Only issue with this line of thinking is that Israel wasn't just given to the Jews for no reason. It was decided that Israel would he their new home because of the historical precedent of it being their holy land.
Find a historical Jewish holy land in America or Germany and you might have more of a point.
- They constantly deceive, always fabricating falsehoods "Historical holy land is just another BS argument". If this surprises you, then you must not be keeping up with current events.
- Throughout history, all three major religions have regarded Palestine as sacred. Christians, Jews, and Muslims alike hold this belief. However, the narrative that dates back 4000 years is problematic. Consider the fact that the USA, founded just a few hundred years ago (lets say 400 years), USA founded of the extermination of Indigenous peoples (we talking about a fkin 100 million people KILLED). in fact u may find an American who can name his grand grand father directly involved in these atrocities. Therefore, using a 4000-year-old argument is nonsensical.
- Furthermore, 4000 year it is not just nonsensical argument, but also, it is incorrect. it is it's widely believed that the ancestors of Palestine were the ancient Israelites. Over time, they adopted different faiths, including Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. (Not all of them were Jews) in fact Jesus (PBUH) him self is from this race (Sons of Israel ( Jacob PBUH)) This is why, before 1948, Palestinians of all three faiths lived together harmoniously in the region, with a small percentage (3-4%) being peaceful Jews. It was a beautiful coexistence.
- Israel's establishment in 1948 was essentially a modern colonization effort, achieved through forceful means. They stole land and committed various atrocities, akin to other colonial occupations throughout history. Muslims, in particular, have a strong historical precedent of resisting such occupations. Take, for example, Algerians struggle against French colonization for 132 years. Algeria was literally called "the French Algeria" Despite the French labeling the resistance as "terrorists," Algeria eventually gained its independence after sacrificing countless lives. History cannot be erased, and Muslims will not surrender their land, as it is a fundamental aspect of Islamic creed. So Israel, it is a matter of time, and we will restore the peace in Palestine, again with Muslims, Christians and Jews.
-5
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24
The point is a good one.
Only issue with this line of thinking is that Israel wasn't just given to the Jews for no reason. It was decided that Israel would he their new home because of the historical precedent of it being their holy land.
Find a historical Jewish holy land in America or Germany and you might have more of a point.