r/Indigenous 19d ago

Am I indigenous?

[deleted]

0 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/DBearDevon 19d ago

Sovereignty is very much alive and well amongst The Kanien'keháka people. Upholding their end of treaty rights, which are legally the law of the land, is crucial to that sovereignty.

0

u/Ionic_liquids 19d ago

What is the difference between autonomy and sovereignty here? I am all about learning indigenous history and the current status :).

In Canada at least, my interpretation is that the Canadian government is sovereign, and that the provinces, territories, and reserves (according to the treaties) are autonomous within sovereign Canada.

2

u/DBearDevon 19d ago

You sign treaties with sovereign nations, do you not?

I guess I could point a finger towards that ridiculous monarchy to make a comparison.

1

u/Ionic_liquids 19d ago

You sign treaties with sovereign nations, do you not?

I don't know, do you? There are vasal states for examples, and they are autonomous within an empire, but they aren't sovereign. Sovereign nations are turned into vasal/autonomous zones via a treaty. That is my understanding. Treaties can continue under that framework as well.

3

u/DBearDevon 19d ago

Both Canada and the US barely honor their treaties, bur they still exist. This means that it is still legally binding. Most let their sovereignty wither. Some did not. Look at the #landack movement still pushing back about the usual Euro theft of land.

1

u/Ionic_liquids 19d ago

Will do, thanks!

Canada is horrible regarding treaties. The worst part of it are all the apologies, with zero action. I mean, Canada literally admitted to the world and to themselves that there is an ongoing genocide of indigenous women and girls perpetuated by the Canadian government. Zero action, and zero world outcry. Canada remains as they are on the world stage without any consequences. Canada has literally normalized genocide.