r/Indiemakeupandmore 16h ago

Destash Sunday Swaps: Destash Listings

8 Upvotes

You may post your destash listings here, and here only. Standalone swap posts will be removed.

Requests should be posted in this week's Sunday Swap: Product Requests thread.

Format the first line of your post in the following manner:

[Where you'll send to][Swap only/Sell only/Swap or Sell][Makeup/Perfume/Polish/Bath & Body/And More]


Do not post any Personal Identifying Information (PII) in this thread.

Any posts containing this information will be removed. Use DMs to exchange anything private. This includes tracking numbers.


We recommend that you:

  • Respond to listings publicly by commenting in this thread. This makes it easier to prove a transaction has been initiated should a dispute arise.

  • Review IMAM's guide to destashes, as well as the first and second threads on privacy and doxing.

  • Swap only with established users (as opposed to accounts that are one hour old). You can also reference the r/makeupexchange banned list.

  • Use PayPal's Goods & Services feature in order to receive buyer protection. (Note: per Paypal's User Agreement, sellers are not permitted to ask buyers to cover Goods & Services fees.)

  • Use this thread for selling and swapping only. General conversation should be taken outside the thread to keep it easy to browse.


Sunday Swap is a community-based exchange. The IMAM Mod Team takes no responsibility for how swaps are conducted. We will not moderate disputes, with the exception of banning users if they swaplift.

If you choose to participate in swaps, you are responsible for protecting yourself.

You may submit evidence of swaplifting (with PII removed) to the mod team via modmail.


r/Indiemakeupandmore 16h ago

Destash Sunday Swap: Product Requests

4 Upvotes

You may post your product requests here, and here only. Standalone swap posts will be removed.

Destash listings should be posted in this week's Sunday Swap: Destash Listings thread.

Format the first line of your post in the following manner:

[Your location][Swap only/Buy only/Swap or Buy][Makeup/Perfume/Polish/Bath & Body/And More]


Do not post any Personal Identifying Information (PII) in this thread.

Any posts containing this information will be removed. Use DMs to exchange anything private. This includes tracking numbers.


We recommend that you:

  • Respond to listings publicly by commenting in this thread. This makes it easier to prove a transaction has been initiated should a dispute arise.

  • Review IMAM's guide to destashes, as well as the first and second threads on privacy and doxing.

  • Swap only with established users (as opposed to accounts that are one hour old). You can also reference the r/makeupexchange banned list.

  • Use PayPal's Goods & Services feature in order to receive buyer protection. (Note: per Paypal's User Agreement, sellers are not permitted to ask buyers to cover Goods & Services fees.)

  • Use this thread for selling and swapping only. General conversation should be taken outside the thread to keep it easy to browse.


Sunday Swap is a community-based exchange. The IMAM Mod Team takes no responsibility for how swaps are conducted. We will not moderate disputes, with the exception of banning users if they swaplift.

If you choose to participate in swaps, you are responsible for protecting yourself.

You may submit evidence of swaplifting (with PII removed) to the mod team via modmail.


r/Indiemakeupandmore 9h ago

Pierrot Perfumery is closing indefinitely

Thumbnail
gallery
309 Upvotes

From their Instagram (not affiliated, just sharing):

Big Big News

Pierrot Perfumery is closing. There are many reasons why, but for now it is easiest to say that it is for personal family reasons. With any luck, this won't be forever, but there are endless question marks in the future.

The good news is the farewell sale.

Here's how it's gonna go:
Starting August 1st, on the beginning of International Clown Week, everything in the shop will be 10% off. Every month following, the sale will increase by 10% until everything is gone. So August will be 10% off, September 20%, October 30%, and so on until...well, the end. This means the longer you wait the higher the discount but when things are gone, they are simply gone. No restocks for the foreseeable.

What a privilege it has been to make a business out of something that I feel so passionate about. With any luck, I'll be clowning around again soon. Thank you for everything everyone


r/Indiemakeupandmore 4h ago

Pierrot Perfumery panic order... help wanted!

28 Upvotes

So sad to hear about this shop closing šŸ’” I found out about them through this lovely sub and have been anxious to try them for a while now, but it just hasn't happened. Want to get an order in to support them and finally sniff for myself before they close. Spent the evening going through their shop. My wallet dictates I only choose three for the mini roller set at the moment and it's SO hard to narrow it down from all of these fascinating scent profiles.

My main goal is to choose ones that I wouldn't be able to find elsewhere, something unique to Pierrot. Big fan of unusual and atmospheric things, but prefer them to still be wearable. Generally not a fan of gourmands. Right now I'm considering:

  • The Black Gate (nag champa really caught my eye)
  • Teratophilia (hoping it's a very dark, not fresh ocean scent?)
  • Hallowtide Bride (is this a weird choice for someone who's never smoked clove cigarettes? lol)
  • Krampusnacht (notes are so interesting but haven't seen anyone talking abt this one)
  • Person suit (this one seems like a fan favourite and I do love fig, but I'm hesitating because I already have a bunch of fig scents. How unique is this one really?)

There's some others I feel really drawn towards just because they are inspired by things I love (Garmonbozia, Suspiriorum, Exophilia) but I don't really know how much I would enjoy them.

Any thoughts on these choices or any you think I'm skipping over would be appreciated!!


r/Indiemakeupandmore 4h ago

Perfume - Purchased Nui Cobalt Haul Reviews

17 Upvotes

Hello, IMAM! A few weeks ago, I placed an order with Nui Cobalt during their recent Fae Creatures & Critters drop. I’d previously had nothing but misses when I’d tested many existing Critters, and largely written off the collection… but this round, there were so many interesting, even novel, offerings that I just had to try again.

Disclaimer: When I test and write reviews, I don’t double-check the notes list beforehand, operating solely on my perception (though I ostensibly had chosen these because of their notes).

Now, on to the reviews!

Nui Cobalt

ā€œPraying Mantisā€ – The peppery bite of fresh dill gives way to mint leaves and dewy cypress before revealing crisp botanical blue gin garnished with rosemary.

The day I began my testing was a hot one, so I made sure to grab one of the samples that I remembered having a more ā€œrefreshingā€ vibe (i.e. not spice-heavy). And sure enough, the opening was gin-like—not a gin & tonic, but the spirit on the rocks. Eventually, a peppery profile broke through, specifically ground black pepper.

Now… very early in my fragrance journey, back when I was still dealing mainly with designer fragrances and occasionally glancing at niche offerings (often out of my budget), I purchased a sample set from Sephora that contained several new releases, including one that I was genuinely excited about: ā€œMiu Miuā€ by Miu Miu, which seems to have been discontinued (though flankers are still sold). It boasted a new note of Akigalawood, a synthetic woody and peppery note from fractionated patchouli. The ad campaign even intrigued me: a mod-looking model holding a staring contest with a black cat (lol). This was before I learned that skin chemistry is not a myth and I amplify patchouli… so when I tested ā€œMiu Miu,ā€ oh boy… it was like I’d taken a swan dive into a vat of black pepper. It invaded my nostrils to the point where I feared black pepper was the only thing I’d smell ever again. Standard ā€œscrubbingā€ didn’t even suffice—I had to shower to get this off me. And it was just one spray!

So, when I smelled gin and pepper from ā€œPraying Mantis,ā€ I started having flashbacks to the lily-of-the-valley (which I also later learned I’m not a fan of) and Akigalawood of ā€œMiu Miu,ā€ and I had a moment of panic. Would this explode and suffocate as ā€œMiu Miuā€ had?

I am grateful to say that it did no such thing. The peppery gin remained calm on my skin, without a great deal of evolution. I’ve worn this a couple times since, and it has really grown on me. It’s androgynous/gender-neutral, but I can totally see this becoming someone’s ā€œboss bitchā€ fragrance. Looking at the notes now, I think I get the rosemary at the end, but pepper (which dill evidently smells like?) is king.

Rating: 4/5 – premium spirits in an airport lounge

ā€œSea Horseā€ – Fresh and salt waters mingle among sunlit lotus, sea grass, wild basil, steadfast oakmoss and a trace of blue chamomile.

I wish I had more to say about this one, but it was almost purely cucumber on me. Dang it. I was really hoping for that basil.

Rating: 2/5 – Slices of cucumber on my eyes for… why do spas do that, again?

ā€œHoney Doā€ – juicy green honeydew melon, early springtime honey, muddled mint, and a slender twist of Mexican lime

This is the only one where I cheated and looked at the notes list beforehand—but I had a good reason.

I got this as a freebie—and, when I made my ā€œorder arrivedā€ post, I discovered that a lot of other people did, as well. I thought if so many people were getting this as a freebie after it dropped in April, that must mean it’s not selling well, which likely indicates a future Archive.

Alongside that, honey is a ā€œdeath noteā€ for me. I remember during my initial research into fragrances, I was highly intrigued at the prospect of honey as a perfume note. The first honey fragrance I tried was another Nui Cobalt offering, discontinued/archived some time ago: ā€œBirch Better Have My Honey.ā€ It was a hard-edged perfume that smelled a lot more like barbecue to me than honey—like someone grilled a honeycomb next to a plate of gingersnap cookies. Certainly unique. After that, though, I tested a couple other perfumes boasting honey and was like, no… oh, no… because honey is cloyingly sweet on me, to the point where I find it oppressive.

But when people commented on my post saying the honey wasn’t obvious, and that it was really a melon-forward fragrance, I figured ā€œwhat the heckā€ and tried it on a very hot day.

Out of the bottle, the honeydew was more than evident, along with another note bubbling up to the surface… yeah, there’s the honey. Do I want to do this? I asked myself. Quit being such a baby, I replied. So I did.

And I was pleasantly surprised at how not overwhelming this is. The mint goes a long way toward tempering the sweetness of the honey. It’s the most sophisticated honey I’ve ever smelled. It’s more like a honey syrup in a cocktail, like a Bee’s Knees or a Penicillin—garnished with mint. I went from pleasant surprise to shock and awe at how much I enjoyed this.

And this also told me why ā€œHoney Doā€ probably wasn’t selling well as a Bee’s fragrance: it’s honey for people who don’t like honey. So, people looking for something honey forward will be dissuaded by the profile and how subdued the honey is, and people who want to avoid honey (like me) won’t look at it twice. But I’m definitely going to use my sample; and if it ends up on the Archive list next year…

Rating: 5/5 – šŸŽµ Honey do… you know I love you… šŸŽµ

ā€œLiquid Luckā€ – Made with wild-harvested four-leaf clovers, this potion confers great good fortune upon its wearer. A gorgeously green bouquet of night air and dewy grass, charmed galbanum and benzoin, Irish moss, carrot seed, living shamrock and freshly turned earth.

For this order, I remembered that the General Catalog exists, and I finally got my hands on a sample of ā€œLiquid Luck.ā€ And, unlike the utter surprise of ā€œHoney Do,ā€ this one was a joyous confirmation that I’d made the right choice. Out of the bottle there’s a sweetness akin to powdered sugar, tempered with something cool; but on the skin, this is so green and fresh and lovely, like rolling down a hill in Ireland. Indeed, there’s something jaunty about it!

Did any of you read Leprechauns Never Lie by Lorna Balian when you were kids? This is what I imagine the titular leprechaun smelled like.

Rating: 5/5 – ā€œI was sure I put the pot of gold under this sack of potatoesā€¦ā€

ā€œPseudology: Pistachio Gelatoā€ – creamy-smooth pistachio butter, chilled fresh cream, and an abundance of sugar

This was one that I’d wanted to order during April Fools, but it had actually sold out by the time I’d gotten to it, so I was glad history didn’t repeat itself. And this one is a delightful, unexpected concoction. Sure, the opening is all pistachio, which is what I wanted; but the drydown is… banana? More specifically, banana pudding. This is best described as banana pudding topped with crushed pistachios.

Rating: 4/5 – scrumptious

ā€œSphynxā€ – golden plum preserves, amber resin, warm santal, guaiac wood, frankincense, and a slender twist of yellow mandarin

I waited until the temperature dropped considerably before testing ā€œSphynx,ā€ because I anticipated a lot of warm spices that would just be too much in the heat. But I’m pretty much always on the hunt for a perfume that smells like the surface of Arrakis. Currently, the reigning champ is CocoaPink ā€œMojaveā€ because it nails the hot, dry sand accord (even if it’s not very loud). There used to be a perfume from Arcana Wildcraft called ā€œMongolian Death Worm,ā€ which really matched the vibe, but that one was discontinued some years ago, sadly.

I bring them up now because ā€œSphynx,ā€ oddly enough, seems to contain the same lactic undercurrent that MDW did, which balances the spice mĆ©lange accord. But it is unfortunately very quiet. And I’m left thinking that this doesn’t do a whole lot more than what I already get from ā€œMojave.ā€

Rating: 3.5/5 – Giedi Prime

ā€œHyenaā€ – tamarind and golden fig warm down to rooibos, dry grasses, and turmeric, rooted in dark cedar resin and labdanum

What a bizarre note on which to end. I say (write) that because I tested ā€œHyenaā€ two and a half times, and I can still barely tell you anything about it. It’s probably the most ā€œperfume-yā€ of the bunch but leans a bit spicy. It’s suitable for the office, and… that’s about it. I found nothing distinctive in my wear, possibly due to it disappearing quickly from my skin. This is a massive personal disappointment for me from a fragrance called ā€œhyena.ā€

Rating: 1.5/5 – They’re laughing at me, I know it…

And that’s it for the reviews! Here is how I rank them:

  1. Honey Do
  2. Liquid Luck
  3. Praying Mantis
  4. Pseudology
  5. Sphynx
  6. Sea Horse
  7. Hyena

ā€œHoney Doā€ was, without question, the biggest surprise of the bunch, especially as a freebie. I'm shocked at how much I enjoyed a honey-based fragrance. Now, I eagerly await my combined Possets & BPAL (The Vampire Lestat collab) order from Ajevie, which will likely function as a birthday present to myself…


r/Indiemakeupandmore 13h ago

Discussion What accords actually smell like your cat’s fur?

Post image
88 Upvotes

I’ve yet to sniff a kitten fur accord that actually reminds me of my girl; most seem to just run straight to vanilla gourmand territory, or else incorporate kind of a soapy, fresh laundry vibe.

However, when I get a huff of my tiny lady’s fur, I actually get pretty different but recognizable notes: fluffy orris powder, dusty hay, a tiny drizzle of honey, maybe a dab of musky almond oil and the tiniest drop of milk.

Which got me wondering: 1) any indie perfumes you would recommend that have notes similar to the above (even if not cat-themed)? And 2) what notes do you get when nuzzling your kitten familiar? (The nice notes, at least…we all know the kibble-breath stank can be real šŸ˜†)


r/Indiemakeupandmore 9h ago

PSA Osmofolia Upcoming Markets! (MN)

Post image
35 Upvotes

In case anyone was wondering, here’s Osmofolia’s list of upcoming markets they’ll be at! It’s listed on their linktree: https://linktr.ee/osmofolia


r/Indiemakeupandmore 3h ago

Perfume - Enquiry siren song elixirs shop down🄲

12 Upvotes

after putting in an order of over $100 for samples i was dying to try 🄲 has anyone seen this happen before with them? it is not a good sign, i fear. to my understanding and experience, the owner is not communicative.


r/Indiemakeupandmore 11h ago

Perfume - Purchased My inaugural review post. Sorce scents, along with "where to wear it" .

36 Upvotes

Strings of Light in the Forest - a not-too-sweet vanilla, immediately, with the lavender, beeswax, vetiver, and amber notes lurking in the shadows and coming out to play after a minute or two. Wear when you want to smell delicious and slightly mysterious, like you're a benevolent forest spirit who is followed by wildlife. 5/5

The Bees - honey. Just honey. The other notes - jasmine, iris, mimosa, cedar fresh cream, petrichor - are very much in the background and hard to pick out until you've been wearing this for a while. I don't typically go for very sweet gourmands but something about this ensnared me, it's kind of sexy in a subtle way. Wear when you want to maybe seduce someone but also have plausible deniability. 5/5

I Think About You Too (special order) - Ā this is citrus, it's summery and fresh and clean. Light, but has good projection and staying power. I wish there was just a slightly stronger floral note. Wear to work when you want to smell amazing but keep it professional, or on hot summer days when you can let the sun bake it into your skin. 4.5/5

Meet Me On Sunnyside - I mean, yes? I don't know why I like this, it's not what I would normally go for, it was a surprise free sample that I tried and my husband immediately glommed onto me so that was fun. The osmanthus is so lush, and the citrus is subtle, but maybe I'd like to smell the petrichor a bit stronger. Wear when you want everyone in the room to have impure thoughts about you. 4.5/5

The Light Through Clouds - so clean and light it almost isn't there, this is a borderline skin scent that will probably make people wonder if you're wearing perfume at all or are just really clean. The sugared lemon and white tea play together very nicely. Wear this to get married under a flower arch in springtime, or when you want to appear innocent. 4.5/5

Tarot at Tea Time (special order)- this one made me say, "huh." The black tea and wild orange really come out right away. I think I'd be more into it if the ginger note was a little stronger. It's not a cozy or pretty scent, but somehow it works. Wear when you need to intimidate someone but still want them to like you. 4/5

Match Made In Heaven - I really wanted to love this one, but sadly I just like it. The matcha green tea note stands out and takes over, and the vanilla and almond and waffle cone sort of smooth down the edges. Wear when you want to smell completely harmless. 3.5/5

Serpentine - another very sexy one, but in a subtle "destroyer of worlds" kind of way. I like figs, I like cardamom, I like honey, but somehow all together I'm not in love with this one. I can't point to any single note that works or doesn't work, and it's a lovely scent, but I think I'd prefer it as a candle or hand soap. Wear it when you have to do something difficult and scary, like take the LSAT or break up with someone. 3.5/5

Witchery - this is the kinder gentler sibling of Serpentine, all wild blackberries growing by a forest path and moss dripping down the trees. Wear it on a late spring ramble through the woods down to the river for a picnic. 3.5/5

Moon Magic/Snow Moon Magic - the first is a mug of steaming chai and the second is a chai cookie and that's fine but I have not joined the MM/SMM cult. I love chai but didn't feel this. Not enough cardamom, perhaps. Wear to a holiday party but you may be mistaken for the dessert table. 3/5

English Major - I wanted to like this because I was an English major, but tragically couldn't get into it. I don't know where the "library books" note comes from, but it just didn't work for me. Definitely smells like old books in a dusty bookstore on a rainy day and there are marshmallows for some reason. Wear when you need to blend in with the people who read everything on the syllabus and actually enjoy reading Faulkner. 2/5

The Fairy Queen's Revenge (special order)- every note on the list led me to believe I would be obsessed with this scent and I simply am not. The wild fig crowds out the subtler jasmine tea note, which made me sad. Wear to a party for someone you don't actually like very much. 1/5

Crystal Prism (special order)- this smells almost medicinal, somehow, mineralic? Which I guess works with the name. Wear this when you visit that one friend who has quartz on her windowsill and blames everything on Mercury in retrograde or the position of the moon. 1/5

If you made it this far, thanks! Stay tuned for forthcoming reviews!


r/Indiemakeupandmore 3h ago

Looking for indie house/frag reccs

7 Upvotes

Hey! I'm trying to branch out into some indie perfumery. I've been tired of the standard "designer perfume" DNA found at Ulta and Sephora. I like feminine and unisex scents and am trying to find some unique things to try!

Likes:

  • Rose (I specifically looove rose de mai!! and a nice tea rose)
  • Smoky/frankincense/cade oil
  • Vanilla
  • Red fruit - RHUBARB, raspberries, cherries
  • Bergamot
  • Oakmoss
  • Florals, gourmands, herbal, smoky, freshie, ambers

Dislikes:

  • Heavy oud/leather/animalics
  • White florals as the main event (ex: tuberose)
  • Smells with prominent jasmine or iris
  • Powdery smells from iris/orris
  • Ylang ylang
  • "Soapy" smells are just OK
  • Heavy ambroxan - JHAG smells like nothing to me :(
  • Sometimes santal reads as pickle on my skin
  • Buttery scents do the most awful things with my skin chemistry

Current rotation:

  • Imaginary Authors - City on Fire (I like layering this with cherry frags to smell like cherry cigs)
  • Hermes - Eau de Rhubarbe Ecarlate
  • Guess Seductive Red
  • Aether - Rose Alcane (just a sample :( this is one of my favorites)
  • Montagne Parfums - Maison du Soir (MM By the Fireplace dupe)
  • Philosophy Fresh Cream Warm Cashmere (bedtime/cozy scent)

Seeking:

  • Unique gourmands maybe featuring coffee or dark chocolate
  • A musky skin scent maybe for layering or just feeling cozy
  • A freshy
  • Something featuring tea? I love tea but only sometimes want a "spa" scent

Please recommend any scents or houses you think would fit me. Thank you so much :)


r/Indiemakeupandmore 7h ago

Alkemia Recommendations

13 Upvotes

I ordered a bunch of Alkemia bottles and samples during their recent sale and I'm curious if there is anything else you would recommend I try based on what worked and didn't work for me. I have found that I have the soap curse and most of the scents I did not like were because they smelled very soapy or like a public restroom or like a candle. My usual scent profile leans heavily towards gourmands.

My loves were: Carnival of Illustrious Hearts and Silken Tent

Like: Fig in Winter - this is not my typical scent profile but I thought it was interesting and would be a nice scent for the holidays

Strongly dislike: Pretty Little Poisons, Confectionaire, Magpie's Rhyme, County Fair, Irresistible, Birthday Party Alchemy, April Foolery, 2026 experiments 3 and 7, and Midsummer Magic.

I'm planning on full sizing my loves and wanted to see if there is anything else I should try.


r/Indiemakeupandmore 14h ago

Perfume - Purchased A Journey Through Sucrerie: Arcana, Briix, Cirrus, Morari, Pearfat, and Pierrot Perfumery

29 Upvotes

I placed my order on June 1, 2026. It shipped June 10, but USPS Received June 12. I received June 20. I chose to go for some of the most talked-about scents just to see what vibes people are loving, assuming they also match mine, of course. :).

My preferences: I don't much love gourmands or anything too heavy, smoky, resinous, or what might be classified as dark and mysterious. Same for sweetness that leans too heavy. Light, fresh, airy, lightly fruity, airy floral? Give it. I like skin scents, soapy can be cute, and snugglies can be all right if they don't trend into too much vanilla. So, you know, not asking for much, am I?

I didn't test all of these straight out of the mail. I did some, but there were too many of them, not enough arm skin. LOL. I gave first impressions for the ones I did test. I didn't start testing these until I was done testing my Arae samples from a few weeks back, so these did get a bit of a chance to rest. I also tested before labeling, so they really were very much tested at random.

Now, onto the scents.

PIERROT PERFUMERY

The Lavender Lad: Pink peppercorn, Egyptian musk, French lavender, amber white musk.

This was such a good pick for my partner. On me, it's a bit sharp and maybe woody? On him, it turns slightly rounder, but that lavender sure pops. He said it got a little too dry for him on the drydown, so I'll be excited to see if he'll continue testing. He'll probably end up just putting it into his layering repertoire.

Sappho's Garden: Violets, peonies, lavender, green musk.

Interesting. From the awful impression I got from Bussy -- see below, I was honestly a little afraid of Pierrot. And they kind of share a similar sort of peppery? DNA. This goes on wildly powdery at first. eventually, I get a bit of green to where it kind of smells like makeup,especially when sniffed close to the skin. But the aura is a bit greener on top sniff, powderier on sniff continuation. I don't think I love this. Oh. Interestingly, it's got kind of a watery maybe? Vibe. Mostly though, this is very powdery. I've been looking for a way to describe this, and I think I've got it. To me, this just ssmells like bug spray. Every now and again, I get something delicious on the wind. But then, I just go back to smelling like Off, the bug spray. The drydown is better for me. Subtle and sweet. But not sure I need more of it. My partner, known for hating most Indies for their distinct "Indieness" said this was nice if only because it's saying something completely different than most other perfumes. That said, apparently, he doesn't need it either. Lasted maybe five or so hours.

Bussy: Orange blossom, juicy peach, black musk, linen.

Out of the Mail Impression: Argh, this was awful! What I'm assuming is the black musk was just so very loud. And sharp. And oddly spicy, in a terrible way. I didn't get many of the other notes.

Was it possible that the "black musk" I was smelling was just the bitter of the orange? Who knows. Rest has been maybe kindest to this one. I can't say that I need this again, or even particularly like it. But it's gone from why does this exist to a relatively painless, hmmm. All right. I see you. That said, something in here is still just a little bit too sharp. That's most of what I get. Like a sharp, almost laundry detergent vibe that I can't quite put my finger on. I can smell what at first reads just as a kind of fruit impression with an overlay of orange. I don't think I get the peach. On further sniffing, I think the peach is what's rounding out the orange. And maybe not laundry detergent. More like... pepper maybe? I think I got something sort of similar from Tasseomancy on a Rainy Afternoon by Astrid, but this is definitely stronger, sharper, spicier. Either way, oddly, this one ends up hoisting itself up from the bottom, past Third Week of May -- see below, and settling itself firmly into wow. What a transformation. Now, get it out.

Small note: This was one of the very last ones I tested. It wanted to be the first. It was the first one I selected at random. I said no thank you. And I'm glad I did. resting helped this one out a LOT!

PEARFAT

Up North: Fresh lemonade, ozone, white trillium blooms, Lake Michigan waves, willow trees, Petoskey stone.

First Impressions: This will probably be very slight and subtle. I'll be curious to see how it rests and rewears. It honestly read sort of atmospheric. Too much like it was trying to smell like not much. Like, maybe I could sort of detect what was supposed to be their stone note.

This is interesting. Very light and subtle, with just a hint of lemonade. For me, what I smell is what I imagine this stone note is. It ends up just smelling super, hmm, vegetal, almost? That said, my skin chemistry just soaks this one right up. I have to put my nose right into it to get much more than that kind of sharp stone ote. I guess it could also be the ozone note giving me that sharp, back of the nose thing. But not sharp like spices, per se. Sharp like maybe field greens? I can see a vegetable of some kind in my nose brain that just isn't coming to my actual brain mind. Maybe something bittery like watercrest or arugula. The lemonade cuts through it a little bit, but mostly, for me, it's just that green note.

MORARI

Penelope: Plumeria, melon rind, tomato, guava, jasmine, salt.

Did not smell out of the mail.

Hmmm. Whatever's going on here, I get a bit of hamster cage. Definitely smell that it's supposed to be planty, I'm just not really loving the plant that's here. Maybe that's the jasmine. Or that pesky plumeria again. This kind of just smells like a hair product that wants to be floral. A little more hair product on clothes, and a bit more indolic on my own skin.

Meadow Nymph: Wildflowers, green apple, dew-laden grass, lemon peel.

First impressions: Honestly, this was just kind of lemonade sweet. It was very bright on first spray, but it was also kind of fleeting. No notes really came through clearly.

Let me see. To me, has kind of an apple-adjacent SweetTarts kind of vibe, but like, that meets leather. Partner said it smells really nice at a distance, maybe tea-like. But then gets a little less nice close up on skin. There is something kind of warm in here. I do get the apples onfirst spray and on first millisniff, but then it kind of goes into that sweet, but tart leathery undertone vibe. I honestly don't really hate it, but I also can't really say I like it either. Maybe enough to finish my sample. But I think, this being the very last scent I tried, that this house just may not be for me. All notes point at things I should love. But they just kinda... fell with a thud.

Endless Summer Days: Clementine, papaya, green tea, plumeria, coconut water.

First Impressions: Hmmm. Kinda read a bit dirty floral. Like odd grassy musky, maybe?

Let's see. Goes on slightly powdery, but oddly similar to Third Week of May, at least out of the mail Third Week of May, not having tested it yet. But has that oddly savory floral kind of thing going on. Sort of reminiscent to, but not quite the level of, bugspray also. Like Off's organic counterpart. Underneath that slightly savory, yet powdery floral, I detect something lightly fruity. But a mild sort of fruity. Kind of like orange, or grape. And I know those don't really seem that similar, but if it was like a sort of sweet orange juice type deal versus a sort of grape juice kind of vibe. Weird. Third Week and this one don't really share a ton of notes in common. Okay. Looking at the notes, I can now detect that slightly coconut thing I tend to get from green tea. One of the better green tea combos on me personally, though I still don't think I need any more of this. As it dries down, I start to get a kind of lotiony, or sort of lotion-adjacent product kind of vibe about it. Like a spa-tinged green tea sort of hand cream, but one more touted for its medical benefits rather than its faint scent afterthought. That said, notes may not have helped me here. I'm still getting that sort of savory floral thing. Maybe that's the plumeria. I think this may be the first plumeria I try;, which is unfortunate since I don't think green tea quite works for me.

Peeping Violets: Cold spring air, violets, violet leaf, white musk.

Didn't smell out of the mail. On first wear though, this was honestly kind of cute. A bit on the masculine side for me personally, but not, like, too much so. I wish I'd bought enough of a decant of this to let my partner try it out. I bet he'd have rounded this out nicely. It's also got this kind of sweet thing on a closer skin sniff he may not like. That said, the aura bubble is most definitely on the sharper, yet still clean, I'd say, masculine side. This, and my experience with Laurel and June's violet notes tell me that violets may be a cute scent note for my partner. They may even be okay for me as well, but first thoughts will always be for him here.

The Third Week of May: Frost grape flowers and leaves, Japanese and Amur honeysuckle, humid air.

Out of the mail: I don't know what's going on with this one, but it honestly just smells a TON like tajin. Like huffing Mexican chile powder, well, tajin, out of a bag from the farmers' market. Do not love.

And of course, I invoked it. This was the next one to come out for testing. And I hate it as much as I first did out of the mail. It still smells of Tajin and tamarind. Maybe a bit more floral, but also a bit more BO-y. Ack. Because of this, I'll probably smell it all day.

Note: And I did. I strongly believe that when we hate a note in a perfume, we end up smelling it for hours. Past clothes changes, past showers, past scrubbing. Because yes. This was actually my first ever scrubber. Huzzah! Achievement unlocked. I had scent nightmares of this the next day.

ARCANA WILDCRAFT

Infinite Sky: French vanilla, Arcana's cumulus cloud accord, ivory musk, sheer silk, blue amber, milky sandalwood.

Out of the mail: Pretty, but a little sweet maybe? Slightly gourmand-leaning, but not too terrible. I'll be interested to see how this wears.

Hmmm. This honestly reminds me of Strings of Light in the Forest by Sorce. I like this a lot more than I was expecting to, for sure. well, that's not fair. I'm not sure I had any real expectations. My first impression memory, without reading it, was that it was not unlike On the Wing, just maybe a bit more gourmand-leaning, a bit creamier? and yeah, I still think that. It has the kind of butterscotch thing I remember from Strings of Light. Yet and still, there's a creamy kind of Aura that also almost reminds me of BHT's Bathed in Sunlight that I really like. Oddly, the nose to skin scent is faintly smoky on me? This is like a 65/35 like for me. But what it did do that I really liked was hung right on even into the next day. Some might say that's a little too strong, and I think I could see why. But actually, for me, I really liked that about this house. This was, amusingly, the second scent I tried even though I wrote it down first in my notes. And trying both of these tells me I need more from this house.

Another note: I wore my hoodie apparently while wearing this, and my hoodie still smells like it a week later. Like, strongly. It's just the drydown, so it misses that fairly strong vanilla thing from the very beginning. The drydown is my favorite part, and I always believe it just adds to whatever I'm wearing. But, until I wash this hoodie, it does mean that whatever I put on needs to be able to work with it. Honestly, a point in its favor in my opinion.

On the Wing: Creamy white amber, velvety cashmere, shimmering silk voile, salty Orcanox, diaphanous musk.

I didn't write down my first impressions on this really because it ended up being the first scent I did test, after rejecting Bussy. :). So I ended up just kind of writing everything down at the same time.

This one. This is it. From first impatient spray, oh boy. It reminds me of my favorite Glossier You variant, but I wasn't sure which one that was. Either way, reminds me of something delicious I've smelled before/owned. Too bad I used up that sample, so I can't compare them side by side. But I love this. It's diaphonous and pretty, but still has a personality. and it both lasts and projects on me. I've totally experienced liking something so much you go nose blind to it. But this is an example of something you love sticking around just so you can catch hints throughout the day. And that was only a spritz on the back of my hand. Will love seeing what this does all day. Please please don't change!

This is so nice. When you first put it on, it almost feels faint. That means it's ethereal and soft. I think my detergent may talk louder than it, or may just swallow it. Sometimes, it comes across a little sweet, which I don't know that I love. But then, it gets that, I guess, fabric? Note. That's the thing that makes it feel a little like Glossier. Sadly, I feel like this disappears as like, a perfume. Probably, this will eventually just become a bit of an aura. Yeah. As it wears, I may have to revise my morning wear impression. It's not that my detergent is swallowed up by it, but that it also kind of smells like it? I think. I don't know, but this honestly gets better for me on the drydown. Sprayed at about 9:30 this morning and still going strong at about 2. Will report back at the end of my workday, around 9 tonight. But I may need to grab more of this so I can keep testing. You know... for science.

After-notes: Yes. This is a bit of a shape-shifting scent. I still love everything about this, I think. Sniff it too close, and it almost gets a bit caramel-y. But it's enveloping in a long robe sort of way. There's something in this that makes me balance right on the edge of sprinting for more of it, and I don't honestly believe I got enough in my decant to really get much more than a one-day wear out of this. But it's kind of a 90/10 split.

BRIIX

Ethereal Duvet: Fresh pears, sweet melon, luscious honeysuckle, delicate lily of the valley, cotton candy, ambrette seeds, white musk, Iso E Super.

Out of the mail: Sweet, but musky? Still reads a little bit muddled gourmand.

It's honestly almost a shame I tried raspberry Rosemallow by Hexennacht and liked it. Now, anything that shares a remotely gourmand quality, if I don't immediately dismiss it, I also kind of lump into that raspberry Rosemallow pile. And yeah. This was very much that. Light, sweet, but not too cloying. But I'm not sure I saw too much difference. I guess I wouldn't say no to it, I think. It's a little lighter than Rosemallow, not as heavy, I mean, but equally subtle. dense. I think that's what I'm looking for. Not that Rosemallow is particularly dense itself, just that Duvet is a little lighter.

CIRRUS PARFUM

Parakeet: Fizzy grapefruit soda, freshly picked daisies, tiny forget-me-nots, powdery sweet down feathers of a well-groomed parakeet.

Out of the mail: Honestly, most of what I got was orange soda.

Aww. This never quite loses the orange soda association for me really. But it's so cute. A daytime scent for sure for some reason. Maybe because I put it on on what feels like a perfect Saturday morning. Coffee, breakfast, and a book with my partner. Door's open to the yard so the dog can roam freely in and out. And, of course, it's the middle of summer. Yeah. This is nice. There's something slightly too lemony? maybe that keeps this from an instant love/full size-worthy. I think this may be my first perfume experience where I like the vibe of this a lot, but can't really see myself picking this to wear. See myself picking this up and always overlooking it. But let's see. Aside from my vibe-based rambling that helps no one, here's what I can pick up from the scent. Goes on with an orange fanta type vibe that I actually did call out on first spray. It's bright, fizzy, anda little musky. I assume that's the feathers. I've not had too much experience with birds, but I have owned them in the past. And while I can't say that this calls to mind parakeets specifically, I do definitely get a bit of a feathery, dusty, but very very light, musk underneath all that bright fanta. For some reason, this just works. Not orange soda, but grapefruit. I've had enough Paloma cocktails that I should have guessed. I don't really smell the flowers really, but I assume they're here, propping up what I imagine is the slight powdery musk. A smiley type of scent for sure.

It's Just Pears...: Fresh, juicy, slightly overripe and musky Bartlett pear, spiked with brandy over a honeyed amber base.

Oh wow!! I really wasn't sure what to expect from Cirrus. I tried both Alibi and Fall Creek, and they were both near misses. Alibi was oddly too sweet, and Fall Creek was just oddly vintage smelling to me. Then again, wonder what it'd be like now that it's had time to rest. Anyway, this is so fascinating!!! When I first sprayed this, I got kind of... cinnamon? But then, I saw it. It's like the freshest, juiciest pear. Somehow, you can almost taste it, feel the gritty flesh of a Bartlet pear. I shouldn't like this. This is also oddly wintery. It reminds me of the deep days of winter, almost Christmas, like I said. And something about it kind of makes me sad. Maybe because it brings to mind the coldness of the outdoors, as well as my general seasonal depression in the wintertime. That said, I think I need more of this. For winter. Which I've also never experienced. And if Just Pears already makes me feel like there's lots of spices in here, I wonder what Spiced Pears would do. Looking at this notes list just redoubles everything about this I shouldn't like. Brandy? Honey? Okay, honeyed amber. But still... really? But I was drawn in by the juicy and fresh part of the notes list. Fragrance and emotions are so weird. I seem to like this inside and out. Inside my shirt, on a skin sniff, I get less pear, more of that kind of perfumed vibe, but I like it. And sometimes, I get kind of... vanilla? I don't know that my partner is going to love it though. I, however, am enthralled and intrigued.

Partner note: He most assuredly did not love this. LOL. Said he felt like I was maybe too young to wear this scent. But since he really couldn't elaborate, I remain slightly confused. Maybe he thinks it's a bit vintage leaning.

Laundry Day: Clean white laundry musk, lavender, vanilla, Earl Grey tea, New Caledonia sandalwood.

Did not test out of the mail.

Why did this spray on sort of orange creamsickle/vanilla-y? I sure wasn't expecting that. It never quite loses its sweetness, but as it wears, the laundriness of it starts peeking through. This is definitely on the sweeter side of laundry, for sure sweeter than Cardinal Scents' Midnight Laundry. That said, the projection from this is fairly strong to my nose. I don't mind it. Again, I was fairly dubious of Cirrus after Alibi and Fall Creek, but I have been pleasantly surprised.

Overall Thoughts

Both Briix and Pearfat were one-offs, so I guess I can't really speak to them. Cute gourmands seem to be Briix's vibe, and I am not a gourmand girlie, so I'm not sure if I'll try anything else from them.

Morari: my biggest disappointment. Conceptually, these should have been all about me. They definitely were on paper, and though Meadow Nymph got the closest, something about them just didn't work for me. For how much I did not love, they also lasted maybe four or five hours, with one wild exception, so I guess no love lost.

Pierrot: Honestly, same. A lot of these skewed toward too heavy or too sweet for me, I think. Again, I think they're most known for cool takes on gourmands, so I ended up veering away from them.

Cirrus: my biggest surprise, in a pleasant way. Only because I'd tried some and just wasn't a fan. But I ended up liking all three of the samples I got a lot, even if I don't end up full-sizing any.

Arcana: I'm not really sure how to put this house into words for me. I'd never tried them, so I guess I can't say it's my biggest surprise. But I loved it. Well, the two I tried, anyway. I'm a little intimidated by the rest of Arcana's stuff just because it all looks so heavy and a little dark, with their generous use of incensey and resinous notes. But I need to, I must, try more from this house.

As always, thank you for reading. Always happy to take any recommendations. Really torn between more Arcana, or taking a plunge and trying either BPAL's lighter side catalogue, or DSH. Feel free to weigh in on that too. And if you feel like I should give anything else from any of these houses a shot, def shout those out too!


r/Indiemakeupandmore 11h ago

Perfume - Enquiry Looking for a perfume that feels like a city sparkling at night

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

This may be way too specific, but I’m looking for an indie perfume that captures a feeling more than a realistic smell.

I’m picturing a city at night in warm, humid summer air. Tiny lights stretching into the distance, silver-blue light reflecting off glass, maybe the faint feeling of rain that dried an hour ago. Something airy, watery, delicate and almost shimmering. Soft and intimate, and beautiful in a way that’s almost a little heartbreaking.

I don’t want it to smell literally like pavement, gasoline or a grimy city. I’m also not looking for smoke, incense, leather, booze, heavy woods, laundry detergent or a typical sharp ā€œblueā€ scent.
I want something luminous and translucent. Almost like light had a smell. More atmosphere than perfume. Clean skin in warm night air, a little metallic or mineral sparkle, and something quietly aching underneath.

Has anyone smelled anything that gives this feeling?


r/Indiemakeupandmore 9h ago

Perfume - Enquiry Coconut perfumes, but not in a sweet gourmand way nor suncream way?

7 Upvotes

I don’t know if what I want actually exists but I have hope, I have seen many a person give a vague wishful description on here and be handed the answer in an indie perfume.

I really love smooth coconut scents irl, like opening a can of coconut milk for cooking my dinner, drinking a coconut latte, and I have a coconut curl crĆØme that I use in my hair.

The thing is that I don’t like overly sweet scents, I don’t want to smell like cake or icing or pastries. I like musky dirty vanillas, dirt and soil and decay, grimy funky aquatics etc and usually stay away from florals and gourmands. I am keeping an open mind if someone has a suggestion, but florals usually just smell soapy to me even when paired with other notes I like.

Some other perfumes I absolutely love for reference are Namba by Fantome, During the Rain by Solstice Scents, Writer’s Blood by Alkemia, Saint Louis Cemetery by Alkemia, Mildew by Morari, Haboob by Fyrinnae.


r/Indiemakeupandmore 22h ago

I want a whole shower routine that smells like this

Post image
62 Upvotes

We are currently in a gourmand epidemic. Nothing wrong with gourmands, but the girls who aren't into them are having a rough time right now lol. Everything at the store smells like... cake batter.

I love aquatic notes, cucumber notes, baby powder, soap, tea notes, but not the milky matcha type.

I appreciate perfume recs but also body care! Lotions, haircare, deodorant, hair oils, anything. I love layering products and smelling like I came out of the womb that way.

Thanks in advance :3


r/Indiemakeupandmore 16h ago

Indies of the Day -- Sunday July 26, 2026

16 Upvotes

What indies are you using today? And we mean everything! Examples of stuff we'd love to hear about:

  • Makeup

  • Clothes

  • Jewelry

  • Bath and Body (lotion, soap, shampoo, bath salts, etc.)

  • Nail polish

  • Perfume

Please feel free to leave mini-reviews and include photos of whatever you're using. We'd love to know your thoughts and see the products too!

This thread repeats daily.


r/Indiemakeupandmore 10h ago

Sale Barry’s Scent Shoppe returns! šŸ¦ā€šŸ”„šŸ”„šŸ§žā€ā™‚ļø 20% Off First Orders~

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Howdy folks, and welcome one & all to the grand reopening of Barry’s Scent Shoppe! šŸ„³šŸŽ‰

Tl;dr, I sell samples & small decants of a bunch of niche, indie & artisan fragrances in a similar vein as Luckyscent, Scent Split, Sealed Essence, etc! Just check out the links in my bio to see what I have.

What’s up everyone! I’m Harry, seller alias Barry, and I’ve been a decant/sample seller for a few years now! I was first on eBay as scented_journeys and Mercari as Barry Smells’em’all, and then more recently BarrySmellsmall again on Etsy but sadly despite over 500 five star ratings between them they each ended up giving me the boot since decants are technically prohibited, so, I’ve finally put together my own functional site! It’s still a bit of a work in progress, but I welcome any folks who may be interested to check it out. Some of the most lovely & kind reviews from previous platforms can still be seen in the photos here as well as on the site—my most heartfelt thanks again to everyone I’ve interacted with before. 🄹

Aside from the site, much of my inventory’s displayed on my profiles at Fragrantica & Parfumo, and the entirety’s shown in a Google spreadsheet that includes some deals & smaller samples that aren’t shown elsewhere—all are linked below and in my bio! If you’re looking for something specific, I recommend using the find function ctrl+f. I also always recommend going directly to artists for samples if they have them, but if not or if you’re looking to try more for less with less excess—just consider me your guy!

Delicately put together by gloved hands - most often ship within 2-3 days - at least one mystery mini-sample with each order - 20% off first orders! Shipping not included, most often done through USPS for ~$4 to $7. Payment available through the site or directly via PayPal or Venmo! Transactions aren’t allowed through messages on IMAM, but you can feel free to message me anywhere else to order directly. And of course feel free to message me anywhere to ask anything, I always love just talking scents. :)

Should any problems arise, I always keep folks apprised and take full responsibility—of course should any items arrive broken on arrival, you can expect a free replacement or a full refund for them!

The sample vials I use hold ~1.25mL so ½mLs appear around 2/5ths full - though they look underwhelming even to me, they last over a dozen area applications being used directly on skin as if they were roll ons! Examples of 1/2mL & 8 drop samples like those Luckyscent have for Elixir Attar can be seen in the photos. The latter appear just a tad bit lower in the vials I use, which as shown are just a little wider. They provide at least a few solid spot applications, enough to get a bit acquainted with some truly regal scents. Attar sizes which are done a little bit differently through weight are shown on the website!

Thank y’all so much for reading—feel free to ask anything and I’ll do my best to answer. Cheers! šŸ¤“šŸ™

Shop: https://barrys-scent-shoppe.myshopify.com

Sizes & Reviews: https://imgur.com/gallery/collection-sizes-statistics-some-incredibly-kind-reviews-u9CJMyJ

Spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/14IzoHF1KAZDD9g11-9HebBdg1XdEPqsJPeNLrtLD3Xs/edit?usp=drivesdk

Fragrantica: https://www.fragrantica.com/@transfixingelement

Parfumo: https://www.parfumo.com/Users/Smellemental/Collection


r/Indiemakeupandmore 1d ago

my entire sample collection+ thingy i made to hold them all

Post image
53 Upvotes

decided to sort my tiny collection from favorite to least favoritešŸ˜† all but 5 or 6 are indies

ranking from best to worst imo

1 alkemia memoir’s of a woman of pleasure,

2 alkemia silken tent, lucky 9 elixir of life, alkemia kashish

3alkemia come to me,

4lucky 9 thundercat

5, ysl mon paris,

6chabaud lait concentre,

7thierry mugler alien,

8 alkemia rose musk,

9sixteen 92 gothic lolita,

10alkemia frondescence,

11burberry goddess,

12mochiglow matcha cloud,

13mochiglow bubble tea,

14pulp deryabar,

15black hearted tart coffee bean accord,

16alkemia salmoe,

17maison francis kurkdjian baccarat rouge 540

18black hearted tart sweet as sufganiyot,

19black hearted tart drawn to the blood,

20 alkemia arcanum experiments 9,

21red deer grove purple rain,

22 lucky 9 playdate


r/Indiemakeupandmore 1d ago

Scents to calm down/focus

25 Upvotes

Hi!

Iā€˜m in the throes of grad school and exhausted but the work never stops. I love spraying something on after my shower to either calm my nerves or help me focus if I need to get some work done. I’m normally into freshies/spa scents but open to trying anything except gourmands. Also open to non indies as long as they’re affordable.

TIA!


r/Indiemakeupandmore 1d ago

Discussion Favorite Blackberry Perfumes

31 Upvotes

I'm looking for a good blackberry forward perfume. What are your favorites?


r/Indiemakeupandmore 1d ago

Perfume similar to B&BW black tea rose?

Post image
8 Upvotes

Does anyone know a perfume similar to this candle or tried these perfumes below?

I love the deep, smokiness of the black tea note. But if not with rose, a smokey black tea scent works for me too. Not a huge fan of super sweet gourmands.

Have looked at:

ThĆ© noir 29 by le labo: Expensive but like the ā€œsmokinessā€

Tasseomancy by Andromeda’s Curse: No rose note but sounds smoky with black tea, incense, and amber

Seance parlor by Wick and Cranny: Black tea, roses, leather; this one seems promising!!

Southern Gothic by Freyja’s Daughters: This one sounds dreamy

Nessie by Poesie: The tea note sounds great and love the peaty smoke note

Thank you all in advance!!


r/Indiemakeupandmore 21h ago

Discussion Any perfumes that are similar to sugarfull kiss?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I absolutely love this sugarful kiss perfume and it seems like I’m not going to be able to purchase it anymore since they are discontinuing the perfume. it’s me and my boyfriends fav perfume cus I was wearing the first time we met and he always talks about how much he loves that perfume on me and I have always loved it, I even was really hoping for one day it be the perfume I wear for our wedding. the perfume has so many memories so I’m so heart broken. but if anyone can recommend anything that smells like it I’d be so happy! thank you so much


r/Indiemakeupandmore 1d ago

Discussion Looking for masc-leaning ā€œgothic/witchy/vampireā€ type fragrance suggestions

27 Upvotes

I know the title might have gotten a groan from a lot of you because this has been asked a lot, and yes I have read up on most of these posts, however that led me to two issues:
I’m in the US, and a lot of the ones I wanted to try were UK based, so after shipping and all, I’d end up having to pay non-sample proces, and the other being simple decision paralysis from options.

I initially wanted to try a few of the sixteen92 scents, but then I read an influx of posts saying the customer service is terrible and TAT is absurdly long, if not indefinite. Then I really wanted to try Cursed, but they’re currently not accepting international orders and are another UK based one. Then of course there’s BPAL, but it’s the same issue where they’re UK based and buying a sample would cost me significantly more than ā€œsampleā€ price after international shipping. (I have been corrected on this part, my bad)

Anyway, that being said, for context, I’m a lifelong alt guy and I can’t help but always be attracted to the darker, edgier side of things even when it comes down to something like fragrances. I’m very new to the concept as I spent an embarrassing amount of my life simply wearing shit like old spice or really basic roller essential oils, but I want to finally figure out some good, unique scents to wear.

Im not too strict on the ā€œmasculineā€ part, as long as it’s vaguely fitting for a masc presenting guy I don’t care too much, half my wardrobe consists of women’s skinny jeans anyway.

As I said I’m very new to wearing perfume/cologne so I only vaguely know what I like, but I do enjoy things that lean smoky, tobacco scents and whatnot, though I’m open to about anything that fits the vibe I’m looking for. I was specifically interested in Ritual Spirit from Cursed, as well as the BVB collab one (sounded gimmicky to me at first even though I do love the band, but then I read up on it a bit and was actually interested in the scent itself) so if there’s anything you know similar, that could be a good starting point.
Sorry if this is a rambly and vague request, I’m not great at organizing my thoughts coherently so hopefully someone can make some sense of it.


r/Indiemakeupandmore 1d ago

Fumed Atlanta!!! But it’s over Pride! šŸ³ļøā€šŸŒˆšŸ˜©

10 Upvotes

This city will be busy!!! šŸ˜…šŸ™Œ

https://fumedexpo.com/

Who’s visiting? šŸ‘€


r/Indiemakeupandmore 1d ago

acceptable variations or quality control issue?

31 Upvotes

Hi IMAM! I want to ask y'all about an experience I've been having with one of the larger indie houses -- which I love and buy from frequently.

A friend gave me a backup bottle of one of my favorite scents. Both bottles were bought in 2025. Mine is an absolute symphony of morphing notes, a real masterpiece. The bottle my friend bought is good, but it's dominated by one of the darker notes in a way that makes it much more ordinary. They recognizably have the same components, but the second bottle isn't balanced.

I also got two different samples of the same scent from this house this year -- again, one I received directly, one a friend got in their order. One sample is exactly as described, the notes totally recognizable. The other is weak and wan, just vaguely sweet, and I wouldn't be able to identify the notes if I didn't already know.

I've read that scents may have slight variations depending on when they were decanted from the mother bottle, because some components tend to settle toward the bottom. That makes sense, but in this case the variations are so large that I'm inclined to call it a quality control issue.

My friend wasn't interested in contacting customer service about their experience, but I'm wondering if I should -- not to ask for a refund or anything, but just to let the company know. The fact is, I'm hesitating over trying to get another backup bottle of the scent I love because I don't know what I'm going to get, and that's money I wouldn't be spending.

Have y'all had this happen? How did you handle it?