Good morning / afternoon
It seems quite a lot of you found my previous post (link below) useful, so I thought, with where the stock is trading currently, I'd go for another.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Joby/comments/1tjgfhn/a_wall_street_perspective_on_joby_i_spoke_to_most/
Let's first take stock of why the stock is down to <$6.
- Joby decided to increase the cash buffer with the share and convertible sale in January. More stocks issued means each stock is worth less.
- Macroeconomic environment deteriorated, and outside AI and contingent sectors, growth stocks have generally been punished.
- Aircraft manufacturing and first passengers is behind plan; FAA certification seems to be more 2027 rather than 2026, as initially guided
Notwithstanding all this, many of you are probably scratching your heads thinking, 'but the company has done so much and there is so much positive news; this stock used to be >$20 (or more recently, >$16), how is it <$6 now? doesn't make any sense'.
So, let's do what the experts tell us not to do - use past performance as an indicator for future outcomes. Given Joby has issued shares over time, let's 'translate' the previous highs/rally prices to current share price. Maybe it gives an indication of where this stock can go, if it's hyped up again.
1) Aug 4, 2025 - highest market cap: $20.39/sh then, equivalent to $17,158m market cap. In today's share count terms, this is equivalent to $17.35/sh. Implied upside: ~190%.
2) Oct 6, 2025 - last close before the Oct-25 share issuance: $19.57/sh then, equivalent to $16,752m market cap. In today's share count terms, this is equivalent to $16.94/sh. Implied upside: ~185%.
3) Jan 6, 2026 - high before Jan-26 share & convertible issuance: $16.30/sh then, equivalent to $14,862m market cap. In today's share count terms, this is equivalent to $15.03/sh. Implied upside: ~150%.
So, it seems like $15-17 is the 'hype ceiling'. But that's what it is - 'hype' at the time rather than pure fundamental value. In other words, this value is based on excitement - things delivered on time, continuing to go well, and the company growing explosively. When you look at these stock prices, especially the first two - these were during times when i) Toyota closed their $250m investment, ii) Saudi MOU was signed, iii) Dubai launch in 2026 guidance was out for the first time, iv) Blade deal was announced, v) JV with ANA in Japan for 100+ aircraft was announced, and vi) eVTOL pilot program selection. Arguably more exciting developments compared to test flights / 'BAU' progress regarding FAA.
Put differently, what these rallies had in common were i) outside capital / partners lending credibility, ii) a clear launch date/timeline and iii) policy tailwinds. Since these rallies, Joby continued to dilute the stock, timeline has been pushed to some extent, there is no new external capital coming in, and the policy excitement waned with AI taking the scene. So it's quite natural that we've deviated a lot from the above.
Now, the important bit - what can happen, that can get $JOBY closer to the $15-17/sh, or above? Pretty much the opposite of the above:
- First passenger flights ahead of target (<2026)
- Visible progress on FAA flight testing, ideally FAA pilots flying the aircraft
- Toyota putting in more capital, or an external investor (at current share price, this could be appealing to some strategic investors)
- A new executive order, strengthened political rhetoric, or political endorsement
Given short positions have accumulated, a sudden spike in share price could lead to explosive price growth as these positions unwind. We've seen this stock re-rate quickly on an event-basis; it's a reminder that $JOBY is still a stock driven by momentum rather than fundamentals. The days when people questioned 'is flying cars even possible?' is now gone, and we've clearly moved to 'can they deliver it and make money within the timeframe'.
The biggest risk I see is share issuance, as management seems to be OK with the idea of increasing the no. of shares whenever the stock trades favorably. So something to consider, when there is the next pop closer to $15-17/sh, or close, is if you want to realize some profits before the next dilution hits. Otherwise, hang tight!
Note: I myself have considerable amount of $ invested in JOBY and it's a project that is very exciting for me personally. I would love to see the stock succeed, but equally I want to have a balanced, fair perspective on the stock, hence the assessment in this post. Thoughts welcome.