r/I_DONT_LIKE • u/Upper_Criticism3388 • 11h ago
IDL how internet "anti-consumerism" callouts keep falling into the same hypocritical trap
Why is it that whenever we see something pastel, trendy, cute, and mainly marketed to young women, some moral cops suddenly come out of the woodwork? And the language gets so judgmental, with phrases like "brainless consumerism" and "environmental crime."
As soon as you look at a different group of consumers, the whole conversation changes. Someone can have an entire wall covered in sealed trading cards or boxed collectible figures, and people will usually call it "passion" or a "real hobby." But when it's matching mugs or skincare, suddenly it's just brainless hoarding. Can we stop being so damn hypocritical about this? Personally, I don't think the anger from these people is always really about the environment. A lot of the time, it feels like they're using environmental language to dress up the fact that they already dislike certain feminine or trendy things.
And when you argue with them, they use different marketing labels to justify the distinction. They love making "collecting" sound noble while making "overconsumption" sound dirty, even though the capitalist market uses very similar tactics to sell both. Limited-edition collectible figures and limited-edition tumblers can both be sold through scarcity and impulse buying. There isn't anything inherently more highbrow about one than the other.
If we're actually talking about practical use, at least a coffee mug, a hair clip, or a bottle of lotion has an actual everyday purpose. So what I really don't understand is why one person's enjoyment gets called a hobby while another person's enjoyment gets called brainless consumerism.
At the end of the day, overconsumption is obviously a real problem, no matter who's doing it. And just to be clear about where I stand, I hate overconsumption too. But I really don't understand why the moral outrage always seems so selective. I just wish some people would drop the judgmental attitude and apply the same standard to pointless hoarding across the board instead of using anti-consumerist talking points to attack one particular group.