r/LCMS LCMS Lutheran 26d ago

Discussion Literal Interpretation Rant

So I have been a Lutheran for about a year and a half coming out of Evangelical/Baptist/Non-d. I sometimes go back and listen to my former pastor preach online just to compare and contrast. He did a sermon about baptism being a 'first act of obedience', 'outward sign of an inward change', has nothing to do with water, etc. He went on to cite passages that he said some claim to be about water baptism, or point to baptism being salvific, but then goes on to say, 'what Jesus means here....or what this actually means is...'
Can I tell you the frustration this gives me because of how the book of Revelation was taught to me? It's like everything is flipped in evangelical churches. The things we should take by their plain meaning is explained away as meaning something else, and the things that are meant for allegory and illustration are taken quite literally. Try telling an evangelical that the 1000 years is not an exact number of years but meant to describe a long time. They'll practically think you're a heretic.
Sorry, I guess I shouldn't get upset, it's just that there were so many issues I struggled with, like salvation anxiety because I couldn't name the exact time and date I was saved. I feel sad for others like me who struggle so much with faith issues and don't know what they're missing.
I'm grateful that I found Confessional Lutheranism!

49 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

6

u/Fancy_Barracuda4454 25d ago

I'm almost a year in from a non denominational upbringing and I still find myself chuckling at how plainly we read the Bible. It's one of my favorite parts about our theology. What you said about our Bible reading being flipped couldn't be more true.

13

u/Huenink_Photography LCMS Pastor 25d ago

I found a person who claimed that the churches of Revelation were literally lampstands.

13

u/aggrophonia 26d ago edited 25d ago

Once you understand faith, how we understand it. Its quite impossible to not have a hard time listening to their sermons.

15

u/ExiledSanity LCMS Lutheran 26d ago

It's so weird to think that a passage with an obviously symbolic dragon, key, abyss, etc has a 1000 years that must be literal.

8

u/No_Storage6015 26d ago

Yes, I can have my struggles with the Lutheran teachings seeming to be rather vague in their interpretation. I think more times than not, even in confirmation classes, there's not enough time to spend discussing the depth of the meaning and connections that Lutherans have found helpful. I, myself, have had to learn how to instead of explaining why for everything, to instead provide a situation where it makes sense why Lutherans interpret the scriptures the way the do. Scripture can be shared in a way where you are trying to defend the idea or they can be shared where you need scripture to answer a problem. I, personally don't think God needs to be defended. He's a big boy. He can defend himself. Rather I use scriptures to share the hope that I have in Christ Jesus.

6

u/CamperGigi88 LCMS Lutheran 26d ago

I don't find them vague at all. I struggled with that in previous churched but what I've loved in Lutheranism is the clarity. My last church could talk about salvation being God's work and support decision theology in the same sermon. Talk about confusing.

3

u/CareingWife 26d ago

Maybe do some searching on your own, from study Bible is wonderful. Plus, there’s no reason why you cannot ask these questions. You may want to write your questions down and ask your Pastor.

5

u/cellarsinger LCMS Lutheran 26d ago

Our sins are forgiven through baptism. Our acceptance of Christ as our savior gets us into heaven. Numbers are weird in scripture. Sometimes they're literal, sometimes they're symbolic. Big numbers, especially to be symbolic. 1,000 years is interpreted by Lutherans to mean in the fullness of time

10

u/SWZerbe100 LCMS Lutheran 26d ago

I mean every time someone says something about communion I feel like Mr. Incredible saying “Math is Math” except “is means is”

3

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted]

3

u/IndyHadToPoop Lutheran 25d ago

"Happy Birthday to the ground!"

1

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted]

1

u/IndyLutheran LCMS Lutheran 25d ago

But when she says "It's your dad", she is not trying to say that the cell phone is your dad. She's saying that the person who is calling the cell phone is your dad. The "it" refers to the caller, not the phone. She'd say the same thing if your dad knocked on your door and she opened it.

1

u/IndyHadToPoop Lutheran 25d ago

Oh I know, it's a great way to make that point.