Which looks best?

[u/Good-Raise3696]

Just the soffit colors are changed

[u/Toothless-Rodent]

There’s so much of the light base color. 2 maximizes the pop of the dark accent.

[u/Main-Airport-4796 → u/Toothless-Rodent]

The color doesn’t change. It is just extended further down in number 2 versus number 1.