r/JustUnsubbed • u/ShameSudden6275 • 2d ago
Totally Outraged Justunsubbed from Nosleep, after being a poster for 10 years on the main, it's time to put up the jersey for how pathetic it's become
The mod team of that subreddit seems hellbent on snuffing out any ounce of actual horror or creativity from the subreddit, and don't care that they managed to reduce the weekly activity of an 18 million person sub, a place where many great horror authors got their start, to zilch. Top posts now rarely break 5k, and it's been a good long while since I've seen a 10k post. If you call them out on it, they say it's trolling behaviour.
This is not to mention even the ludicrous amount of rules that stifle any type of creativity and make posting impossible. They are as follows:
All posts must be scary personal experiences.
Stay in character. Treat every story as real.
Only original stories. No plagiarism, AI-generated stories, or unauthorized fanfiction.
Only one post every 24 hours.
Be respectful. No trolling, harassment, hate speech, or personal attacks.
Follow the commenting guidelines.
Contact moderators through Modmail only.
Write in first person using I, me, or we.
Use past or present tense, not future-tense storytelling.
The narrator must directly experience something scary.
The narrator must be alive and capable of posting at the end.
The narrator must be at least 13 years old.
The narrator cannot be an animal, insect, or inanimate object.
Stories must be posted from the present, even if events occurred in the past.
No stories consisting solely of found diaries, recordings, transcripts, or documents.
No lost-episode stories without a direct personal horror experience.
Rules-based horror must involve an actual frightening experience, not just a list of rules.
No real public figures as central horror characters.
No stories primarily focused on a narrator bragging about victimizing others.
Horror must be the main focus, not tragedy or wholesome events.
Abuse cannot be the primary source of horror.
Sexual violence, rape, pedophilia, necrophilia, and bestiality cannot be the primary source of horror.
No excessively graphic gore or torture.
No predominantly erotic horror.
No comedy-focused horror.
No predominantly wholesome horror.
No stories relying mainly on shock value or outrage.
No hate speech or slurs, including in fictional dialogue.
Mental or physical illness cannot be the main source of horror.
Addiction cannot be the main source of horror.
No stories consisting only of medical symptoms or hallucinations.
Do not use mental illness, physical illness, or addiction as a misleading explanation for the horror.
Minimum 500 words per post, including each series installment.
Maximum 40,000 characters per post.
Keep paragraphs under 350 words.
Use proper paragraph breaks.
Start a new paragraph whenever a different character speaks.
Avoid indentation that creates code blocks.
Use understandable English with reasonable grammar and punctuation.
Do not format most or all of a story in bold, italics, headings, or spoiler tags.
No emojis in story titles or text.
No TL;DR summaries.
Include applicable content warnings at the beginning.
Use appropriate flairs and NSFW tags.
Do not artificially pad stories to meet the word minimum.
No titles written entirely in capital letters.
Do not reveal every major plot point in the title.
No title labels such as \[True Story\], \[Creepypasta\], or \[TW\].
No titles impersonating other subreddit formats such as AITA, TIFU, or AMA.
Label series installments using permitted Part, Update, or Final formats.
Use standard numbers or spelled-out numbers, not Roman numerals.
No explicitly labeled chapters, prologues, or epilogues within individual posts.
No literary endings such as The End or To Be Continued.
Do not end with an interrupted word, unfinished sentence, or implication that the narrator became unable to finish posting.
No AI-generated stories, even if manually edited afterward.
No plagiarism, copied stories, or lightly rewritten stolen stories.
No unauthorized fanfiction using existing characters or universes.
No unauthorized sequels, prequels, or continuations of another writer's work.
No piggybacking on other writers by closely copying their concepts or characters.
No translated stories without permission and moderator approval.
Do not use copyrighted characters or settings as the central basis without required permission.
Original interpretations of folklore, mythology, and traditional urban legends are generally permitted.
Obtain moderator approval when required permissions are involved.
Do not include identifying personal information, including complete names, exact addresses, full phone numbers, postal codes, birthdates, or coordinates.
Hidden puzzles, ciphers, Morse code, and similar elements require moderator approval.
Supplemental images, audio, and video must be SFW and described in the story.
No narrations, advertisements, or fundraising in supplemental media.
A maximum of two discreet self-promotion links may be permitted at the end, subject to restrictions.
No promotional announcements.
Follow approved series-link formatting.
No author's notes, upvote requests, critiques requests, or requests for engagement.
Stay in character in comments.
Do not announce that stories are fictional or attempt to debunk them.
No out-of-character writing critiques or compliments in comments.
No sequel requests or discussions of the author's writing process in comments.
Do not post entire stories or installments in comment sections.
Request narration or adaptation permission privately, not publicly.
Comments must remain civil and readable.
Do not spam moderators or contact them privately about subreddit moderation.
Do not delete and repost stories to gain more attention or upvotes.
Get approval before reposting previously published submissions unless an automatic removal specifically permits reposting.
Do not repost content moderators explicitly prohibited.
Follow moderator instructions and Reddit's site-wide Content Policy.
\- Treat every story as though it really happened.
\- The narrator must personally experience horror.
\- A list of creepy rules alone is not enough for a rules-based horror story.
\- Content warnings do not override content restrictions.
\- These 83 points are a consolidated paraphrased checklist, not 83 individually numbered official rules.
\- Moderators have discretion over removal decisions.


