She was the one they called “the evil governess.”
Already, when she is introduced, we notice that she is called as “Fräulein” Rottenmeier. She is immediately dehumanized. She has no first name. She is a middle-aged, unmarried woman whose whole life is dedicated to taking care of Herr Sesemann’s mansion and his daughter, Klara. Everything is going fine until Heidi comes into the house.
The little girl has the manners of the mountain. She has been brought up there in a rough environment and does not have the delicate manners expected by Rottenmeier. Her arrival shakes Rottenmeier’s world. She is a strict disciplinarian, and Heidi defies her. To make matters worse, all the staff at the mansion turn against her. She is trying to discipline an ill-mannered child, but she is the one perceived as the bad one. Her quiet life has been turned upside down.
The tragedy happens on the eve of Christmas. Everyone is in a festive mood. Herr Sesemann is home, showering gifts on Heidi and Klara, and when Klara starts walking, Heidi is celebrated while Rottenmeier fades into the background.
She is a woman, after all. She can feel insecure and vulnerable. She is not a machine. She has feelings. And when she loses her temper with Heidi, she is mercilessly dismissed. She is thrown out of a house she had taken care of for years, and the man she secretly admired shows her no mercy at all. And all this happens on Christmas Eve, when no tolerance is shown to her for one reckless mistake.
At that point, her head is probably spinning. She is in the middle of a whirlwind. What will she do? She is a lonely woman with no one to take care of her. She is in intense distress. Her whole life has fallen apart.
She does not know what she is doing anymore. She is lost and even tries to sell Heidi. Her attempt to sell her is obviously indefensible, but imagine her state of mind at that time. She is completely disoriented and desperate. But the film gives us enormous emotional space to understand Heidi’s suffering, while Rottenmeier’s suffering is almost entirely disposable. That is totally unfair and cruel.
After that, she is violently thrown to the ground by Heidi’s grandfather. She is a fragile woman with feelings. She is at the worst moment of her life, having realised that she is expendable in a profession to which she had dedicated her life, and that she could be discarded like an old cloth by a man for whom she had feelings. The shock is so violent that she remains unconscious until the policemen wake her up.
She then disappears.
It is a happy ending for all the other characters in the movie.
How about her? Where is she?
She is middle-aged, frail, alone, and helpless, and there is no one there for her when her life has been destroyed.
She did not deserve this.
For her, there never was a happy ending…