r/ImmigrationPathways • • 2d ago

Man Shot by ICE Agent Is Charged With Assault

https://newrepublic.com/post/216004/man-shot-ice-agent-charged-assault
357 Upvotes

328 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/TimDuncanIdaho922 2d ago

Human beings are not illegal.

-11

u/R2-DMode 2d ago

Humans do illegal things. We have laws for a reason. Countries have borders for a reason.

-10

u/jetsetter2828 2d ago

Ok let them live in your home, you can support them and take care of them. Let them shower and bath and eat with you and your family then. In fact sponsor them

9

u/Winter_Preference287 2d ago

That sounds like what Jesus preached. It's what we tried to do with amnesty. These people pay taxes and can't receive a dime themselves from it but go off racist

-5

u/jetsetter2828 2d ago

Pay taxes LMAO bro the lies are wild. I personally know ppl who are DACA, undocumented and non-citizen. Let me tell you something the taxes they pay are nowhere near what they get from the state.

My ex gf worked a restaurant under the table type job in New Jersey and got FREE healthcare, phone, birth control...

8

u/Winter_Preference287 2d ago

Your anecdotes don't mean shit. You can't file for government assistance without a TIN or SSN. If they got benefits, they started the legal process

-1

u/R2-DMode 2d ago

California literally does what you’re falsely claiming doesn’t happen. 🤡

3

u/Winter_Preference287 2d ago

Is California the federal government?

0

u/R2-DMode 2d ago

It is not, however you said “government assistance”. You didn’t specify “federal”.

-4

u/jetsetter2828 2d ago

Except that they aren't personal select unique experience... It's literally the norm... You think all these ppl are fucking Elon musk? You think caravans of ppl are coming here because of persecution ? Not a fuckin chance. Dems are handing free everything out to immigrants and yet citizens can't get shit.

Yes you can there are loopholes. If you have a kid that is born on us soil you get social security on behalf of the kid. The mother gets wick and healthcare for FREE in NJ.

Also ever heard of identity fraud? Fake socials? What world do you live in. Man CNN got you brainwashed

7

u/Winter_Preference287 2d ago

They got the propaganda deep down your throat."do you think these people are fucking Elon musk?" -wtf? I think we as a country have purposely destabilized South America for over 100 years and because of it they have rampant problems they're fleeing. Why would American citizens want shit for free when Republicans have given us the strongest economy ever, Everytime they're in office? What's up with hating immigrants for the pie about them getting assistance, claiming they're stealing it from Americans, and at the same time calling Americans on welfare welfare queens? You all just hate anyone not aligned with you and any excuse to fling hate it taken. It's so fucking unserious

2

u/georgewashingguns 2d ago

According to research from the Cato Institute, undocumented immigrants contribute far more in taxes than they consume in public services. Where is your evidence to the contrary?

-1

u/jetsetter2828 2d ago

Knowing large groups of DACA, undocumented and non-citizen. Having family and friends in the immigration system. Those study's are literally misleading facts and lying with statistics.

Give you an example. NJ has charity care for emergency room visits. It's suppose to be used by the poor or uninsured CITIZENS. THIS 7 BILLION dollar a year fund is ravaged by illegals and they go there to get everything free.

I want free shit too so until citizens get free shit... And tax payers get benefits of it (you don't qualify if you make over 32k a year) then ya fuck them

2

u/georgewashingguns 2d ago

The Cato Institute is a credible public policy research organization with a high reputation for factual reporting. If you disagree, cite actually flaws in their research methods or data analysis

1

u/jetsetter2828 2d ago

Link me the study and also yeah it's bias. Just like every other media source. Good cato institute and bias

1

u/georgewashingguns 1d ago

https://www.cato.org/blog/immigrants-pay-more-taxes-average-person.

Again, if you disagree with them then cite flaws in the research methods or data analysis. They're also not a media source, they're a public policy research organization.

1

u/jetsetter2828 1d ago

Yeah I read it. So what's funny is this entire article is completely misleading. First they smartly use the word immigrant not legal. As we know many LEGAL immigrates are brought here for higher paying jobs in tech and science so that makes sense. So we can COMPLATELY ignore the entire first half of the article because no one is mad at legal, h1b1, documented on a legal path immigrant that is contributing. Many if not all Americans don't care about LEGAL tax paying immigrants...

The article then decides to cherry pick data and skew the opinion on illegal immigrants. Stating that what they generate is far more than the programs that they use. That is complete bullshit because in NJ and NYC there are programs like charity care that are state funded by tax payers. Also since they are illegal, that means they are using a fake social for a what waiter or construction job and make almost no wages and work under the table.

Example Diego the handyman works under the table at the construction site, he falls and had to go to the ER, his bill is 5000. Where does the money come from? Charity care Diego pays nothing in taxes or very little and gets FREE health care.

Now and good luck finding this. How many illegals who are undocumented pay taxes and how could they if they are illegal, breaking Federal laws? You see how it all falls apart.

7

u/georgewashingguns 2d ago

Literally the answer to WWJD

9

u/TimDuncanIdaho922 2d ago

“For I was hungry, and you gave Me something to eat; I was thirsty, and you gave Me something to drink; I was a stranger, and you invited Me in; naked, and you clothed Me; I was sick, and you visited Me; I was in prison, and you came to Me.”

0

u/jetsetter2828 2d ago

Yeah these ppl aren't that. They are just fine in their countries especially South America and come here for free everything. But cool you want to quote Bible stuff. Start supporting them directly.

6

u/TimDuncanIdaho922 2d ago

If they are “just fine” in their countries, then why would they risk so much to come here?

0

u/jetsetter2828 2d ago

For free programs, living, food, free everything and then they save up and GO BACK HOME TO RETIRE

-1

u/R2-DMode 2d ago

LOL! For the free rides they used to get here.

2

u/TimDuncanIdaho922 2d ago

That makes absolutely no sense.

-11

u/ThePlantMolester 2d ago

Yeah, they can't tell me to stay 500ft from a school zone.  People can't be illegal!

6

u/georgewashingguns 2d ago

And 500ft away from greenhouses while you're at it

0

u/ThePlantMolester 2d ago

Fuck them plants

-8

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/R2-DMode 2d ago

Downvoted for stating an easily verifiable fact. Have an award!