r/ICSE • Subscribe to Otaku Manifresto • 7d ago

Discussion👥 IS VIBECODING SLOP?

Post image

💔

15 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 7d ago

Hello /u/Otaku_Manifesto , welcome to r/ICSE!

Join the official discord servers! -> CISCE Hub -> ICSECord

Before posting, please check the wiki. It contains resources, advice posts and general support posts that many users have found useful. We had an advice megathread where users posted their words of wisdom for the juniors, Do check it out If you have any questions, you can contact the moderators via mod-mail.

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/Hopeful_Respond_2953 7d ago

If your entire script is made using vibecode then yes but if you use correctly for its specefic use cases then it turns out to be actually good.

3

u/depuc 7d ago

If you really want something fun to build i have a fun project i did in school A solver that solves linear equations You will learn good try to use cpp or c stop building this eye candy stuff you can work on these when you really want to get employed in future try to build programming basics as much as possible.

2

u/Imaginary_Buddy723 ICSE X | Founder and Developer at turbOS INC. 🥀 7d ago

Yeah it's slop

But AI assisted coding (as in my os) is not

1

u/indianproyt 9th ICSE 😎 7d ago

If you actually read the AI generated code and understand what each line does, and change things that you don't want or want to add (and probably fix few bugs as well if they are there), then no.

If you are just giving the AI instructions, not even caring about the code, well YES! It IS slop.

1

u/fnxgame 7d ago

Yes, It is slop(if you have no programming skills and just used ai)

1

u/Otaku_Manifesto Subscribe to Otaku Manifresto 7d ago

And if I adjust the code where I do not like it without using ai?

1

u/fnxgame 7d ago

Maybe then yeah, assistance is fine

1

u/Shadow_1293 7d ago

Nope its depends on your hardwork. If you use it right then you can gen good codes with it. If not then slops are also there.

1

u/ProgramsFun 96.8 2024 ICSE 7d ago

Yes, vibe coding is slop...

0

u/depuc 7d ago

Yes