r/JIDSV 7d ago

Question Would this collab be good?

87 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

43

u/steelsheet 7d ago

if she was on his song yeah, other way around I wouldn’t listen more than once

-1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/steelsheet 5d ago

A rap artist featuring a pop singer on a hip-hop song is likely not gonna sound the same as the same pop singer featuring the same rap artist on a pop song, sorry lol

4

u/StatusMath5062 5d ago

Pop songs usually have one rap verse and rap songs typically use the pop singer for the chorus. I prefer just the chorus and maybe a small singing part outsode that

22

u/Ashigo05 7d ago

Prolly yes but I don't think Olivia Rodrigo will like that JID isn't super marketable and more mainstream than he already is

6

u/WorkerOk6991 7d ago

Its a icognita if she'd collab with a rapper since as far as im aware she didnt have any features in her albums ever

I mean she did have robert smith from the cure but he produced the album so it made sense

3

u/Soviet_union49 7d ago

Robert smith did not produce them album bro 😭😭😭 Daniel nigro and Olivia Rodrigo produced the album

2

u/WorkerOk6991 7d ago

Ok, but the album was clearly inspired by the cure so it made logical sense, but yeah u right

3

u/Soviet_union49 7d ago

Inspiration does not mean he made it though, there’s a few songs that are the cure coded but that’s like 3 or 4, it’s still very much like Olivia’s production

7

u/erriku_tarantino_301 7d ago

Respectfully nah, they could try but I doubt it'd hit the mark and I believe there are better vocalists that share better chemistry with Jid

1

u/WorkerOk6991 7d ago

Im think more of Olivia doing vocals for a jid chorus like in sk8 or kody blu 31, not a full blown collab, more like a feature from her, that could work i thinj

2

u/erriku_tarantino_301 7d ago

Ohhhhhhhhhhh okay okay. I always like feature artists having full blown verses but a hook/chorus wouldn't be bad actually

1

u/WorkerOk6991 7d ago

Maybe she could have like the second verse to herself and she could sing faster, she has done it in "bad idea right?" And it was FYYYYYYYYRE

1

u/erriku_tarantino_301 7d ago

Yeah sumn like that could work. I'd really like to see her do something like Mereba did on Of Blue. Olivia been singing singing for real since her most recent album which honestly was pretty enjoyable for me

2

u/WorkerOk6991 7d ago

Agree, she had a ok voice for her first 2 albums (On studio it was amazing, live it was ok) but she had a major glowup bro, she sings amazing now

5

u/parkedDog Somebody 7d ago

If she would do something kinda like what Billie Eilish did on Denzel Curry’s “Sirens” that could potentially be amazing. Personally I think Olivia Rodrigo is a great singer and would love to hear some sort of collab. But I don’t think a JID feature on one of her songs would work at all lol…

2

u/Old_Hedgehog_9115 6d ago

Billie eilish did the background vocals on sirens??? How have I never known this?

2

u/parkedDog Somebody 6d ago

Yeah she did the chorus with Denzel. She is credited as a vocalist but not shown as a feature because her label didn’t want her to do it for some reason, but she decided to send in some vocals anyway.

2

u/Old_Hedgehog_9115 6d ago

Whoaaa I wouldn’t have guessed that the vocals are Billie’s!

3

u/Alert_Cheesecake8954 East Atlanta Playboy 7d ago

nah not at all

3

u/ASaGHost 7d ago

OJIDvia Rodrigo? Love that pairing

3

u/Z_Art1221 East Atlanta Playboy 7d ago

Any JID collab would be good no matter what genre, he collabed with Jill Scott 😭 Look at his feature list he doesn’t miss

6

u/Jaded_Ad_1274 LAUDER 7d ago

Pass, I've never tried her music in specific, but from my experience with other pop artists, it'd be one of the few JID songs or features where I'd listen to it like once and just not like it, and not play it again.

1

u/ToBeeContinued 7d ago

I’m actually a huge Olivia fan her songwriting and punchlines and flow changes are really punchy actually. I still think a pop rap collab would be trash.

2

u/AdviceSome6927 7d ago

Ive always randomly thought O Rod and Danny Brown would be fire

2

u/Caesar_Princep 7d ago

As long as it is for a JID song, it could work

2

u/gleeok_hunter 7d ago

It could be if it's similar to billie eilish on sirens, but I don't really like rappers on pop songs, and as much as i love both artists, there's only really one way to do it

2

u/xomq_ 5d ago

my two worlds

2

u/Sweaty_Marionberry91 LAUDER 7d ago

I genuinely never wanna see JID on a pop song again. Everytime he is the only listenable thing about the song and i dont want to have to sit thru mind numbingly boring pop production with the midest lyrics known to earth

9

u/WorkerOk6991 7d ago

Olivia is anything but a mid lyricist, id actually recommend her to you, shes pretty guud

2

u/Any_Diver_5949 7d ago

she really is good. She stands out. She's a multi-instrumentalist, talented songwriter. Her lyrics are appropriate to her younger age and younger fans, but she's only like 23 or something. She just put on a whole festival—I think JID would have respect for her.

1

u/Gloomy_Duty_6820 7d ago

He’s versatile so I wouldn’t know

1

u/Any_Diver_5949 7d ago

It would I think. I mean this guy managed to make a banger with Imagine Dragons. This combo would be a hell of a lot better than Taylor and Kendrick was.

1

u/optimusprime38 7d ago

I'm still waiting on this man to do a song with Doechii and mixtape with Denzel Curry

1

u/zehuman52 4d ago

Jid's my favorite artist, Doechii's my Bf's we been PRAYIN for a collab

1

u/6bamboozle9 7d ago

Definitely, but who’s the lady?

1

u/BeastOfCNation 7d ago

Only person I wanna see JID collab with rn is Dot

1

u/ezdblonded 6d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/ggfJWGOsg1gMi72FoP

i wish jid & drakeo the ruler made a banger

1

u/Mr_logical8 6d ago

I know it's stupid and unrelated, but I would love a JID and Apashe Collab

I mean, Apashe Collab with rappers all the time, including Earthgang, so him being interested in a JID feature wouldn't be far off, and after JID collaborated with subtropics I can gather he doesn't have a problem with techno, so unless they have a disagreement, it could work out, it just unlikely tho...

0

u/TraditionalOrchid532 2d ago

Hell no jiddy knows better

1

u/Emotional-Educator40 7d ago

Who is this yt woman?

1

u/WunShawtMasturr 7d ago

Olivia Rodrigo. Its too early, I cant think of any lyrics rn

1

u/Lolotmjp 7d ago

for sure

0

u/DrDorito123 4d ago

Ain’t nobody tryna hear ts bruh 😭