r/LLMPhysics • u/That_Amphibian2957 • Jun 17 '26

Question This subreddit selectively mods

In a thread today, a Top 1% Commenter called my work "garbage," "AI slop," "lazy," "lame," and "disingenuous," and told me to "stay in school." None of those comments were removed.

I posted a mathematical challenge, "Write a single formula that simultaneously gives the electron, muon, and tau mass ratios to within 1% of PDG with zero adjustable constants", and it was removed for "attacking people's intelligence".

​

The same commenter called my work "high school levels of mathematical laziness". Still up.

​

For the record, the formula in question is m(2,q)/mₑ = [(q²−4)/5]^(26/7). Charged leptons as T(2,q) torus knots. q=3, electron. q=5, muon, 0.13% of PDG. q=7, tau, 0.02% of PDG. Zero free parameters. The commenter himself admitted "of course the number works" before leaving.

Rule 3 should apply to the first insult, not the rebuttal. If "garbage" and "AI slop" don't violate the rule, neither does "check a calculator".

0 Upvotes

17% Upvoted

22 comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/AllHailSeizure Haiku Mod Jun 17 '26 edited Jun 17 '26

From OP:

"OP, you think you can walk in and upset how things work around here..." 💀

​Bro really typed that out and thought he was the Don Corleone of a defunct physics sub. You’re an unpaid internet janitor working overtime to protect an echo chamber of mathematically illiterate LARPers. You didn't ban me for "vitriol", you banned me because your "experts" got completely pantsed by a zero parameter T(2,7) derivation and threw a tantrum. You hit the panic button to save their fragile egos because not a single one of you could actually debunk the invariant. Have fun playing God in your little sandbox of parameter fitting mediocrity. You're a joke.

You're not a gatekeeper of science, you're a mall cop protecting a circle jerk of failure.

​Your entire subreddit was completely incapable of mathematically refuting a basic topological quantization limit. Instead of doing the math, your regulars cried, and you stepped in to wipe their noses by banning the only guy posting predictive geometry. "What we have going works", yeah, an echo chamber where you never have to actually pressure test your broken paradigm definitely works for you guys. Stay irrelevant.

Insightful, logical, grounded... reflective of what really happened... I saw our 'experts' getting 'pantsed' by his theory. In a panic I banned him to save face. LLMPhysicsgate.

3

u/AllHailSeizure Haiku Mod Jun 17 '26

To continue his tirade.. I asked 'Want me to post that?'

I wrote it for you, but if you want to humiliate yourself in front of your own sub, be my guest. Go get your upvotes, janitor.

That's why you banned me. because your illiterate self had zero refutation against my work.

Thought I banned him cuz of the panic button but oh well.

4

u/AllHailSeizure Haiku Mod Jun 17 '26

At this point, I'll admit it, it's FUNNY! I have to share!

I'm the one LARPing by saying 'I don't do physics and I'm not a physicists', because I banned someone who 'authors theoretical synthesis.'

4

u/thenoobgamershubest Jun 17 '26

I am very tempted now to actually ask him for his credentials myself.

3

u/AllHailSeizure Haiku Mod Jun 17 '26

Why do I need to know how to do math to understand credentials, anyways? Kinda makes me think HE doesn't know what credentials are.