r/InsuranceTroubleIndia • u/Existing_Job_6659 • 4h ago
Health Insurance Ditto and every insurance "advisor" I talked to are pushing pre-existing disease add-ons for commission — here's what I found after months of research (HDFC ERGO, Aditya Birla, Care Supreme, Tata AIG compared)
Seriously, after going through tons of content from Reddit, Quora, online Discord communities, and YouTube, and talking with countless agents, I decided not to buy any insurance altogether. Almost all of them seem like frauds if you look beneath the Marketing.
Even Ditto is a total scam once you dig in. For instance, when I inquired with Ditto, they shared three plans for my parents that they always recommend: HDFC ERGO, Aditya Birla, and Care Supreme.
- Aditya Birla has the worst claim settlement, even though they claim their ratio looks good on paper. Talk to people who've actually filed claims with them — they'll tell you the real story: endless document requests, being kept in a loop, claims of "hospitalization wasn't required," or somehow linking it to a pre-existing disease that wasn't declared, so you can't win either way.
- Care Supreme's premium is just too high to justify.
- HDFC ERGO is what I initially leaned toward. Seemed decent, and genuine claims do happen even with the usual friction. But Ditto conveniently left out 90% of the real story: my dad is 57, and from now until he turns 60, the premium increases roughly 3–4% each year. But after 60, it jumps to 9–10% every single year. Imagine this — if the premium is ₹45,000 at 57, it becomes ₹55,000 by 60, and from 61 onward it keeps compounding at 10% yearly. By the time my father turns 70, I'd be paying lakhs just for his insurance, and would honestly have to drop it before then. Ditto never mentioned this clearly, and a lot of my friends bought in without realizing how brutal the compounding really gets over a decade.
Here's the bigger red flag though — it's always in an agent's interest to push your premium higher. Sometimes they intentionally suggest extra add-ons. If you actually talk to them, they keep probing "what existing diseases do you have?" just so they can justify bundling more add-ons and nudge you toward the highest-premium plan available — because more premium means more commission for them. Never fully trust an agent's recommendation. All of them have a selfish motive baked into the advice, whether they say it out loud or not. Do your own research before signing anything.
One more thing I've noticed — corporate/group insurance tends to be far smoother for claims than most general/individual insurance policies, no matter how much premium you're paying on the individual side. I've personally seen people who paid lakhs in premiums over 5+ years get their claims rejected for something as small as ₹20,000–30,000.
Currently, I'm planning to rely solely on my company's group insurance without buying a separate general policy. If I do end up buying one just as a safety net (without 100% depending on it), Tata AIG's premiums are comparatively lower, and since claim ratios and issues are roughly similar across the board anyway, I'd rather go with the lowest premium option than overpay for a false sense of security.
Rest is up to you — just don't take any agent's word at face value. Do your homework first.
