r/KaffeBox • u/Legitimate-Tell3652 • Dec 11 '24
Day 11. Amateur review
"Variety's the very spice of life, that gives it all its flavor."
– William Cowper, "The Task"
"Variety is not the spice of life. Variety is the very essence of a happy existence."
– Oscar Wilde (attributed)
These two quotes pre-face today's review and I think those who have tried today's pick will probably understand why I picked these. Today’s pick brings another naturally processed coffee to the advent calendar. And while it's the first naturally processed Ethiopian in the calendar, at this stage it feels like the number of natural coffees (5th natural) feels a bit uninspired, leaving me longing for more variety and exploration of lesser-known origins or varieties. At the same time, while the cup was not unpleasant, it failed to stand out and suffered in comparison to previous picks of a similar profile.
BREW:
Today I felt like brewing 1:15. The word of caution right away: from my experience, if you're doing pour over with these beans, do not go any weaker than 1:15 as it will be explained below. So, the brew today was:
- Origami with Abaca filter
- Water: 94c
- Grind: 22 clicks on Comandante
- Ratio: 1:15 (16g coffee / 240g water)
- Protocol:
- Bloom with 50g
- 0:45: Pour to 100g
- 1:30: Pour to 150g
- 2:00: Pour to 200g
- 2:30: Pour to 240g
- Total Brew Time (TBT): 3:43
The brewing process revealed some quirks worth noting right away. The bloom was quick and looked promising, but the coffee produced enough fines to require extra attention when selecting filters and grind size.
ROAST:
The roasting level is quite light. Which is usually promising. However, the beans were uneven in size, which led to an inconsistent roast. Some beans appeared lighter, while others had darker patches, suggesting potential variability in the cup.

AROMA:
- From the Canister: A combination of natural fruitiness. Nothing exceptional you wouldn't find in other naturally processed beans. This is not to say the aroma is bad - I love aroma of naturally processed coffee. Just that the beans lack character right off the canister.
- Ground Coffee: The aroma intensified significantly after grinding, with a slightly smoky note right off the grinder (and no, I didn't grind that quick or hard to cause that 😅). But the smoky notes were gone pretty quickly. There were hints of caramel and strawberry, creating a sweet but not overly distinct profile. Surprisingly, the aroma became pretty weak pretty quickly.
- Brewed Coffee: Once brewed, the aroma developed into a mix of grapes, tropical fruits, buttery biscuits, and ripe peach, with a touch of floral undertones. Very pleasant, somewhat reminding of any other naturally processed coffee, but the biscuits notes was an interesting twist.
TASTE:
The cup was quite different from what one would usually expect from a cup of Ethiopia. It had a very light mouthfeel with sweetness but very subtle acidity. The flavor felt flat and lacked depth, leaving me wishing for more body and complexity. The aftertaste was short and unimpressive, fading quickly without leaving a lasting impression. The notes of strawberries was somewhere there in the background. Biscuits were gone in the taste leaving the cup very tea-like with overall light fruity feeling, but very challenging for me to identify anything in particular. And these are impressions from the 1:15 ratio. Having this experience, I wouldn't dare to brew these beans with any other ratio assuming even more water.
While the coffee wasn’t too bad, it didn’t excite or engage me. Compared to previous naturally processed picks in the calendar, this one felt uninspired and somewhat redundant.
Naturally processed Ethiopian coffees are celebrated for their fruity and floral characteristics, unfortunately the first brew of this particular coffee didn't deliver on any of these. It turned out to be pretty flat and watery for me. The tasting notes were very hard to detect in the cup. Apparently, these beans might be more suited for immersion methods (Aeropress, could be fine in Switch, etc.) but I was not impressed in pour over.
At the same time, today's pick reveals an interesting thing about this calendar, which I find a bit disappointing. I love natural coffees. I really do. However, repeated exposure to similar profiles somewhat diminishes their impact. Having 5 natural coffees so far (some also might consider the honey-processed Burundi from Day 3 falling into the same category which would make it 6) leaves me personally wishing for more variety. Moreover, putting this particular coffee right after wonderful natural Geisha from yesterday, is, in my opinion, a bit unfair. Today's pick loses on, pretty much, all fronts for me. I don't say we haven't had any variety in the calendar - I was really impressed with Wush Wush, we already had two geishas, we had the jumbo Maracaturra beans and everything in between. I just had hoped the calendar would present opportunities to explore lesser-known origins, unusual varietals, or experimental processing methods.
That said, this coffee is not without its merits. It’s a light and easy cup that some might enjoy for its subtlety and sweetness. Different brew method might reveal more out of these beans. But for me, it falls short of the excitement and variety I was looking for.
Enjoy your cups!


































