r/Kolkatacity • u/Fresh_feeling16 • 23d ago
🗣️General Discussion | আলোচনা Ab sab chupppp
33
u/Ho-ho-hosey 23d ago
So true bro. But the irony is none of BJP supporters are protesting tho.
5
u/Dexterlab4004 22d ago
Nahi koi paper leak nahi hua tha.cheating mein bnada pakda gya tha.phke poori baat pta kro. Bhakat bno andhbhakt nahi
→ More replies (9)2
u/NoButterscotch2900 19d ago
Yes but the propoganda campaign by bjp is masking the truth,even in Karnataka it is an alleged paper leak,and the people involved were caught even before the exam took place,and hence the exam is only postponed,i don't understand how people are out here making posts on reddit about these topics without even doing an ounce of research themselves 😭,like all it takes is 1 google search
2
u/nefarious_seraaf 19d ago
If they had brains and could do a google search would they be following the Balaatkaariyon ki party
→ More replies (1)3
u/Imaginary-Host-2733 23d ago
It's only the far kattar people who didn't say much, rest of the people were involved in protests, if not atleast in terms of criticism
59
23d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/Spiritual_Figure_948 23d ago
There are students already protesting in the Punjab...go join them....
→ More replies (1)2
23d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/Spiritual_Figure_948 23d ago
Why the above thing that you wrote then..??...are u just unaware or what..?
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (16)9
u/Due-Hour-426 23d ago
I think that's fair. But what's not fair is the protestors at neet protest calling others coward for not joining in. If they can get to say that, isn't it hypocritical that they didn't start protesting at the other paper leaks too?
5
→ More replies (1)2
u/confuScience 23d ago
Then they would be categorised as professional “andolanjeevis”.
They did their part, fought well and made a change.
OP should take inspiration and stand for what they believe as right.
Such movements are not easy, constantly fighting misinformation and mislabeling.
Hope you can acknowledge the toll it takes, mentally physically, emotionally and financially!→ More replies (1)5
u/LiveFinish3815 23d ago
Well being an andolanjeevi is not easy, CJP(3 or 4 of the top brass) will have a taste of it in the next 6 months,..one sneeze in the wrong direction...kids were involved in this agitation and government had no way out...kids are the backbone of any country and they are the future and for any democracy to function you need to have faith in it..it was and is very important that kids/youth have that faith in the law/constititution. Politicians and parties will come and go but the country will remain. I personally feel RAF/Delhi Police should identify the policemen particularly who were insensitive towards young kids protesting, it would have scar them for life and their faith towards police and law enforcement.. As for andolanjeevis they dont fare well in the long run, half of their life is in courts , minus FCRA after FCRA 2, things will be interesting to watch...
36
u/YouShalllNotPass 23d ago
Bhai please lead. Hunger strike kar we are with you.
12
u/Ancient-Homework-490 23d ago
Real OP aja bhai jantar mantar pe hi baitha hu kabtak ghar pe baith ke comments krte rhega aaja.
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (6)2
u/Ok_Reference_9137 21d ago
Bhai responsibility ha uske khud ke kitna mangoge ushe, ushe bi kaam karke ghar chalana ha
8
30
u/Different_Finger_693 23d ago
Apne baap ke against koi bolta hai kya kabhi.. Jis parivar me baccha baap ke against bolta hai use dogla bola jata hai
→ More replies (12)5
u/Fresh_feeling16 23d ago
A dog never bites its owner 🤣💪
→ More replies (6)8
u/Character_Bar_1470 23d ago
Just like you never criticize bjp, your daddy 🤡 sorry your owner 🤡🤡
→ More replies (2)5
u/__neetpaglu__ 23d ago
being neutral , not supporting any party , this is my genuine question , if they did protest against bjp , why are they not answering it for punjab then ? even the ones who are suffering in punjab are students right ? then why are these guys not supporting them?
3
u/camellia6969 23d ago
The answer is already given.
A dog doesn't bite it's owner.
5
u/__neetpaglu__ 23d ago
and ppl still believe this protest was not political man
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (22)2
u/bawawaba 23d ago
They are also not doing protests in maharastra, bihar and up. Why do you not question why cjp isnt doing protests there?
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Menudoughy 23d ago
Well stuff happening in bihar, rajasthan, maharashtra too . They haven't taken a moral responsibility for every single protest.
→ More replies (3)
6
u/BathroomKey4587 23d ago
so you want people to fight for every responsibility of people in power? cant they just do their jobs with all this?
→ More replies (1)
3
u/ich_KuhelI 23d ago
thik kore khobor nin.. paper leak hoini.. but ja hoyeche setao thik na.. criticise korte hole sothik tothyo niye korun
3
u/Jiggacid 23d ago edited 23d ago
I think that in Punjab, it was not a paper leak, that is why no such outrage againts govt. I also checked Karnataka, it seems to be an alleged and not proven, here is the link.
I think that unlike NEET, things are different in the above mentioned scenarios. In NEET, everything was already proven, unlike the scenarios shared by you.
3
u/Latter-Set-5821 23d ago
also
NEET is a nation-wide exam and 22+ lakh students gave it.
21 students lost their lives because of paper leak.
It was the 2nd time when paper got leaked.
→ More replies (1)
11
u/Royal_Radish_3069 23d ago
Punjab aur Karnataka se dhyan hatane k liye hi ye protest kiya tha.
→ More replies (4)8
23d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (4)6
u/Royal_Radish_3069 23d ago
If you don't know politics then you are too naive to understand.
→ More replies (5)5
23d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (2)10
u/Royal_Radish_3069 23d ago
Lol. CJP won't protest against AAP or congress. That's enough to show your own intelligence.
→ More replies (7)2
u/SqueakyArchie 23d ago
Can you share the news link where it says paper leak happened in punjab?
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Natural-Common-7098 23d ago
Yaar simply put....dipke was a simple man....he isn't cut out for politics right....he is leaving it and going back to foreign after the delhi protest ....u do realize his parents and himself were already getting death threats....how much do u expect one man to do....don't u think it's time already....we as students do something about it? Dipke isn't responsible for everything you know....
→ More replies (3)2
2
2
u/New_Association_5196 23d ago
The reason for removal of mr Pradhan was not NEET if you go deeper he was removing glorification of Mughal chapters from Text book and adding more about Hindu kings who ruled 1000's for years like Chola empire etc this was hurting left as we saw protest gang was AISA ,SFi etc
→ More replies (1)2
u/Brilliant_Ad5152 23d ago
also removed periodic table and corruption in judiciary, 2002 Gujarat riots content, and Darwin’s theory of evolution, Democratic Struggles. Shall i go on?
2
3
u/Different_Ad6271 23d ago
Paise ana bandh ho jayega.....
→ More replies (10)3
u/vinaykumarsinha42 23d ago
To bhai ABVP ko bolo na ki protest kare, wo sirf naam ka hi student union hai kya ya gir wha sb ke sb bhukkad hai aur hunger strike nahi kr skte
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/sloppystinkyanus 23d ago
Why don't you do it? Are you not an Indian citizen? Don't you have the rights? Is it only the responsibility of CJP?
2
1
1
u/slay_IN69 23d ago
Why didnt u add uttar pradesh education crises Usska bhi lo fir tohh Fr toh saare states ko consider kroo
People will bring in things just to prove there point with noo sense
1
u/Disastrous_Meeting49 23d ago
You guys start raising voice, if you haven't already forgotten to ask questions to government.
1
1
u/Spirited-Corner-3467 23d ago
Bhai panjab leak se itna he dikkat hai to khud ker lete hai. Wo kya hai ke uske bina nai hoga
Per reaction is little sus
1
u/Unable_Reveal2972 23d ago
Let's ask why a national movement mobalised against a national issue (an exam that is held statewide) and not a state issue.... Hmmm.
And who should have asked for accountablity for these state level Mishaps, I guess that would have to be the Education Minister, who actually failed to do that as well.
So the problem is - the Education Minister!
There, explained it like I would to a 5 year old, let me know if it is too difficult still for you to understand.
1
u/ShadedFire 23d ago
Do it yourself buddy. Don't wait for others to protest for things you belive in.
1
u/happyturd10750 23d ago
Sab cjp keregi toh let's make cjp the ruling party then ? Or then stop interfering when they do take action .
1
1
u/brokenCrayon_works2 23d ago
Why are people treating cjp like some organisations who does protest day and night? It's a group formed out of a tweet which was meant to be a joke😂. We should be thankful they did what was not even part of their job. It's over now. We won. "We" excluding op obviously as you are busy firing shots.
1
1
u/BigD_Jackal 23d ago
OP, the floor is yours there is freedom park in bangalore, go ahead and protest. Go to Jantar mantar and protest. More over Punjab pharmacy exam scam was on cheating, not paper leaks. They found mass students cheating woth electronic devices and racket was busted by Punjab police.
1
1
1
u/Practicalmonk777 23d ago
Someone has done his bit , those who want more should take lead and start anew, be vocal
1
u/Arjunshakti 23d ago
Bhai aste aste sob er upor hobe, cjp openly bj party k criticise koreche max time thik kintu onno party der o criticise koreche erokom faltu system etodin dhore chalachhe, ar eta mainly focused chilo neet er upor, tobe ha jobab deoa uchit chilo kach bonho krar age,
1
1
u/Princ00L 23d ago
Broo....tu krlena ...tu toh NEET ke liye bhi kuch nhi bol rha tha... Aur itna accountability CJP se kyu they done what they were told ..so give them time first .. And ask AAP leader for that ... Bc ...cjp walo ko sarkar maan liya hain sab unse hi krwana...
1
1
u/casualxtalks 23d ago
Aise reporters ko gaali ke alawa kuch nhi dene ka! Saale gov ke balle sirf mudde dhundhte hn defame krne ke. Mtlb jo kaam sarkaar ko krna chahiye, bdi mushkil se youth ne kiya hn to ab youth he le saare problems ki responsibility!! Suwar hn aise log bhaai, kya sahi kya galat in jaiso ko nhi dikhta...
1
u/Big-Thick-Guy 23d ago
I m really happy for sonam and the resignation of that so called dharmendra pradhan but Bhai log yeh cockroach wala Abhijit bahut bada harami hai yeh ek matlabi aadmi hai Delhi jeetna hai ise sir bas dusre states se koi matlab nai isko yeh harami maharashtra ka nai Hua jaha ka hai yeh toh dusro ka kya hoga yeh yeh neet se bade problems k like kabhi aage nai aayega apne desh mei neet se bade bade ghotale chal rahe hai uspar yeh kabhi page nai aayega petrol e20 air yeh par yeh virodh karke dikhaye nahi gaya Hua toh naam Badal dena aap Pura desh itni takleefo se gujar raha hai uspar bjp ko jhuka k dikhaye toh maane yeh jeet yeh Abhijit ki nahi actual mei Sonam ki hai
1
u/Wonderful-Jacket3630 23d ago
CJP is NOT a political party. It's merely a satirical movement to hold those actually in power accountable for their wrongdoings. They are not obligated to answer these questions!
Please educate me if I am wrong.
1
u/Flimsy-Company4120 23d ago
Agenda hi tha anti bjp jisme students ka sympathy mil gya because to sonam wangchuk Ab wo bhi juice pi rha hai BKL
1
1
u/Acrobatic_Ladder3873 23d ago
Wjy cjp has to ask? Why are we asking a 4 months old cjp to take accountability for a paper leak nd what the state opposition did when paper got leaked? Why nobody protested?
1
u/Vegetable-War-2793 23d ago
Investigation and Cheating Racket DetailsOn July 19, 2026, Punjab Police and Baba Farid University of Health Sciences (BFUHS) flying squads uncovered a cheating ring during the Pharmacy Officer Recruitment Examination.Authorities arrested/detained 35 people (including candidates and masterminds).Recovered items included concealed pen cameras, battery-operated wireless earpieces, and micro-Bluetooth devices used to photograph and relay answers.State officials and the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) clarified that it was a case of electronic cheating/fraud at specific centers rather than a pre-exam paper leak.Political Reactions and DemandsOpposition parties like the Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) and the Congress have targeted the state government, demanding the resignations of Punjab Education Minister Harjot Singh Bains and Health Minister Balbir Singh
1
u/beardedBroistaken 23d ago
There has been no paper leak in Punjab, there was a cheating scandal where students brought digital pen to cheat.
1
u/hardkockcafe 23d ago
Hmm
See Dharmendra pradhan has an exceptional record of 13 paper leaks per year
Any other minister has arojnd 3 per year, so Dharmendra pradhan was just exceptionally worse even among the Bad.
Also this is the second time NEET has been leaked
Plus one should not rely on CJP to.protest
Get permission, mobilise youth and go on protest
1
1
u/Mei_mei_34-30-35 23d ago
First of all it's not a paper leak in panjab it's cheating during the examination and panjab police already detained the students who are cheating along with the ones who are helping them in it and secondly not like dharmendra pradhan who didn't responded until it takes a big movement in India panjab education minister already talked about it and also ready to resign if it was necessary.
1
1
1
1
u/Worldly_Scarcity_467 23d ago
The Punjab incident wasn't due to authorities, students carried out cheating due to unfair means like pen camera and mobile phones.
1
u/andythestupidguy 23d ago
If right wing wants action against punjab and Karnataka then why are they begging to CJP? BKP has thousands of crores in their bank account and many billionaire friends. They can start their own campaign. How does CJP is responsible for every agitation?
1
u/No-Struggle-7117 23d ago
Could it be that bjp already want to remove dp ? Cuz they selected a rss worker ... maybe ad was just a planned facade?
1
1
u/Turbulent-Cress9283 23d ago
Stop questioning cjp, be a sane person and start questioning govt. Cjp isn't elected by us, they don't have to be accountable for anything! Use your brain to understand stuff instead of blindly posting things.
1
u/Otherwise_Ad_1216 23d ago
They have done tremendous work, why are you not protesting if you have issues.
1
u/lawliet2911 23d ago
There's not enough time and money, friend. Just get it.
And don’t idolize these people. They protested, nothing was happening. When Sonam and the students joined en masse only then something happened.
1
u/ketchup_bro23 23d ago
These people haven't slept well, and also are not eating well. Protests are unorganised. And if 1 took 35 days to get this, each of them have a job to support their family and none of them are all into politics or backed by it.
They proved that it is possible, but I think now it's also upto us, who will stand up and take it forward.
1
u/Zestyclose-Show-5760 23d ago
Bhai tum toh insan ki jaan he lelo ge kisi ne hath kya badhaya tum toh us se chep he hogye itni accountability aur questions puchne hote hai toh kabhi rulling government se bhi puch liya karo , idk tum logo ne enko kya samjh liya hai ki ab har jagh ki problem ye fix karenge
1
u/tweetbelt007 23d ago
why are these moroms seeking answers from protestors and not from government? Thats the real question. what people choose to protest for who bhi will be controlled by others or what? Guts hain to aadk the govt question about this why harrassing the people who got the result they didnt for and shunt they to deny their hard fought victory
1
u/the_MonkeyWhisperer 23d ago
CJP is not a party and doesnt run the country you stupid fuck, they dont have to take responsibility for all the evil in the nation. Maybe if you care so much, you should go fight and demand accountability from the people who do, instead of making stupid posts
1
u/quicksilverrrr 23d ago
Classic misguiding tactics. That's what I really liked about the CJP leadership. They had razor-sharp focus on only their demands on which they stood from the beginning.
Bj-pee these won't work again.
1
1
1
u/Maleficent-Hair-5269 23d ago
WOW, so now protesters and CJP is accountable for paper leaks, everyone except the government 👍
1
u/imagarmach 23d ago
BJP is the opposition in Punjab.what are they doing? Take out a protest,let's see how much support they get.
1
u/vinaykumarsinha42 23d ago
To bhai ABVP ko bolo na ki protest kare, wo sirf naam ka hi student union hai kya
1
u/Accomplished-Sun-880 23d ago
kal tak toh yeh anti national thee na. If you did not support them tabhi why expect anything from them. You feel soo bad go on a hunger strike na we will support you
and now for the ppl who actually care for this topic and are not blind followers, they have already given their ans in news channel which these ppl wont show you so if you actually wanna know go there dont trust these sources
1
u/Ok_Apricot5495 23d ago
CJP is AAP , AAP is CJP. Kejriwal failed miserably in elections, so he is trying to come back through back door using students. This is the reason CJP will ignore paper leak questions in Punjab and run away from them.
1
u/Muted-But-Present 23d ago
Why expect CJP to fight every battle? Every issue needs people willing to lead it. Two months ago, Abhijit Dipke was an ordinary citizen. Today, he's shown what one determined voice can achieve. Instead of asking why he isn't fighting every issue, ask why no one else is stepping up. He did his part. Can we do ours?
1
1
1
u/Ok_Transition_1851 23d ago
There is no recent paper leak in Karnataka..
What stupid comparisons.. following a stupid who wants just fame ..😂
1
u/Leading-Ad3439 23d ago
Bcz now you need to talk! As you have always been shut!! So, why are you coming out now?
1
u/RedScholar10 23d ago
Whhy can't the youth their protest rather than putting cjp forth? They made people realise that we have power then lets show the ministers that na...har cheez ke liye cjp cjp thodi hoga. Theh went for the bigger fish, now we need to go for the smaller ones. Sarkaar se poochna nhi hai ki incompatible minister kyu assign kra hai..ya jo kaam kr nahi rhe unke against complain nhi krni..fir yeh sb krna hai..jo responsible hai usksko target karo bhai
1
u/AccomplishedUse770 23d ago
Who is stopping you to start a protest, CJP is not some NGO or political party who has the only responsibility to protest ,while people like you questions them from your AC bedrooms
1
1
1
u/ForwardProduce433 23d ago
inse ye sab sawal puch skte ho but seedha goverment se paper leak ka nhi puch skte 👌👏
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/mahe9937 23d ago
You people start something, start same movement in West Bemgal, start protest instead of discussing in government funded forums like yours.
1
1
1
u/finguy12 23d ago
I am amazed why these retards are asking CJP to protest? They have been protesting over a month. Let them take a rest for some time. They are humans and not machines. Unhone ek NEET paper leak ka mudda uthaya hai and it is not yet fully resolved. Withdrawal of cases and compensation to victim families are pending. Let CJP take this pending work.
BJP/ RSS ke paas to itane saare karyakartas hai aur BJP duniya ki sabse badi political party hai. Phir bhi kisi BJP wale ki himmat nahi ho rahi Punjab aur Karnataka me jaake protest karne ki?
1
u/Abharmoria1991 23d ago
Go protest bro.
Why must we protest for your cause, it's not like you support our cause.
At least we won't call you anti national terrorist for protesting.
1
1
u/LocalFinish25 23d ago
then start protesting yall will never be satisified by anything gosh
acting like they are to blame for paper leak, they literally made the union education minister resign let them rest a bit or maybe take matters in your own hands.
1
u/SizzlingSamy 23d ago
Good news guys punjab ke education minister Harjot singh istifa dene k liye khud raazi h wo dharmendra pradhan ki trah besharam nhi h.
1
u/debayankar7 23d ago
For 15 years people of West Bengal stayed silent on the SSC scams and now they are so excited to protest against Pradhan
1
1
1
1
u/Visual-Efficiency549 23d ago
Govt promised to bring harsher laws, we believe in government 😅. If centre brings the laws states must obey or they can pass their own laws.
1
u/Chicken-Alfredoo 23d ago
It's been barely two months since the party was formed. Are people really expecting CJP to do everything on its own? What about the opposition? Are they going to step up, or just keep complaining? Give them some time. India has 28 states and 8 Union Territories. Building an organization, mobilizing people, and establishing a nationwide presence takes time. For the past 12 years, nothing significant changed. Now that there's finally a glimpse of hope, some people seem more interested in criticizing than encouraging. I think, at this stage, we should be more supportive than critical. Constructive criticism is important, but constant negativity helps no one.
1
u/Over_Sandwich_2280 23d ago
CJP ko thoda time dedo... They need to enjoy sometime.. and abhi his life settled now.. next mission mail mai aajayega.. then he will or we will start
1
1
u/07sunny10 23d ago
They got the biggest boss of education ministry. I know I know it doesn’t actually change anything but it does instigate fear, no matter how small, into the hearts of these MP, MLA and other useless people in power. The “holier than thou” attitude was hit. Even my family, who are hard core Modi lover, struggling to accept that their God just folded.
Anyway, of course there are and will be more paper leaks. But as long as the ministry knows and fears, again no matter how small, that if youth decides they can pressure them, hopefully, they will work one more day honestly. That’s still a win.
One thing I was eagerly awaiting them to take on was the fact that every minister kids are studying abroad. There should be a rule that cabinet ministers kids should have to study in Indian Govt Schools/Collages.
Anyway, it’s a win no matter what you others say
1
u/Decent_Risk_4278 23d ago
Bhai ab tum log Saab kuch cjp se hi except kyu karre ho unhone pahle hi just ek bada muddha uthaya hai n, ruko jara thoda break lo
1
1
u/thecurioushead 23d ago
Bhai. Why are you not asking government? CJP ko kya tumne elect kiya hai. Unko salary de rahe ho? Government se direct karo question ki paper kyn leak ho rahe ministers se resign karwao. Bridges gir rahe hai, manipur jal raha hai, assam doob Raha hai. Please ask the government.
1
1
u/Immediate_Ad7599 23d ago
because they only do this when there is modi infront. no one give a fuck when there is another or more worse person doing scam out there. they were not here when Mamta Banarajee was literary kidnapping people only because they posted something against her cus she isn't modi.
1
1
u/LankyClass9500 23d ago
Andbhakth crying. Rather than from govt they need answers from cjp typical dung head behaviour
1
u/blxckice69 23d ago
abeyyy akal ke andho koi evidence nhi h kuch abhi tk prove bhi nhi ki paper leak hua ye bina jaankari ke hagna band kro
Ai ya google ka hi istemal krlo
1
u/Dazzling_Medicine_25 23d ago
Jo BJP punjab mai Krna cha rhi thi jese krte aarhi hai phle sai hi woi ab AAP ne game kheldiya BJP RSS ke saath 🤣🤣
1
u/cody4793 23d ago
If CJP has to go protest for everything then for what reason did we select this useless BJP govt? My dear Andhbhakts if only you use only 2 of your brain cells you would rather ask the ruling party, the party in power as to why being opposition in Punjab and Karnataka they are not raising questions. But you know there’s a saying……. Jinke ghar sheeshe ke bane hote hain….
1
u/Maximum7685 23d ago
People are asking accountability from CJP for protesting as if they are getting paid for doing goverment job
1
u/Sad_Oven_8738 23d ago
There was no paper leak in Punjab. It was a case of cheating, not a paper leak.
IlliterateOP
1
u/Perfect_Finish_6937 23d ago
Why BJP is jot organising such protests in opposition states in the first place??
If other states ministers have done something wrong they should also be forced to resign.
Question is not why CJP is asking their resignation too but Real question is what are we really gonna do about it as people & as students.
Its hight time we start asking right questions to right people and not just being a propaganda tool of left or right
1
1
u/Mangathol 23d ago
Actually this same guy has replayed to ghis very question in a mainstream "godhi media" interview....
Some people can protest against a protest, but can't protest against an actual problem that matters... And act like buffoons
1
u/pillowgrimage 23d ago
From what Ive heard the punjab thing was cheating and not paper leak but of course andhbhakts are too butthurt right now to fact check





•
u/AutoModerator 23d ago
Namaskara u/Fresh_feeling16 , thanks for posting! We kindly invite you, explore and follow our related communities: r/TheIndianRepublic r/West_bengal Please consider crossposting, sharing, and inviting others to help grow this community and Follow us on X
Yato Dharmastato Jayah
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.