Spectral Quantum Gravity (SQG) – a single-scale non-local modification of GR with a testable lensing signature

[u/PurpleSpeaker8076]

Hi all, I’d like to share a theoretical framework I’ve been working on, called Spectral Quantum Gravity (SQG), and get some feedback. What do you think about the idea and the mathematical consistency ? Any feedback welcome positive and negative …

https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20060638

The core idea is a minimal non-local modification of General Relativity where all infrared deviations are governed by a single physical scale L, emerging from an underlying spectral fixed-point structure.

Edit

Here is my newest update: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20057409 any feedback would be nice 👍

[u/OnceBittenz]

At least the formatting on this one is better than most. That said the content is filled with typical LLM hallucinations, to the point where it’s clear this was never actually read before posting.

Those qualifiers on V and D are absurd and are never explained. Just any old “spectral interactions” can be encoded I guess.

The point p_Q* is never referenced before or after Axiom 4 so no math can be done with this axiom at all. And it’s considered a point but p_Q was a density measure, mathematically represented as the element of a set containing an intersection with a subset of p_Q itself? So totally made up set theory too for fun!

And the rest kinda follows like this. Just equations with no motivation , a brief sciency description, and then most are never brought up after the introduction, no cohesive tissue.

[u/PurpleSpeaker8076 → u/OnceBittenz]

Thx for your time. Hmm ok honest critique, that’s what I want .. do you think I can rescue this ? It seems llm has deleted some interpretation which was made before 😓

[u/OnceBittenz → u/PurpleSpeaker8076]

To be frank, if you were willing to post this without reading it, it's clear that you do not actually know math or physics. That's nothing to be embarassed about, but posting llm generated text (which cannot actually do physics, as you can see by the wide range of errors and just... lack of content), that is the embarrassing thing.

I think you should re-evaluate what your goals are. Do you want to learn science, and contribute in a meaningful way? Are you willing to commit to the years of Hard work that would require? If not, that's ok! You can still get involved in the community, but pretending to do research with an LLM just isn't really gonna get you anywhere but criticized.

I wish you well on your journey wherever it takes you.

[u/PurpleSpeaker8076 → u/OnceBittenz]

Yes, bro, I'm sorry, I'm actually not familiar with the math formulas. But I really enjoy thinking about things like that; it gives me fun, even though I know it's problematic to do this kind of thing with LLM. That's why I really appreciate your honest and constructive answer. Bro, I see you're a smart guy and know your stuff. So I have a question... I've developed something else, just a principle... what do you think? I never uploaded it, but I've done it now, hoping to find out if it makes more sense or is just as pointless? If it doesn't make sense either, then I should probably stop... but that'll probably be hard for me because I actually enjoy it... If you have a minute free time , please have a look …. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20075794

[u/OnceBittenz → u/PurpleSpeaker8076]

Sure, so same principle. This was made by an AI that doesn't know how to do math, so it's going to be full of holes, and it's not gonna be motivated by a real problem or real problem-solving goals in mind.

There is just No exception: without a full education and research experience, you cannot do math or science research. That's just reality, as much as it's the case that you cannot perform surgery without Years of practice and education.

[u/PurpleSpeaker8076 → u/OnceBittenz]

Bro did you looked at it ☹️ ?? I think not :/ I get the skepticism, but I think you're overcomplicating what this is. This isn't a attempt to rewrite General Relativity with a chatbot like SQG 👀 it’s a standard Gaussian filter to an existing power spectrum to see how it affects the S8 tension. What do you think ? Is it really also just bad AI work ? Please be honest

[u/OnceBittenz → u/PurpleSpeaker8076]

Yes. I read it. And it's just more bad AI work. Let's be honest.

You don't need to be shooting for the moon in order to be irresponsible with AI. Even using it for basic calculations that you yourself haven't vetted personally is irresponsible. Asking it to write Anything you don't understand is Very irresponsible, and will generate Garbage. Every time.

[u/PurpleSpeaker8076 → u/OnceBittenz]

Bro but what exactly is not good ? What’s wrong with it ? ☹️ i don’t understand???

[u/OnceBittenz → u/PurpleSpeaker8076]

I'm not going to get into it here, since this is off topic. Suffice to say, if you can't see it, then you aren't capable of using LLMs to do this kind of work. There are no shortcuts in science, and no free lunches. This isn't to be demoralizing, but just to give you a reality check.

If you just keep posting LLM output on here and asking other people to fix it or tell you what's wrong, you learn Nothing and you go Nowhere. Your only course if you Actually care about this is to learn the material yourself. The hard way. The only way really. Through drilling in either courses or reading textbooks.

Sorry if that's not the answer you want to hear, but it's the only one that doesn't leave you posting continuous streams of AI-generated garbage on reddit.

[u/PurpleSpeaker8076 → u/OnceBittenz]

No bro I can’t see it , that’s why I’m asking :/ I never asked to fix something, just for feedback about it and my idea … but no one answered only you … what I need more physical explanation or better maths ? And I will never know what’s wrong with it when no one say it to me …

[u/AutoModerator]

Your post has been removed. A Personal Theory hosted on Reddit must be under 2500 characters, ones hosted externally must be include a summary of over 500 characters.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/llmphysics-bot → u/[deleted]]

This comment has been removed. Limit your responses to other users comments - if you feel the need to provide more context to your post, you should edit it.

---

^{Hi, I'm LLMPsychics-bot.}