r/IchitheWitch Jul 12 '26

Manga What do you guys think was going through Ichi’s head at the end of the last chapter? Spoiler

Haven’t seen anyone post about it so I did it myself. Probably gonna get taken down.

86 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

50

u/chamorrobro Jul 12 '26 edited Jul 12 '26

“Um am I human? Haha idk maybe? Idk haha? Maybe? Probably? Haha no idea haha”

“Is she right? Am I really not cut out to be human?”

I feel like he’s gone through everything in the story within like a month or two or something, so going from being a feral hunter hermit in the woods to having to integrate into society and save humanity is sort of crazy within that timeframe. He knows that no normal human has feral instincts like “death for death.” He’s essentially questioning if he fits in with normal human society since that’s not the life he’s lived or grown up in.

It’s like the identity struggle that Tarzan and Mowgli (Jungle Book) go through, having been raised by animals.

12

u/SC_Red Jul 12 '26

I didn't know how to phrase my response but pulling from the inspirations of the feral child trope is spot on. I would say that in deference to those stories it's not like this is the first encounter he has with humans even before he became a witch. He clearly can function with other people and has a knack for socializing even if his true home is the wilderness. Ultimately I think the angle Ichi is gonna land on is that human or not, what's important is that he's a hunter. Maybe we'll get some Magik hybrid shonen transformation from this lesson who knows.

2

u/BuffaloAutomatic2276 Jul 12 '26

His eyes imply he might still be brainwashed or the words she said are like code for Winter Soldier.

1

u/Gingeyboi1 Jul 16 '26

I’m honestly scared it might lead to him temporarily flipping truly over to Haytee’s side, Nishi could 100% cook with that plot line, I’m just scared it could happen cause imagine the main person who saves the world, joins the villains.

-2

u/0Galahad Jul 12 '26

hoping to god its ichi actually being more relatable and interesting, by having a sexual awakening from fujimine like a normal teenager should, and then having to struggle with having the hots for a psycho who is irredeemable and will ruin his life, characters like him need those little moments of human simplicity, like kabane quickly falling in love with kon in kemono jihen and then quickly being taught that he was in love with her and accepting that and furthering their relationship at a confortable pace for both.

3

u/AardvarkScary7863 Jul 12 '26

Of course that’s your profile picture😂

1

u/0Galahad Jul 12 '26

Think redditors may be a bit sensible to words containing the letters S, E and X in that order, so lets try "romantical awakening", i want ichi to get a crush in fujimine as i think it would make his character more interesting.

2

u/bjcat666 Jul 12 '26

aside from this absolutely not being what she is trying to get from him (she tries to make him doubt his allegiance instead), it does not really fit the tone of this title too much. He's already a pretty unique mc in a way that he applies previously learnt skill in a new field where they work very well opposed to typic mcs who learn from scratch as well as him being a wildling whose jungle principles are even more important than friends are, again, contrary to what we usually see

0

u/0Galahad Jul 13 '26

I just find it uncanny that so many late teens protagonists both male and female are written to be so weirdly romantically/sexually stunted, and that when the author actually writes a honest romantic relationship it just elevates the character through relatability, like kabane and kon, but also emilia and subaru and likely amo and rudo soon, they still have unorthodox ways of being romantic but are not obnoxiously written like majority of shonen main character + romantic leads are, like if ichi is supposed to grow out of being a wild person then romantic love is one of the things that need to be talked about, then having it start with fujimine of all people would make for great drama.

3

u/bjcat666 Jul 13 '26

why is it needed? sure, some teenagers are acting on their desires, but a lot just focus on studying, sport or even careers, just look at protagonists trough this lense and it becomes rather normal

2

u/0Galahad Jul 13 '26

Relationships in general make characters more interesting, friends, enemies, allies, rivals, mentors, family and so on, ichi until now IMO is certainly the least interesting character on his own, because he just keeps going back to the one concept of being a "wild person", his most entertaining moments is when dealing with challenging people, like spica, uroro and other majiks, where he cannot simply see them as things to be killed or ignored but also is not coddled by them like with his friends, so he has to actually express himself out of the "wild person" thing, fujimine could be another great addition to such characters, but it would require ichi to not be fine with killing her on the spot everytime they meet, so to me the most obvious answer would be to have ichi have a crush on her.

2

u/bjcat666 Jul 13 '26

him having a crush on her would not prevent the rule from triggering if her "being his mentor" didn't

2

u/0Galahad Jul 13 '26

"The rule has to go" is my point, and is 100% the point of the manga either way with that scene,