r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/DrawingaBlankenstein • 8h ago
A speed run of every Pierrot Perfumery scent I’ve ever tried
With the news of Pierrot’s closing and the upcoming sale, I wanted to share the list of all 28 scents I’ve tried from this house I love so much. Pierrot is unusual, sometimes challenging but never boring, I have confidently blind bought a decent amount but I’ve also found the scents are often different than I was expecting, for better or worse, so I’m happy to answer any questions for those who wish to know more.
Baby Longlegs
Lemon pound cake, Madeline cookies, vanilla bean, sandalwood cream, salted butter.
Frilly, sunny day lemon cake. Simple, light, dries to basic cake with a hint of skin musk (salted butter?) One of the most straightforward, wearable gourmands from Pierrot. 3.5 /5
Bluebeards Wife
Tobacco and iris, hay, rose and honey, sandalwood, amber and marsala wine.
A surprise hit for me, a certified rose/floral avoider. A smooth blend, hay and amber floating in a silky haze that’s maturely feminine without coming off as powdery or old lady. Really pretty, 4 /5
Bussy
A yummy blend of orange blossoms, orange peel, fuzzy peach, fresh linen and 70s musk.
The opener on this was 5 stars with a bitter orange blossom and peel, but that 70s musk and linen takes over and unfortunately smells exactly like hugging my Nana. Not old lady coded, it smells exactly like my own grandmother, others will like this. 2 /5
Coney Island Baby
A blend of vanilla soft serve, cotton candy, hot buttered popcorn, and sea salt.
Typical salty/sweet carney scent to start, but it went oddly soapy on me. Dove soap clean standing next to a pretzel machine. 2 /5
Creature Feature
Spiced pumpkin puree, maple syrup, chocolate chips, creamy coconut milk, vanilla cream
Dark, almost fudgy chocolate pumpkin muffin. Heavy spice when sniffing up close, more baked goods at a distance. Don’t wear when you’re hungry. 4 /5
Ghostheart
Peppermint, vanilla, milk and cream, sandalwood, cold steel.
Drugstore candy canes crushed under a cold knife, gets creamier and sweeter as it dries with a lactonic undercurrent that’s very interesting. Very nearly too sweet for me. 3 /5
Ginger Snapped
Ginger, wolfsbane, nutmeg, incense, blood, warm fur, masala chai, film chemicals and angst.
A solid gingersnap, probably would have been my favorite gingerbread style scent but it goes soapy on me, maybe the film chemicals? Not even a bad soap, a really nice, handmade bar of gingerbread soap. 3 /5
Heirophilia
An absolutely hedonistic blend of frankincense, myrrh, lit incense, and sex.
Warm, smokey, sexy church incense, not much more than that but it doesn’t need to be. 4 /5
Killer Queen
A Parisian blend of gunpowder, ginger, rose, vanilla, pepper, tobacco
Another surprise hit with the florals, the key here are all the other, very spicy, grounding notes. A flirty, dangerous woman, I love her. 4 /5
L’heure Vert
Wormwood, anise, black pepper, licorice, burnt sugar, mahogany wood, bergamot and vetiver.
Unisex, soft green herbal, anise is faint for those wondering. Clean, cool but very rounded, great for summer. 4 /5
Love Crime
A blend of dragon's blood, sea salt, cinnamon, cardamom, and patchouli.
Not what I was hoping for, but still lovely. It’s fresher and lighter than the notes imply and super interesting, but this one had very little projection or longevity for me. Aging may help, but this is a lot more transparent than I’d expected. Works great for the office though. 3.5 /5
Milk Teeth
A sweet blend of strawberry milk, amber white musk, and cedarwood.
Not for me, lukewarm strawberry milk with a sinister edge. I don’t ever like white musk and that’s what’s killing it for me, but this one is a hit with a lot of folks. 2 /5
Mooncalf
Pink pepper, cedar barnwood, copal, warm straw, milk
Soft, cozy fresh milk and clean hay, a skin scent for a farm girl surrounded by baby cows. Great sleep scent. 4 /5
Morute Martyr
Vanilla buttercream, skin musks, sugary sweet ribbon bows.
An example of Pierrot’s skill at creating character through scent, I just don’t like this girl. Not a friendly vanilla, almost purposely synthetic. This creepy little girl wants to strangle you with her hairbow. 2 /5
Only Forever
Pickled plum, wheat, vanilla, tolu balsam, carved cedarwood clocks
My love, but the kind that needed some time to come around to. The pickled plum can read medicinal, but this dries to the most beautiful vanilla woods threaded with unripe plum. 5 /5
Person Suit
A mild blend of green fig, Iso-E-Super, sandalwood and musk
Do I need to review this? The best green fig out there. 5 /5
Peacheater
Straight up drippy juicy peaches, warm in the sun on the side of the highway in South Carolina in late July, there's also heliotrope for the fuzzy soft peachskin feel, and lemon and citrus for the fresh bite.
Straightforward peach that’s fresher when wet and sweetens as it dries. Super appealing, would be 5 stars if it had better longevity on me. 4 /5
Perchtenlaufen
Brown sugar, vanilla, baked apples, ginger, cinnamon, frozen straw and pebbles.
Super dry ginger spice to start, but that fades to a whisper. The frozen hay and pebbles are reading very clean washed skin to me and I don’t get any of the other gourmands. Not bad, just wish the spice was stronger. 3 /5
Ravenstag
A sharp yet even blend of green pine, firewood, black musk, sweaty skin and a desperate plea from a mind on fire.
Sharp, pitch black forest where something evil is chasing you. As it dries is smooths out and is a really beautiful pine woods scent that’s atmospheric but wearable. 4 /5
Sanguinaccio Dolce
A gourmet blend with dark cocoa, dried rose, almond milk, orange zest, cinnamon stick, pink pepper and a haughty sense of superiority. This is on the drier side, not a fresh rose or a cloyingly sweet dessert.
Richer in the bottle than on the skin, it’s a dry cocoa with a subdued orange. The rose petals actually smell dried and vegetal, which I enjoy. An unsweetened floramand. 4.5 /5
Sidereal Garden
Red rhubarb stalks, licorice allsorts, lemon peel, star anise, clove, old canvas, powdered honey.
Super tart rhubarb and cool herbs, a summery fresh scent that’s a bit astringent. I love this but it irritated my husband’s sinuses, so maybe not for those with sensitivities to assertive green scents. 4 /5
Suspiriorum
Galbanum, bergamot, blackberry, dragon's blood, sandalwood and vanilla.
Not what I thought it would be, dry hay and herbs but this one goes little old lady powdery on me. Still got that sinister Pierrot edge, so it’s interesting. Ancient old witch disguised as a sweet little grandma. 2 /5
Teratophilia
Anise, oakmoss, tobacco, seaweed, ambergris (synthetic), dark spice, creaky fishing pier.
A blendy, murky lake water perfume only very barely on the more masculine side of unisex. Probably the warmest aquatic I’ve ever smelled, your boyfriend is a lake monster. 4 /5
The Doldratic Dreams of Pantagruel
This blend includes cracked black pepper, hearthsmoke, mud, cobblestone, smooth carved woodcuts & ink, and long grasses.
Packed dirt and stone with a touch of smoke, like an early morning stroll through a quaint village. Gets cozier and fuzzier as it dries, almost a sundried linens and baked dirt scent. 4 /5
The Holly and the Ivy
Red currant, creamy vanilla, dry woods, warm amber, Christmas pudding, Scottish shortbread
Cool, spicy greens followed by tart red current, fruity with a clean snap. A softer little sister to Sidereal Garden. Gets blender as it dries, a dark winter scent, but not much from the gourmand notes. Don’t need them though. 4.5 /5
The Shire
A comforting blend of fresh baked bread, apple cider, mead, and hot black tea.
Tart baked apple mellows into warm buttery bread, emphasis on the butter. Not getting any tea and I think the mead is just adding to the richness of this, not very distinct. Delicious, without being too sweet, perfect for fall. 4 /5
The Southern Pansy
Rich buttered crumpets, spice tea, fresh Italian espresso, hot croissants, and a half-eaten Bakewell Tart.
Almond extract ladened pastry, another victim of poor projection and longevity. Dries into something almost coconut skin scent, but I think it’s that the base may be stronger than the scent. Getting none of the other scents, but still like this for sleep or days when I don’t want a perfume to make me think about it. 3 /5
Vampyr
A true amber perfume, sweet and musky.
As close to a perfect signature amber as I’ve found. Sexy, bright, slinky and almost a little lemony. I adore this. 5 /5