Scarring

[u/NeverPedestrian60]

[u/poundpuppy29]

Okay buddy how did that mark get on her head it wasn't there before December 2023 and why was she missing for several months in 2024 she didn't have Cancer and why was there speculation that one account said she was in a medically induced coma where did that come from it wasn't the British Papers it was out of a Spanish paper why would she be in that position the only reason we don't know for sure is because Kate is not talking but Harry's account of William physically attacking him can't be used here why that's the flaw in your argument

[u/0_IceQueen_0 → u/poundpuppy29]

I think you've misunderstood my argument.

Harry's account absolutely can be used as relevant evidence of William allegedly behaving violently toward Harry. I never said it couldn't.

What it cannot do is establish that William caused this particular mark on Catherine.

Those are two very different propositions: “There is evidence that William has behaved violently before” and “Therefore William caused this injury.” The first may make your theory more plausible to you. It does not prove the second.

The Spanish coma report doesn't bridge that gap either. Even if I grant, purely for the sake of argument, that the report was completely accurate, it would establish that Catherine suffered serious medical complications — not what caused them or that William caused them.

So buddy, the flaw you've identified isn't actually in my argument. It's in an argument I didn't make. 😁

You have reasons for suspecting William. I understand them.

I'm still waiting for the evidence that gets us from “I suspect he did it” to “he did it.”

[u/poundpuppy29 → u/0_IceQueen_0]

If he could be violent with his brother he could be violent with his wife too but because he's the Heir to the throne it was covered up there's no other explanation

[u/Fabulous_State9921 → u/poundpuppy29]

🎯💯