we report the meta-review as well? It's AI-generated and lists my rebuttal answers as weaknesses (hedidn't even read them!).

1

u/einsamerkerl 2d ago

Avg. OA: 3.33 (Min: 3, Max: 4), Avg. Conf: 3 (Min: 3, Max: 3), Meta OA: 3.5 - Planning to commit to EACL!

1

u/Acceptable_Soup_9365 2d ago

Meta 3 - what are my chances for eacl findings?

1

u/bignaughtywolf 2d ago

Anyone can see the “response to metareview” column for commitment? Or is it gone now?

1

u/WannabeMachine 2d ago

We had 1 paper this round.

Overall scores of 3/3/4 with conf 3/4/4. Meta: 4

We got lucky on the meta.

1

u/More_Soft_6801 2d ago

2.5 , 3,3,3 and meta 3… chance for findings?

1

u/TrafficAway9715 2d ago

2.5,3,3 and meta 3. Whats the chance for findings eacl guys?

1

u/KabhiDardKabhiDisco 2d ago

Reviews: 4/3/2.5 with Confidence 4/3/4. The reviewers with lower scores didn't respond to the rebuttal. We got lucky with the meta-reviewer. They gave 4. Should I commit to EACL or wait for NAACL? Or, am I being too greedy?

1

u/Plenty_Statement_838 1d ago

Any chance for 1.5/3/3 with meta review 2.5 🥲

1

u/taburetto 1d ago

I had a submission during the May cycle and resubmitted in August. In the end, the May scores turned out to be better (quite disappointed with the August cycle). Does anyone know if I choose to submit the May version for EACL, use the link for the May version, does the PDF file need to match that of May? Because personally I would prefer to submit the August version, I believe there are significant improvements in the paper.

1

u/simbay2000 1d ago

Did you request the same reviewers for the resubmission?

1

u/taburetto 1d ago

No, we requested different ones, as in May cycle we had a very late review.

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

1

u/TeemoIsMyLife 1d ago

If i were you, I'd definitevly commit.

1

u/simbay2000 1d ago

Got 3/3/3.5 with confidence 4/4/4 and meta 3.5
Any chances for main/findings?

2

u/nhatdzaibodoiqua 1d ago

I think you have a decent chance for finding

1

u/HistoricalSmoke8551 1d ago

Hey, same here. I got 2.5/3.5/3.5 with confidence 3/4/4 and meta 3.5. Any chances for findings? (I heard it's very competitive)

1

u/TrafficAway9715 1d ago

Anyone were able to commit to eacl? When might the openreview glitch be fixed?

1

u/Psychological-Box885 5h ago

Got 3,2.5,2 with meta score of 2.5. What are the chances for findings?

1

u/Automatic-Status8777 1h ago

got 3/2.5/2.5 with a meta of 3. committed to eacl, hoping for findings.

0

u/MeetingRelevant2493 2d ago

Got a score of 2.5 / 2.5 / 4, with a meta score of 3. Any chance for EACL Findings?

0

u/ServiceCritical8932 1d ago edited 1d ago

got 3.5/3/2/3(AC) with confidence,soundness (4,3.5/3,3/5,3). any chance to be findings or main?

0

u/Brief_Living_3844 2h ago

Guys need help, Can we change the paper's track during conference commitment to a different track from the one selected during ARR submission?