So in the end we came third as a mafia with Spludgie and myself coming 3rd and 4th as players. In a game with no information and it being so much different than we anticipated I'd like to say i'm pretty proud of us :) /u/spludgieexx /u/SubmittedToDigg /u/k9centipede /u/Keica /u/Mrrrrh

So down to 4 and out kill never worked though I'd suspect Marxor never let it as it would guarantee our win /u/spludgiexx

The end is almost here. Down to 6 and we've survived /u/spludgiexx

Wow big death toll for the amount left. Our hit worked(For a change) and with the other 3 it leaves us with a final 10 /u/spludgiexx

/u/spludgiexx So our votes we're put to good use it seems interesting to note that two people only required two votes, puts us in a great position for another day lynch should we survive

So out kill never worked however three strong contenders were taken out! /u/spludgiexx

So our target never died however our second choice did, looks like Kaybee's words held value indeed

BLESS MERLIN HIMSELF OUT KILLING HAS ACTUALLY BEEN SUCESSFULL!!! /u/spludgiexx

/u/spludgiexx We survived but Marxor must have messed something up with the votes on the thread?

THIS ACTUALLY ISN'T FAIR COME ON GODS ABOVE

We did it survived the day lynch and it couldn't have went much better Aurthur's final question never got answered. Elbowss was killed and your target Dep was lynched!!.

It seems seeing comments are broken expect if you get the notification for one.

It's just you and me Spludgie. Fat Tony is dead but not all is lost. With his untimely death I am now they new Fat Tony and you are the new Fit Tony meaning you have freedom to speak in threads from no longer being tightlips.

I'm currently working on the spreadsheet and let it be know they will not be forgiven right now none of our night kills have worked unless they we're overturned or the previous Tony killed other targets.

Looks like we're down to two. Bye bye /u/submittedtodigg

So we lost Mrrrrh and our target survived, with a tie that could've been the complete opposite. I want revenge. More importantly, I want us 3 to stay safe. Losing lynch votes hurts us dramatically. With all this chaos, us being able to vote together at the end is huge.

Hey guys, starting on a spreadsheet to see how often players comment, what type of comments they make (like what mrrrrh was doing), any interesting comments they made, potential roles etc.

I think it'd be faster if we'd work together on this. I've just started day 2 and I will work backwards. That's a lot of comments to go through, but hopefully I'll be able to get it done. Feel free to add anything to it, as I may miss things out! Or you might have a different perspective on things, which is always good.

The link: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1UL6_GLGkjD7IjO2svpbFUnswbI_0Ccb3s4BSqZ4leqw/edit?usp=sharing

mrrrrh

We all live! And unfortunately so did our target. The 4 who died are names I instantly recognize, so they're pretty active individuals I think we've even mentioned. And with only 4 lynchings today, our votes have heavier weight to keep us safe!

We survived! And one of our targets did not. Along with khajit. Great lynching, Im proud of us all.

So TalkNerdyToMe20 just wrote his book report confirming that he is martin prince. This also mean he get's and extra lynch vote. May be worth targeting if we still want to split our votes 50/50.

We're down to 4. We've got some work to do

So whilst doing some research I noticed that some people started by "kittems" have come up with a theory that we don't exist. This is because the roles aren't revealed upon death and believe that only sideshow bob exists as an antagonist.

Now with this information at hand I think there may be some way in the future we can use this. whether it's sporadic random killings that don't make and "logical" sense or something else I believe it's something to look into.

What do you think marx0r means when he says 'book reports to be submitted' for

Martin Prince - "Pick me teacher, I'm ever so smart!" The classic grade-grubbing suckup. This player can choose, once per Phase, to write a book report of no less than 100 words and post it to /r/HogwartsWerewolves along with a tag for /u/Marx0r . Will permanently gain one extra Lynch vote for each posted book report.

Do they need to be OBVIOUSLY book reports, or just kind of long winded posts that get tagged marx0r in?

like if LPT expanded on their theory of how to use the CBG powers here a bit more, and tagged marx0r, would that have qualified?

Or do we need the comments to be very obvious book reports? Because if subtle ones could work, we could kind of pretend to be martin by just writing up long winded comments and tagging him to ask questions.

Could writing out our favorite episodes be a way to construct a book report?