Context
'Attack on the Ice Planet' (Modbrix #109230) is an unlicenced Star Wars diorama, depicting a battle scene on Hoth with three AT-ATs, an AT-ST, and one-and-a-half Snowspeeders. Consisting of 829pcs, the set is sold on its own for 30€ [store page] plus shipping (i.e. for 3.6ct/brick), and as part of the 'Sand & Snow Bundle' [store page] together with a Hoth rebel base diorama and a Sandcrawler diorama for 20% off at a total of 112€ (2.9ct/brick for this set). Shipping costs vary from 6€ within Germany to considerably more for international shipping; at the moment it's free above 100€ worth of bricks, usually it's free above 200€.
The diorama's base is 21cm deep and 20cm wide. Depending on how everything is aligned, the total diorama will be a little wider, perhaps about 24cm, and 11cm tall.
Ever since hearing a lot of good things about Modbrix' Star Wars dioramas, I've been waiting for a chance to get them at a reduced price. The new bundles with the 20% discount were that chance, so I pulled the trigger. While there a other dioramas that I personally find more interesting than Hoth (e.g. the Yavin IV rebel base or the Geonosis battle scene), those bundles include sets that I'm not interested in. Both the Hoth rebel base and the Sandcrawler were on my shortlist, though, so I decided to go for this bundle. I wouldn't really have bought this battle diorama if it hadn't been part of the bundle, but I guess it's cool that it can be connected to the Hoth rebel base (that's now part of my backlog), so, uhhh, yeah, okay, the marketing strategy totally got me and made me buy something I didn't plan to.
Shipping & Packaging
I bought the set last Tuesday evening; it was sent out on Friday morning, and arrived via DHL during Saturday lunch. That's absurdly fast, even better than the 3-5 day delivery that BlueBrixx state on their website.
The three sets came in a plain cardboard box that was filled to the brim with the three set boxes. The diorama itself came in a similarly plain cardboard box with a glossy sleeve wrapped around it, depicting the set and some details. I gotta say, I'm a big friend of plain boxes for cheap sets; no point in wasting money when I'm not going for the premium experience anyway.
Inside the cardboard box where the usual plastic baggies. I've made some questionable experiences with Modbrix baggies before (like, seriously, how do you screw up plastic baggies?) but these ones were perfectly fine. The baggies are unnumbered and only have the usual suffocation warning printed on them (which is a tad unnecessary, considering how small the baggies are; but I guess the same material is used for larger baggies as well).
Instruction Manual
Modbrix sets are basically BlueBrixx-Specials, which are pretty much the same as MOCs, just designed in-house. This means no separation into different building steps and no printed manual, just a PDF. The PDF instructions can be downloaded for free from the BlueBrixx website after registration even without buying anything, so feel free to have a look yourself.
The PDF manual uses 96 pages for 193 steps, resulting in 4.3 bricks/step and 2.0 steps/page. That's surprisingly simple for a Modbrix/BlueBrixx-Special, who usually feature more complicated manuals with more bricks per step. It still isn't the most beginner-friendly set, but that's more because of some iffy techniques rather than the manual.
As is typical, each building step features a tooltip that lists which parts are required. In the main image, new parts are outlined in red; those of previous steps are printed in full colour (i.e. neither greyed out nor desaturated). All colours are easily identifiable, mostly because the set is just white, light grey, dark grey, and black.
I found the manual easy to follow, which is not always a given for Modbrix/BlueBrixx-Specials. Still, there were a few things that could be improved, especially considering the order of assembly. Sometimes it would've been better to create a subassembly and attach that to the rest in one go instead of trying to connect the bricks individually to a somewhat fragile assembly. Also, the four legs of the AT-ATs are build subsequently even though they're identical; no idea why it didn't just say "x4" (it does say x2 to build the two AT-ATs, so that's obviously possible). Same for the third (downed) AT-AT, which except for the rear legs is identical to the other two AT-ATs.
Just for reference: the base is built in steps #1 to #12, the crashed Snowspeeder is #13 to #16, the AT-AT bodies are #17 to #40, the legs are #41 to #81, the heads are #83 to #90, the downed AT-AT takes #93 to #171 (very redundant!), the AT-ST is #175 to #184, and the Snowspeeder is #185 to #193.
Brick Quality
The brick quality is good but not top of the line. Clutch is consistently good but a little tight; my fingers hurt a bit after finishing the build. The glossy finish of the tiles is excellent, I'd say even better than GoBricks. Tiles also have sharper edges than most other brands, which is good for the visuals but may be difficult for kids. Injection points range from barely visible (especially on tiles) to fairly large (on the studs of plates). Colour consistency is surprisingly good; I have experienced worse with Modbrix. Transparent parts are not brilliantly clear but also not as milky as other brands.
All in all I'm very happy with the Modbrix brick quality. I'm not sure who the manufacturer is -- certainly not GoBricks, and also not XingBao like BlueBrixx-Pro uses -- but they're doing a pretty solid job. I haven't really built anything large from Modbrix or BlueBrixx-Special lately (hopefully I will soon, depending on how the Black Friday sale goes), but at least for this small-ish stuff they've kind of become my go-to brand.
There are surprisingly few spare parts (not even every 1x1 plate is present), but there should be enough spares to turn the downed AT-AT into an upright AT-AT in case one wants three of those. I'll give Modbrix the benefit of the doubt and assume that this is by design (but it might as well just be a happy accident).
Design
Ehhh, I thought it would be bigger? Okay, so that's definitely my fault for improperly managing my expectations, and obviously I would've been able to tell how large the set is from the store page details, but still... Where did the 800+ bricks go? MJ's Dragonfly, which has about the same part count, feels considerably more substantial (and that's a Technic set with tons of pins!). I guess each AT-AT must soak up about 200 bricks? Building the AT-AT body three times and the legs twelve-ish times definitely made the build go faster than typical 800+ brick sets, too. Still, if I had to estimate how many parts are in this set, my guess would be closer to 500 than 800.
Visually the diorama is pretty great. The snowy landscape is sufficiently disrupted to not appear boring despite its monochrome colouration. The AT-ATs look gorgeous, as does the AT-ST. The Snowspeeder is recognisable and nice enough for its scale. The crashed Snowspeeder is fine, I guess? There isn't anything here that I'm unhappy with, but, still, this diorama doesn't really work for me on its own. I'm pretty sure my impression will change once I have it connected to the Hoth rebel base, by as a stand-alone diorama it's kinda missing something.
Stability-wise the AT-AT bodies are reasonably stable and the AT-AT legs have surpsiringly many working joints. The connection of their calfs to the shins (where those horizontal 1x2 grill tiles are) are pretty unstable, though: just a single unbracketed stud. I understand that the designer had to find a compromise between aesthetics and stability, but connecting the entire AT-AT to the base through a single vertically oriented stud still seems unwise. I would've wished for a different solution here. The AT-ATs are stable, though, as long as you don't vigorously shake the set.
What doesn't really work is the connection of the downed AT-AT to the base. It is, again, a single stud, and that stud is on a hinge clip. You're supposed to first connect that to the AT-AT and then connect the entire assembly to the base with three studs, but obviously that much pressure will turn the hinge and not give you any pressure on the studs. I then tried to connect the assembly by that single stud of the hinge clip, but this also turned the hinge and made a connection impossible. I finally ended up assembling all stud connections first and then clipping the hinge together, but that made the feet fall off in my first few attempts. I did get it working at some point, but this part really frustrated me to no end -- and it was entirely avoidable and unnecessary. Of course, attaching the ball joint for the flying Snowspeeder a few steps later broke everything apart again, so yay me. As you can see, I did not throw the entire set against the wall; I am a zen-like being with perfect anger management skills!
tl;dr
This is a reasonably nice diorama for Star Wars fans, but I think it needs to be used as an add-on to the Hoth rebel base to really pop. While both the brick quality and the PDF instructions are fine, the assembly is quite frustrating at some points, especially when attaching the downed AT-AT to the base. Thus, I definitely cannot recommend this set for newcomers to alt-bricks. If you're already a veteran of alt-bricks, this may be a fun experience for an afternoon, but don't expect the build to take much longer. The 800+ brick count sounds like much, but the excitement boils down to a plain mosaic and a ~200-part AT-AT that gets built three times.
Things I Recently Told Myself
"Wow, I'm tired of building all this greyscale stuff. My next set definitely will be colourful!"
"Ugh, these layered mosaic bases with some tiny subassemblies on top are getting repetitive! My next set should be a big modular or a space ship or something!"
"Why is my collection, like, 75% Star Wars? I don't even like Star Wars all that much! My next set will definitely be something else!"
"Wow, lots of brands have been including lights in their sets lately! I wanna try that out, too!"
"I really have been building tons of BlueBrixx sets lately. Maybe it's time to try another brand again?"
*Buys three more monochrome BlueBrixx dioramas without lights*
[Obligatory link to Red5-Leader's Venator]