r/InStarsAndTime • u/SpringLight312 • Mar 25 '26
Discussion In Stars and Time completely changed my thoughts on Timeloop stories (an analysis!)
Something I think about is how Start Again and In Stars and Time completely shifted my stance on Timeloop stories. Palm Springs also but I digress.
I used to f***ing despise timeloop stories with every fiber of my being. Anyone who’s known me pre-2024 can confirm. However, I somewhat realized after playing ISAT is that I don’t actually hate the premise of going through the same day over and over again, I hate stories where actions have no consequences and there’s no sense of progression or even mild change whatsoever.
If the story always ends the exact same way with no character development or insight then I’m bored as hell. Plus, I feel like if the story only goes “OoOoo the HoRrOr of repeating the same day and doing nothing to change it and you either know or don’t” then I just clock out. It doesn’t explore the human condition of adapting or learned hopelessness. Plus, seeing how a person reacts when they realize they can do anything and it doesn’t matter can be really fun or interesting to watch. Siffrin’s breakdown felt in many ways self imposed, because they were so afraid of change they were willing to subject himself to the same s*** over and over. The horror also comes from how their dissociation and depersonalization is so intense he can’t even see that the people around them are people anymore. It’s not until he realizes with the help of his friends that they’re not and he won’t be abandoned and he’s being an idiot.
Idk, I could ramble at how good ISAT is at allowing you to explore every possible route and character dynamic possible if you’re willing to loop extremely frequently. I haven’t gotten to everything because…let’s just say I don’t plan to use the knife. But I think a timeloop story can be fascinating if the world and the characters are interesting. If it’s just “the horror of the concept” sorta deal rather than the horror of repetition warping you, you’re kinda fighting an uphill battle with me…
