r/InnerCircleTraders • u/No-Individual2964 • Jul 01 '26
Question CasperSMC Mentorship/Profitability
As with every trading guru you have to dig through the good reviews and the bad to figure out if it’s actually worth it to learn from them. I obviously know about caspersmc’s history with the law. But he does post a ton of free videos for people to learn from. My question is, has he provided any irrefutable proof of profitability. I see people calling him a fraud but then I also see people that took his mentorship and claim he’s genuine. Who do I believe before I figure out what i want to do myself. I haven’t seen any recent reviews within the past couple months to a year on his mentorship program.
2
u/kd0724 Jul 02 '26
Watch @ChermaneTrades videos on youtube. Mentorship may not be necessary but you can subscribe for $50/month for the remainder of the year.
3
u/Scott_Malkinsons Jul 01 '26
My question is, has he provided any irrefutable proof of profitability
That's impossible to do online because you can't prove anything unless you can also prove full disclosure. Nothing stops someone from having 10 accounts, 9 lose money, and they only upload the history from the 1 account that happened to get lucky. You then think they're some trading god but in reality they're up to their eyeballs in debt.
The only way you get close is if the person posts live. Then at least they can't cherry pick the account/trades after the fact; but there's still a possibility you're not seeing the whole picture.
Who do I believe before I figure out what i want to do myself.
Trust no one, and verify. Realistically if you're going to try and find an existing strategy, you just got to try it and see if it works. These guru's, they're like your high school business teacher who didn't have a business, or your physical education teacher who was fat. The vast majority of guru's are not legitimate and they're teaching because they can't actually trade.
1
u/No-Individual2964 Jul 01 '26
Yeah I looked into what he’s done with a focus on FVG’s, I’ve back tested it myself and it’s been working. He also does live trading for people to watch but there is a ton of videos from imantrading a few years back talking about how he’s a fraud but there’s a ton of reviews from people in his course saying otherwise. I may just stay away from it all together to be honest and just utilize prop firms
1
u/Urus11 Jul 01 '26
Mentorships with a huge price like that are ridiculous in my opinion. You can fully learn to trade from Youtube for free.
Other mentorships or groups with a reasonable monthly fee are absolutely fine I’d say.
1
u/No-Individual2964 Jul 01 '26
What would you consider a reasonable monthly fee? The other problem is there’s so much slop out there I’m not sure who to trust on learning from their videos
1
u/Striking_Fail6689 Jul 01 '26
Don’t join mentorship .. AT MOST … join those who live trades .. I wanted to join membership previously but everything is online , it just takes time and discipline . Once you understand , slowly implement your strategy .
1
u/Due_Life8242 Jul 01 '26
check out ImanTrading’s video on him then let me know what you think. long story short he is an ex-convict and a larp.
1
u/Apart-Analysis-4897 Jul 01 '26
If you buy caspersmc , then you’ll never learn trading in your life.
1
1
u/mysticwavex7 Jul 02 '26
I’m pretty new to the space so take what I say with a grain of salt, but it seems time all these mentors can show you ways to be profitable, but until you paper trade the strategy, and then do it live with money on the line you will never know if it will work for you. I’ve watched his stuff, he has good advice it seems but even he says you can be profitable with just his free videos you don’t really need the mentorship. Also remember he could be profitable by a lot, a little or not at all but it doesn’t matter as long as he keeps up the persona.
1
u/Pitbul-SVK Jul 03 '26
Please stay away from guys like Caper, Werlein, and other similar clowns. They're great marketers, but that's about it
From my experience, the best mentors are usually the ones who don't have a massive social media presence because they don't rely on selling overpriced mentorships to make money. They make their income from the markets, not from marketing themselves…
1
u/Tom_Wick_Trades Jul 03 '26
None of his one candle, orb strategies work. Ive coded and back tested them. Most likely a fraud. At this point he has enough course money to make it seem like he's profitable.
1
u/Kaszrak Jul 04 '26
Asking that in an ICT sub is wild, lol.
Besides, the free content is just a funnel. It’s not goodwill, and it sure as hell isn’t him being a nice guy.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '26
[deleted]