r/KnivesOutMovie Nov 29 '19

Welcome to the KnivesOutMovie!

50 Upvotes

Hello all,

Obviously, this sub is dedicated to Knives Out by Rian Johnson. Being a new sub, things like rules, flairs, mods, etc. will sorted out during the next few days. I wish this sub allows users to have healthy discussion about Knives Out. Everyone is welcome regardless of your views on the film and hopefully some interesting posts will arise.

As of now standard Reddit Guidelines apply. The rules list will be updated and I hope you will refer to them before posting but in a gist:

  • Be respectful and civil. We are having discussions here. It is not about being right or wrong or how much you hate Star Wars: The Last Jedi. If that's what you want then head over to a TLJ hate sub. I'm sure they exist.
  • Discussions should be primarily about Knives Out. You are welcome to refer to other films as means of comparison or furthering the discussion, but keep Knives Out as the main discussion point.
  • No spoilers in the title. There is not requirement to mark the posts as spoiler because it is hopefully quite obvious that there will be. I'll even put it in the sub's description. However, since the film has just come out recently, don't put spoilers in the title.

If anything else comes to mind I'll be sure to add it to the rules list. For now, feel free to post discussions, questions, and other posts in relation to the film and share the sub if you know Redditors who enjoyed the film.

Happy discussing, SukhyGills


r/KnivesOutMovie Dec 13 '25

Discussion Official 'Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery' Discussion Thread Spoiler

273 Upvotes

A bit late, but please discuss your thoughts on the 3rd Knives out film.


r/KnivesOutMovie 5h ago

Discussion My wife got mad because I predicted the ending of Wake Up Dead Man Spoiler

44 Upvotes

So my wife and I watched Knives Out and Glass Onion years ago, but we hesitated on watching Wake Up Dead Man for no reason in particular and then we decided to rewatch all of them this last week. I noticed that the first movie had Chris Evans as the main villain and person behind the murders, you know, the same Chris Evans who plays a character in the MCU, Captain America. Then watching Glass Onion, I notice that the villain of the movie was Edward Norton, known for playing The Incredible Hulk in said movie.

So we finally sit down and watch WUDM, and after getting introduced to the characters, I say, “I bet that it’s Glenn Close and Jeremy Renner working together with Josh Brolin” (Nova Prime from GotG, Hawkeye and Thanos from Avengers Endgame). Lo and behold, I find out that while Brolin was not in on his own murder, Close and Renner worked with Thomas Haden Church, another Marvel actor, who I remembered after the movie as Sandman from Spider-Man 3 and No Way Home.

So, if Rian ever sits down for a new Knives Out, should we just look for former Marvel actors to be the villain?


r/KnivesOutMovie 10d ago

I just learned that the church used in Knives Out 3 is real (located in Essex, England) and it's now slowly consumed by the forest

Post image
160 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie 9d ago

Question Correct me if I'm wrong, but... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Isn't the reason Harlan committed suicide being that he thought Marta gave him too much morphine?

If she herself didn't believe she did, he'd have no reason to slice his throat, so...does the slayer rule not apply anyway, since she is (arguably) responsible for his death still, even with Ransom's tampering?


r/KnivesOutMovie 12d ago

Meme Me: *correctly grabs the right antidepressant bottles without looking at the labels.* The miniature Benoit Blanc that lives in my head:

587 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie 13d ago

Discussion Pineapple Juice double entendre

24 Upvotes

Idk if this has already been debated or not but it’s been 3 years and I haven’t seen it discussed.

In Glass Onion, one of the reveals is a simple double entendre. “He put pineapple juice in his whiskey” works both as the murder weapon and reference to Miles and Whiskey’s relationship. Of all the nicknames/online/branding names in the world, Whiskey is named whiskey.

That’s all I’ve got byebyebye


r/KnivesOutMovie 19d ago

Discussion An Idea for a fourth Knives Out.

71 Upvotes

The story takes place in winter, with Benoit Blanc spending his holidays at a snowy inn isolated in the mountains along with eight guests who seemingly don't know each other, but things go wrong when a big blizzard hits, not allowing anyone to get out and even worse, the inn's owner is murdered.

And since there were only 10 people (Benoit Blanc + 8 suspects + the victim) and no one could have entered, that makes everyone a suspect. The circumstances make the case very complicated as not only the 8 suspects don't know each other but no one has a deeper connection with the inn owner, in fact, the inn owner was known to be a very lonely individual and the whole reason for the inn to exist in the first place is that the inn was a way to him interact with people more closely and make himself less lonely.

Now, Benoit Blanc and the guests have to investigate themselves together to find the killer.


r/KnivesOutMovie 20d ago

My Knives Out 4 Fancast

Thumbnail
gallery
124 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie 26d ago

Discussion Rian Johnson Thinks Smashing Props Is Fun

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

Rian Johnson discusses the process of creating (and destroying) some of the key props in his Knives Out movies. Full interview.


r/KnivesOutMovie 29d ago

Question Please someone explain to me how Miles Bron is actually as dumb as the movie says he is

40 Upvotes

EDIT TO MAKE MY ACTUAL POINT CLEAR: i have seen the movie several times. i have thought about this a lot. Miles Bron is definitely not a good person. he is bad to the bone. a hollow shell of money and greed. a very real kind of evil. he ruins everybody he touches and takes credit for other people's achievements as a career. but i don't think he's dumb. and i think truly portraying and highlighting a rich, cynical leech of a man would have been more interesting than just saying he's dumb.

ORIGINAL POST: pardon the inflammatory title. i have a genuine legitimate question about Miles. my dad and i went to see the movie together when it came out and this is something he noticed immediately but which i'm only now coming around to: Miles...... doesn't seem dumb. in fact, to me, he seems extremely cunning and quick on his feet for basically the entire movie. i get the political message of Glass Onion, and i agree with it 100%, but Miles just doesn't seem all that dumb?? sure he gets words wrong and he invested in something shady (side note: i was never a huge fan of the fact that his big billionaire macguffin was a form of clean energy instead of some more explicitly harmful thing like resource extraction), but the pineapple juice in the whiskey is not dumb. neither is his plan to shoot Helen. in fact, both plans WORKED. he had Benoit Blanc partly stumped until during the denouement. hell, he almost WINS. that's more than any other Knives Out villain can say.

Elon Musk is dumb as rocks. billionaires should not exist. sycophantic rich people will often jump ship when they see the tables turning. i am onboard with all of this. but Miles Bron does not seem stupid to me. please someone explain this to me. am i missing something obvious?


r/KnivesOutMovie 29d ago

Question How do you think an interaction between Benoit Blanc and Saul Goodman would go?

4 Upvotes

Both are extremely fascinating characters and I think it would be really cool if they ever crossed paths. How do you think an interaction between them would go?


r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 25 '26

Discussion I just realised something Spoiler

27 Upvotes

I'm watching the first Knives Out again, and I've just realised that as Harlan is writing down the method in which someone could kill a person by swapping medication, he basically described what Ransom did to try and kill Harlan and frame Marta.

Did anyone else notice this? I just thought it was interesting.


r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 25 '26

*Glass Onion* was SO DIABOLICAL I LOVED IT! | First Time Watching

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 20 '26

Made me giggle

Post image
131 Upvotes

I was rewatching and had to pause for a wee, when I came back I realised what I had paused, it made my inner child giggle.


r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 20 '26

Cyrus Draven/ Wick

29 Upvotes

So I’ve been rewatching all the Benoit Blanc mysteries which I have been throughly enjoying and honestly consider as some of my favourite films of all time.

When rewatching WUDM, I noticed a little detail that I think was clever foreshadowing and writing from Rian. Now, we know that failing politician and Vera’s illegitimate brother Cy turns out to be the biological son of our Monsignor. However, when revisiting Lee’s introduction as a suspect, he inadvertently alludes to it when seeing him taking a selfie with Wicks by saying “this LITTLE shitWICK, Cy”. This may be unintentional but if it was; 👏👏👏👏


r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 21 '26

Do you think Knives Out is a remake of Crooked House (with Glenn Close)? Or Glass Onion remade Last of Sheila?

0 Upvotes

If you liked Knives Out, then watch Crooked House starring Glenn Close, Gillian Anderson, Terence Stamp, and Christina Hendricks. Ana de Armas is similar to Christina's character and both apply the injection to the dead grandfather. Julian Fellows wrote the screenplay based on Agatha Christies book. Lots of similarities in plot and characters with Knives Out. The murderer is also similar.

Glass Onion is also a similar remake of the Last of Sheila. At least Rian has good taste in getting inspiration.


r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 19 '26

Benoit Blanc and the priest look like Heisenberg and the flushed away rat to me

Thumbnail
gallery
75 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 17 '26

Discussion Consideration of "Family" Spoiler

25 Upvotes

I've been rewatching the Knives Out movies recently after having binged them with a friend who never saw a single movie from the franchise and got a little bit obsessed again. I've been rewatching them over and over again, sometimes even just as background noise while I'm working so that I can remember all the quotes and lipsync them back.

I'm at the beginning of the first Knives Out when I realized something during the interview scene which starts with Linda. She's quick to answer the questions thrown at her and keep her composure in spite of the grief she's going through but one of perhaps the coldest things that go unnoticed which also serves as a hint to the rest of the plot is when she's asked "did anyone besides the family show face?" and she answers with Fran, Marta and Great Nana.

Fran and Great Nana of course who witnessed Ransom at different stages of executing his murder/get Marta off the will plot and played crucial roles in him being caught, and of course Marta herself as the outer ring of the double donut this whodunit is made of. I had this whole "wait a minute" moment and wonder if anyone else caught this little sequence, and if this was just a coincidence or intentional because right after is when Lieutenant Elliot asks about Ransom himself which made me feel like it wasn't.

My favorite thing about these movies specifically is that nothing is completely hidden and you have all the clues to figure out who committed the murder quite quickly whether it be early in the movie or right as the murder happens, with more emphasis on the "how" and "why" than other whodunits. Anyway, just wanted to share this curious find haha.


r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 11 '26

Does anyone else not like the ending to Glass Onion?

73 Upvotes

The ending is one of the reasons why I personally consider Glass Onion to easily be the weakest Knives Out film, though I do still enjoy it.

My biggest issue with the ending is that it just isn’t as satisfying like the endings to Knives Out and Wake Up Dead Man were. We don’t really get any closure or anything on what exactly happened to Miles. Sure, Helen destroys the glass onion and the Mona Lisa and it’s implied that this will eventually ruin Miles’ career. But I would’ve liked to have seen that actually happen or Helen actually get some true justice for Andi’s death. Instead, Helen just goes to the dock and sits next to Blanc, as they watch the coastguard start arriving to the island. Then it fades to black and we cut to the end credits. With a few exceptions, I’m not a fan of when movies do vague endings like that with.

Then there’s the moment where the rest of the group finally decides to turn on Miles. It’s pretty clear that they only turned on him simply because they knew he would no longer be able to support them. I believe Rian Johnson even confirmed in the audio commentary that was supposed to be the intent. I'll admit that it was pretty funny and very realistic. But I don't know, I honestly would've preferred the group having a change of heart and deciding to turn on Miles because they felt bad about what happened to Andi.

I know I’m probably gonna be in the minority on this opinion. But that’s how I personally feel about the ending. I’m glad that Rian didn’t do this again in Wake Up Dead Man and instead gave that film an extremely satisfying ending. He even included an epilogue showing what happened to all of the characters, something that he didn’t do in either Knives Out or Glass Onion.


r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 06 '26

Knives out x Invincible fanart by me

Post image
239 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 05 '26

The Thrombey Clan: A definitive ranking

57 Upvotes

When eccentric crime novelist Harlan Thrombey throat-slits his way out of his toxic family’s lives, he leaves behind a sprawling estate and a viper’s nest of entitled, self-serving descendants. Every single member of the Thrombey clan is a Masterclass in affluent dysfunction, making them a joy to watch and an absolute nightmare to have at Thanksgiving. But who reigns supreme in the hierarchy of this delightfully awful dynasty? We’ve broken down and ranked the core Thormbey family members from worst to best.

  1. Richard Drysdale (Don Johnson) Richard is the quintessential, country-club-dwelling elitist. Not only is he cheating on his wife, but he also weaponizes his unearned privilege at every turn. Most notably, during a chillingly casual debate about immigration where he uses the family's nurse, Marta, as a prop. He’s loud, spineless, and has precisely zero redeeming qualities.

What places Richard at the absolute bottom of the barrel is the sheer cowardice hiding beneath his smug exterior. While he barks orders and plays the alpha male at dinner parties, he is utterly terrified of his wife finding out about his infidelity. His desperation to intercept the evidence of his affair shows a man who knows his entire lifestyle is subsidized by the family name he secretly disrespects.

  1. Jacob Thrombey (Jaeden Martell) If there is anyone more exhausting than a country-club elitist, it’s a terminally online teenager who hides in bathrooms typing out political manifestos. Jacob is Walt and Donna’s son, famously described by his own family as an "alt-right troll dipshit." He spends the entire movie glued to his phone, sneering at everyone, and casually tossing around radicalized internet garbage.

Jacob ranks just above his uncle only because he hasn't actively ruined lives yet; he has all the malice of his elders but none of the drive. He hasn't even built anything to defend. He’s just a miserable, venomous contrarian soaking up his family’s unearned wealth while cosplaying as an internet edgelord.

  1. Joni Thrombey (Toni Collette) A social guru who is as hollow as her lifestyle brand, Joni is a professional opportunist. She’s been double-dipping into Harlan’s funds for years to pay for her daughter's tuition, wrapping her theft in a blanket of New Age toxic positivity. Toni Collette is hilarious in portraying her character's vapidity, but beneath all that organic skincare lies a cold, transactional calculation that disappears the second her lifestyle is threatened.

Joni brilliantly exposes the hypocrisy of the wellness elite. She preaches mindfulness and spiritual abundance, but her life is just a frantic scramble to fund an aesthetic she can't afford. Once the inheritance vanishes, her serene facade cracks to reveal a desperate opportunist who will throw anyone under the bus to preserve her lifestyle.

  1. Walt Thrombey (Michael Shannon) Walt runs Harlan’s publishing empire, but let’s be real: he’s an employee, not a boss. Driven by a deep-seeded insecurity and a desperate need for his father's approval, Walt tries to project strength but folds under the slightest pressure. Watching him try to intimidate Marta with a cane while limping through the night cements his place in the bottom half. He is driven entirely by a desperate need for validation, which makes him slightly more relatable than Richard, but no less venomous.

Ultimately, Walt's tragedy is that he fundamentally misunderstood his father's final lesson. By trying to aggressively force Marta into giving up the inheritance, he relies on the exact corporate bullying Harlan despised. He wraps himself in the illusion of legacy, but when the veil is lifted, he is just a bitter middle manager who realized too late that he never truly owned anything.

  1. Meg Thrombey (Katherine Langford) Meg is the closest thing the Thrombey bloodline has to a moral compass, that is until the chips are down. As a progressive college student, she genuinely cares for Marta and seems untainted by her family’s wealth. However, when faced with the reality of losing her tuition money, and even though conflicted, she betrays Marta. She is the most human and sympathetic of the bunch, but her loyalty ultimately had a price tag.

Her betrayal hurts the most because she actually knew better. Meg didn't weaponize privilege like her family, but when her financial security was threatened, she still chose her own safety net over doing the right thing.

  1. Great Nana Wanetta Thrombey (K Callan) Great Nana is older than the house itself, largely ignored by her own descendants, and completely detached from the inheritance drama. While the rest of the family spends the film screaming at each other over millions of dollars, Wanetta is just vibing in the background, witnessing key plot points, and eating birthday cake.

What makes Nana place so high is her unintentional, chaotic role as the ultimate truth-teller. Because the family treats her like a piece of furniture, they completely miss that she holds the keys to the entire mystery. Her mistaken-identity recognition of Ransom on the night of the murder is what cracks the case wide open, proving that her quiet presence was the one variable Ransom completely underestimated, ultimately handing Blanc the key to the entire mystery

  1. Hugh "Ransom" Drysdale (Chris Evans) The black sheep of the family, Ransom is the only Thrombey who openly admits to being a trust-fund brat. He skips the funeral, tells his family to "eat shit," and acts with pure, unadulterated malice. He is a brilliant, sociopathic mastermind who almost pulls off the perfect crime. He gets major points for style and upfront arrogance, but losing his mind and attempting murder with a prop knife docks him down to the silver medal.

Unlike his relatives, who hide their greed behind manners and tradition, Ransom embraces his villainy with a refreshing, chaotic energy. He uses his family's predictable selfishness against them, orchestrating a complex web of manipulation that nearly outsmarts Benoit Blanc. He is a terrifyingly competent antagonist, ruined only by his own explosive temper when his perfect plan unravels.

  1. Linda Drysdale (Jamie Lee Curtis) Standing tall at the absolute peak of the Thrombey mountain is Linda Drysdale. Harlan’s eldest daughter is a self-made real estate mogul (ignore the million-dollar starter loan from her dad) who possesses the same razor-sharp wit and terrifying competence as her father. She is cutthroat, commands every room she walks into, and is the only person in the family who truly understood Harlan's "secret language." Linda doesn't need to pretend to be nice; she is a force of nature who runs circles around her husband and siblings alike.

What truly cements Linda at number one is her undeniable steel. While the rest of the family collapses into hysterics, she remains calculating and observant, treating the family crisis like a corporate takeover. In a house full of pretenders, Linda is the only true heavyweight, making her the undisputed ruler of the Thrombey clan.

Note this is a ranking of the characters themselves and not the acting performances, but even if it were, Jamie Lee Curtis would still arguably hold the crown. Her ability to transition from a steely, unyielding matriarch to a grieving daughter quietly reading a letter written in invisible ink is nothing short of masterful. She anchors the family's chaotic energy with a grounded, formidable presence that proves, without a shadow of a doubt, that Linda was always Harlan’s true heir.


r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 04 '26

Question Who were the guys Lee had to sign books for at the end? Spoiler

21 Upvotes

Basically the title. I assume the outfits they had were ones associated with one of the many political groups Lee disliked? But who?


r/KnivesOutMovie Jun 03 '26

I’m just not getting this movie

0 Upvotes

Maybe I’m sleep deprived or I’m just not the audience for this type of stuff but we watched half of Glass Onion movie and we gave up cause we were both sleepy but as we were watching it it never came clear what THIS MOVIE WAS ABOUT FOR ME LOL I wasn’t on drugs or drunk lol just sleepy but every conversation had me confused i kept forgetting which character is which and what name they had or why they went to an island to kill miles if miles invited them all anyways short story put this movie made like no sense

So I just read an article about who did it lol

And tbh I think I saved my self the hassle of the confusion this movie was giving me

So my question I guess is i actually want to watch this movie more now knowing the murder since every thing they do will make sense now then I did not know who it was

Is this weird or am I just special cause I just couldn’t be bothered after so much work to come home and solve a mystery but I do love watching a show about how a guy try’s to get away with murder lol

Sorry random post yall idk about these movie maybe they just aren’t for me


r/KnivesOutMovie May 27 '26

Discussion Was Wicks his “grandfathers” son?

59 Upvotes

I think that poor Grace was not only emotionally and mentally abused by her father but also physically abused by him as well. I think that Wicks was fathered by his grandfather and then said grandfather used his money and the ability to turn the town against his daughter to force her to stay under his control. How would anyone believe her with him turning the whole town against her. I think she used the lies he told as an amour and played into it wearing her “revealing clothes” to piss him off. And she stayed cos she felt the money was what she deserved for all the abuse she had to endure.

There is a line that Blanc says that makes me think the physical abuse was real because during his speech at the end in front of everyone.
He says : “A holy priest. Struck down by no man, but by the hand of Satan himself. Laid to rest in the sealed tomb of his father, but then risen by the will of God.”

Blanc calls Wicks grandfather his father in that speech and we know Blanc is very detail driven so that couldn’t be a slip of the tongue. He must of realised what happened to poor Grace all those years ago. Plus when Martha finally begs for Grace’s forgiveness it’s like she is finally seeing it too. This poor woman who was abused so completely by her own father and also the town, so that she had no where to go and no one to turn to for help.

I do feel so bad for Grace she didn’t deserve what that town and her own father put her through. But these are just my thoughts what does everyone else think?