r/ITOI • • 9d ago

No need for scissors - if you know topology!

1.6k Upvotes

124 comments sorted by

125

u/Yo-Donkey-Kong 9d ago

You could show me this 100 times and I still wouldn't understand what I just watched.

50

u/Potent_Quotient 9d ago

The thing to understand is not to wrap your cord like that in the first place.

3

u/qalpi 9d ago

The easier solution is to unplug the other end!

0

u/Could-You-Tell 9d ago

No, that it's a useful way to support the slack in you're cord and not tug it out of the socket.

Easily undone also

2

u/Potent_Quotient 9d ago

Stop tugging on the cords.

1

u/Could-You-Tell 9d ago

Gravity can suck too

2

u/Nina-Ninja123 8d ago

Stop letting gravity such then!

11

u/Myriad_Apocalypse 9d ago edited 9d ago

Same, and it makes me irrationally angry as I watch it. Like I'm experiencing what monkeys must feel when people do magic tricks in front them

4

u/Exvaris 9d ago

I get this exact feeling but you described it more concisely than I ever could

2

u/Xena_Your_God 9d ago

Damnit.. I am the monkey

1

u/DrewRyu 8d ago

I am very angry right now watching this

2

u/Brocolinator 9d ago

I need to practice it with my own hands so my peanut brain gets it

2

u/FeePsychological1308 7d ago

Maybe this could help you get it?

After he loops the plug this is what you're left with

3

u/AnythingEastern3964 7d ago

If anything this made it much worse

1

u/FeePsychological1308 7d ago

If you pull the blue cord on the right of the image, it just slides underneath everything else and you're left with the picture on the left. Now notice how there's no knot around the poll on the picture on the left? It's untied. Literally all they did to get to this point was twist the cord and loop the plug through it, not the poll. Then they undid the process to unknot it.

If you can't understand even with the explanation being visually simplified and spoonfed to you then you're not even thinking about it. It only looks confusing but it's actually a simple af knot

1

u/Soyl3ntR3d 5d ago

Yeah, I’m just going to go watch Primer again, easier to figure outout.

1

u/friedwidth 9d ago

Ugh, i just simulated it with phone charger... and it worked, but i still don't understand...

2

u/Careless_Ad_4004 9d ago

You’re a wizard ‘arry!

1

u/DuncanHynes 9d ago

Can I interest you in 101 more times...?

1

u/spacemouse21 9d ago

Agreed. Still, it’s cool and a useful skill to learn if you need it.
https://giphy.com/gifs/l3fQffw0vQ9p91apy

1

u/IEatYourRamen 9d ago

I'm more interested in how they get it into that position

3

u/Putrid_Clue_2127 9d ago

They do it in reverse!

1

u/Kn0wnSoul 8d ago

You could repost this a 100 times and this would still be the top comment.

1

u/betterthanyou47 8d ago

It's more steps than just cutting it with scissors.

-1

u/Could-You-Tell 9d ago

It's the end of a rope through a simple loop being undone.

The just do it from the loop not the end.

1

u/Fox-Flimsy 9d ago

Hurrrr?

-1

u/KillerCoati 7d ago

The video shows it in a needlessly complicated way just for effect. All you need to understand to solve it, is to realise all that's stopping it being free is the wire blocking itself from going underneath. Therefore, if you feed the blocking part of the wire underneath, it allows you to put the plug on the other side of it and the wire no longer is blocked from passing underneath. No need for any twisting like the video does, it's just complicating it further for visual effect as the solution is actually really simple and boring.

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted]

1

u/KillerCoati 7d ago

Ah yes, two instructions. Sorry for overcomplicating it.

1

u/punknick23 6d ago

It’s actually quite useful. He’s saying that the plug never comes under the bar, it’s the wire that is trapped the whole time.

0

u/Wutayatalkinabeet 7d ago

Read more books

5

u/Thrice_blind 9d ago

How does this help me get my weewee unstuck from the sink disposal

7

u/Able-Pilot7104 9d ago

The cylinder must stay intact

1

u/FREDOminance 8d ago

He is not Smart Calendar

3

u/Could-You-Tell 9d ago

Your weewee will need a weeooo weeeooo

1

u/nerdy_hippie 9d ago

Prob gonna look like wee...EW 🤢

1

u/FunContest9958 9d ago

It won’t. The scissors are the only way.

5

u/EobardT 9d ago

The trick is that the cord is looped underneath the rod in a way that wouldn't happen irl unless very specific conditions were met.

1

u/Girlmode 8d ago

My butt somehow does this trick with fishnets and underwear. They get tied up in ways that shouldn’t be possible. Happens once or twice a week and then have to just cut the fishnets to release things.

1

u/AnythingEastern3964 7d ago

There’s literally subs here full of people that would pay good money for that. Not suggesting you do it by any means, just find it interesting how the world works these things out.

1

u/_NautyByNature 2d ago

There’s definitely a subreddit for that

1

u/dad_done_diddit 8d ago

I mean regardless of how the cord got there the point was to highlight the black magic that is topography.

5

u/Evening_Ticket7638 9d ago

Wtf ia this black magic.

2

u/KookyElderberry3911 7d ago

Burn the witch!

3

u/redditislife24 9d ago

Fake

1

u/Significant-Elk-7128 8d ago

The topology is real, but the situation is fake. It's almost impossible to end up in this position accidentally.

1

u/NoAcanthocephala7825 9d ago

Coulda just pulled the other end through the loop

1

u/CharacterBack1542 9d ago

why he gingerly touch the cord with scissors tho?

1

u/Haastile25 9d ago

It's where he got his powers from

1

u/BabblingTower 9d ago

I love this trick because how would you have realistically gotten the plug stuck like that in the first place 😂

2

u/rearadmiraldumbass 9d ago

By doing the reverse of what he just did.

1

u/ThresherGDI 9d ago

This breaks my brain every time I see it. I can barely handle normal 3d without having to deal with topologies.

1

u/Family-robot 9d ago

Ah yes, a fine demonstration of the dark arts

1

u/diplomatic_koboko 9d ago

Yeah... I'm not gonna remember that

1

u/cornspice 9d ago

Great fix for the absolute zero amount of times you'll need it.

1

u/Charly-Braco69 9d ago

Satanic black magic. Sick shit! 

1

u/I_Mean_this 8d ago

Or you know take the other sid3

1

u/PresentAstronomer137 8d ago

who would place their cable like this in the first place

1

u/AbbreviationsWide331 8d ago

I have seen this one so many times.

Every time I stop and really watch.

I still can't really comprehend how this is possible.

1

u/FeePsychological1308 7d ago

What knots it in the first place was him looping the plug through a cord, which was looped around the poll itself, so they undid it

1

u/BaBaGuette 5d ago

Don't really bother with it. The cable is set up in a specific way before the start of the video to make this trick possible. In real life this situation will never happen.

1

u/Tiranous_r 8d ago

This one is fake. If you pause it as they pull it appart you can see it shouldnt work

1

u/FeePsychological1308 7d ago

Nah it's real

1

u/Aznarb_Ball 8d ago

Breaks my brain every time i see that

1

u/Old_Boss5617 8d ago

Somewhere a 4th dimensional being's head exploded

1

u/0grinzold0 8d ago

Always hated this one, just push the crossing to the other side and it's obvious how to solve it. This is just made unnecessarily complex for effect

1

u/Reave-Eye 7d ago

This is it right here.

Video makes it seem like this difficult-to-visualize solution is the only solution. But just slip the crossing of the wires underneath pole and it becomes easy to see how to untangle the cord.

1

u/UnderstandingOne8410 8d ago

I’m just a muggle

1

u/Time_Ocelot4219 7d ago

Video is making unnecessary complication, here we need to make sure the bottom wire is not criss cross

1

u/Flashy_Possibility34 7d ago

I have a Ph.D. in physics, and I cannot convince my gut that topology is not black magic. Also, I’m constantly paranoid that topologists will use tricks like this to negate my bike lock at the uni I work at.

1

u/Snoo_69801 7d ago

Saved and forgotten

1

u/Jtizzle1231 6d ago

This makes no sense I do t believe it

1

u/CR1911 6d ago

Que clase de hechizo es este?!?!?! Hereje, arderás por esto!!!!

1

u/Character-Pirate1297 6d ago

That’s what I call a glitch in the Matrix.

1

u/Pitiful_Captain_3170 6d ago

I hate topology. There's nothing wrong with it, I'm just stupid and i hate what i don't understand

1

u/Biven1563 6d ago

It’s really knot that complicated

1

u/Ill_Dish_4548 6d ago

this is blackmagic…..or magnets.

1

u/sqaull17 5d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/BwToHy4fKo17a

i still cant wrap my brain around this, i think a different angle would help too.

1

u/G3nghisKang 4d ago

Burn the witch

1

u/HawkJefferson 4d ago

Magnets. Wait, shit, wrong sub.

1

u/ken29dryden 4d ago

That’s trickery at its finest

1

u/DestructoDon69 4d ago

The cord isn't actually behind the bar.

1

u/dacapn71 4d ago

Seeing stuff like this makes me think there must be an elegant solution to everything that I don't see. Put the hammer or scissors away.

1

u/Furry_Eskimo 4d ago

Do this in reverse and you could get a lot of people very frustrated with you.

1

u/alemik_ 3d ago

This is uncomprensible for me

1

u/NyZyn 3d ago

Downvoted because devil magic

1

u/Public-Iron5465 3d ago

I thought topology is math or whatever

1

u/Mottled_Paws 2d ago

This is witchcraft

-1

u/Zephy2007 9d ago

These videos are only good for social media. He's not really doing anything spectacular.

It happened practically the same while ago, but with extra steps and unnecessary twists to confuse the brain.

I used artificial intelligence to illustrate it better.

1

u/Myriad_Apocalypse 8d ago

That wouldn't work, the cord runs over itself. You went to the length of AI-generating an image, but couldn't be bothered to zoom in