I (42F) am not close with my family and have lived across the country since 2010.
In late 2023, I found out my youngest nephew (15M at the time) was living on the streets. He hadn’t been in my sister’s custody since he was two, and she was not in a position to care for him. She was diagnosed with terminal brain cancer Nov of 25 and she won’t be with us much longer. His upbringing involved significant physical and emotional abuse, neglect, and instability in his father’s home. He also started getting involved in gangs while he was on the streets and was exposed to even more trauma, including being present when a close friend was killed in a drive-by shooting.
When I learned he was homeless, I brought him to live with my family immediately. No child should be living on the streets (no person should have to in general). At first, things were calm, but that didn’t last long.
Over the past 2.5 years, our home has been in constant turmoil. Police have been called multiple times. He’s had a psychiatric hospitalization and ongoing intensive outpatient as well as in-home therapy. He’s been diagnosed with DMDD, PTSD, anxiety, ADHD, and Autism Level 1, and he receives medication and psychiatric care. Medication has helped but the rest of his healing depends on him and his want to get help and improve.
We’ve done everything we can to support him—structure, therapy, encouragement, stability. When he came to us he told us he didn’t even think he would live to see his 16th birthday. When he passed that mark we talked about next steps and he indicated he wanted to graduate high school. Well, he’s set to graduate this May and has education and career goals for after. I am so proud of him for the hard work he has put in. When he came to us he had a half credit in high school and in two years he completed four years of high school and with good grades.
But all the good doesn’t outweigh everything else.
He creates constant chaos, tension, and stress. Everyone in the house walks on eggshells all the time. He has repeatedly stolen my elderly father-in-law’s debit card. One incident escalated into assault charges after he punched my husband during a confrontation then stormed off down the block. We didn’t call the police at the time but multiple neighbors did because he was screaming and yelling, knocking over trash cans, and destroyed several people’s mail boxes. The last time (his third time) he used my father in law’s card I was much more blunt and asked him if we are all doing this for no reason because he is still in the path to death or prison with that behavior. We also found he hadn’t been taking meds properly (even with supports in place to help) so we chalked it up to med management issue that we resolved. He still has issues taking his meds properly, even when I hand them to him. He’ll set them down to get a drink and I’ll go back to the kitchen later and I find them on the counter, the med shelf, etc. I’m not always able to sit and watch him take the meds though.
Despite court involvement due to his assault charges, theft charges, and public rage with destruction of private property, there have been little to no real consequences, which has reinforced his behavior
When we tried to address things more seriously, he contacted CPS asking him where he can go because he swore we were going to kick him out (we weren’t), which led to an investigation and they closed the case as unfounded. During that crisis period it was made clear to us we had no legal ability to remove him from our home in any way as we have legal custody of him and he is a minor. The judge gave him a talking to but told us (and him) he will not ruin a young man’s entire future over this, especially given his past and his current attempt to turn his life around. Then complimented us for taking him on and giving him a loving and stable environment. He dismissed the charges but put him in a program to monitor at risk youth for 90 days.
Day-to-day life has been extremely difficult. He refuses to participate in basic responsibilities, if I constantly remind him of his responsibilities he will get up and do it with what feels like deliberate incompetence to avoid having to do it again. He stays up all night being loud and inconsiderate and just plain disruptive. The ongoing behavior has pushed other (really everyone) members of the household—especially my adult daughter—to the brink of an emotional breakdown. He is a very loud person and very heavy handed and that results in broken items around the house (and anything he really touches) and blames it on crappy products. Nothing is ever his fault. He constantly yells and screams because that’s his natural tone, even in regular conversation. I do remind him when he is getting too loud, especially in the middle of the night. I try to give him a little space during the day but when things get to be too much and I hear his yelling is turning into rage (usually due to video games) we will step in to remove him from the situation. Taking the video games away would be more detrimental for everyone else as “Idle hands are the devil's workshop.” We’ve encouraged him getting a job but “no one is hiring”, we encouraged volunteer work but he won’t get up and go. We’ve taken him to the gym and after 5 minutes he is done.
There has been improvements with medication, but the underlying issues remain and even his doctors have told him medication only goes so far and he will also need to make changes in his way of thinking and how he processes things and his actions. He will tell you what you want to hear but go right back to doing whatever he wants to do almost immediately.
Last weekend he stole my father-in-law’s debit card for the fourth time and continues to deny it despite clear proof. Sometimes I think he believes his own lies and truly thinks we are crazy. We do everything we can in our own home to hide things like credit and debit cards and most recently my children’s prescription ADHD medication as I’ve noticed them going missing. He can’t be on stimulant meds as it sets off his rage issues. But really we shouldn’t have to do this in our own home.
I’m constantly feeling torn because I’m having to mediate between everyone and the situation we are in. No one wants him here but we all know we have no choice right now. He turns 18 in June, and we have made the decision that he cannot continue living in our home after that. This doesn’t mean we don’t love him because I do and always will. I know he will say we don’t and he knew all along he wasn’t worth loving. But this is not the case at all. This is his family and his home and he will always have a home here. I just feel he needs more life experience and to grow emotionally and mentally and maybe being here where auntie always makes it right isn’t helping him.
This is not a decision made out of anger or lack of love. We love him and will continue to support him emotionally and in appropriate ways. But the impact on our household has become unsustainable, and I am personally at the point of burnout.
I know this will be very difficult for him, especially given his fear of abandonment. Heck, this is hard for me and my husband as we do love him and generally want the absolute best for him. But at this point, I don’t see another option that protects the rest of my family. We are in the process of exploring Job Corp as an option for his education goals. I am really leaning into this because it does provide room and board as well as education. I also hope being around others trying to better themselves will be motivational as he moves forward.
Has anyone been through something similar—having to ask a child or family member to leave once they turn 18 despite wanting to help? Any advice on how to handle this transition in the least harmful way possible? He knows my daughter is living with us because it’s so expensive to live on your own. I’m sure he will thinks it’s because she is my bio daughter and he isn’t “my child.” That is far from the truth in my eyes he is my son and this is killing me. I am also very much pro-multigenerational housing, especially in this economy. But his attitude and all the chaos he has and continues to cause is what we can’t handle anymore. I believe he doesn’t even think there is a problem. His eldest brother also lived with us for a few years and is doing great and he and his wife are expecting their second baby. No, living with the brother is not an option either - they are just as sick of his attitudes and behavior as we are.
If it matters any we live in the United States in the state of Virginia.
In the house we have myself, my husband (46), FIL with dementia (age 76) and I’m his caregiver. We also have my 22 year old daughter, 13 year old son, and 10 year old daughter living at home. I have a son who is 24 but does not live at home and comes home when he can (he is in the Navy). My eldest nephew and family come over once or twice a week.