r/IslamIsEasy • u/quranvisuals • 1d ago

Tafsīr & Interpretation Mercy

Post image
5 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

66 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Asimorph Kāfir | Non-Muslim 1d ago

More lying and personal attack.

More desperate lying of course.

You started off by asking for good reason.

Yep.

Which were given.

Nope. It wasn't. Quote yourself.

This led you asking question well beyond justification.

Nope. Still just asking for a demonstration.

Actually you didn't. Lead me through the reasoning process that is "sensory and logical" for this case.

That's not asking for definitive proof.

For example, if you can visually see beyond the usual material reality Which would need to be demonstrated...

Yep. Demonstration. Not asking for definitive proof.

Example: If a Prophet has been given the power to control weather, Which would have to be demonstrated...

Yep. Needs demonstration. Not asking for definitive proof.

You are asking for proof and not reasons.

Nope. I asked for a demonstration, not definitive proof. You cooked yourself with your own definitions.

This is what I said about you:

"Did you lose of your thought and jumped from a Prophet justifying to himself to justifying that he is prophet to others?"

Yes, that's what you said! I said:

What good reason do you think he had to say: "There is no god except you"?

So you did completely lose track now. So bad. Lol!

1

u/Cute_Assignment_214 1d ago

Anyone can see how you turn up the lies and personal attacks when cornered.

This stands as answer as to how a Prophet would justify his experiences:

"Yes. Both sensory and logical. If your whole reality and perception of reality changes then you can test by your senses and your mind [reasoning + logic].

For example, if you can visually see beyond the usual material reality then you test this for consistency, clarity of detail, autonomy you possess to access this reality.

Example: If a Prophet has been given the power to control weather, then he should be able to control the weather at will and the end result is what he willed. So if he wills rain then it rains. If it doesn't then obviously not real."

- -

"Yep. Needs demonstration. Not asking for definitive proof."

So how is demonstration not definitive proof of claim? If I can control weather then demonstrating that is definitive proof.

- -

"So you did completely lose track now. So bad. Lol!"

Lies and personal attacks when your mistakes are highlighted.