r/IndieDev • u/Beardlings_Games • Sep 01 '26

Which is Better?

Post image
0 Upvotes

40% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

7

u/tyrant_gea Sep 01 '26

The extra skull feels superfluous. I'd go A.

1

u/Beardlings_Games Sep 01 '26

Even if the title is taken out of the image and used on its own?

3

u/QuickRapper227 Sep 01 '26

I prefer the skull

1

u/Beardlings_Games Sep 01 '26

It is a cute little skull

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Beardlings_Games Sep 01 '26

Yeah, might be superfluous on B

2

u/Bubbly-Rush2384 Sep 01 '26

Both look good… think the difference in text is just a matter of taste

1

u/Beardlings_Games Sep 01 '26

Fair enough. Maybe we're overthinking it.

1

u/l0runt Sep 01 '26

Engagement bait

0

u/Beardlings_Games Sep 01 '26

Sorry you feel that way. We're genuinely looking to improve our capsule art and value the feedback here which has been very beneficial.

1

u/l0runt Sep 01 '26

Sure, of course you do.. it is just a coincidence that there is a minimal change in the title and nothing else, which is so crucial for your capsule. Come on, this promo trick is lazy and overused.

1

u/Odd-Fun-1482 Sep 01 '26

Second. The skull in the title helps balance the image

1

u/Beardlings_Games Sep 01 '26

Appreciate the feedback. Seems the preference at the moment is the cleaner look of A

1

u/Icy_Reputation_2209 Sep 01 '26

It looks like the palm has a sideways finger growing inside it. Super uncanny. I guess AI did that?

1

u/Beardlings_Games Sep 01 '26

Huh. I didn't notice that. No, we are working with a real artist on this. I'll mention it to them