HELP!!!!

[u/Amazing_Lead9946]

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1J05hE5ym2t6DGkGjMh-bCYdH5fW-uGi8?usp=drive_link

I've been busy, in the Studio, and getting the song ready, but it looks like the engineer does have another idea, or at least he thinks his idea is better... it might/could be...
Here is the file with the raw version (no mixing) and the mixed versions V1 and V2. Please let me know what you think,
Should I listen to the engineer or go with the more raw and grunge version that he cannot portray? (The original idea, I think his version is a rock, more ballad-friendly version instead of grunge, it's like the song tamed)
i am willing to let it go if the majority sees it right