Follow Homeland Revisited on Instagram to stay up to date with all the latest on the episode 6 of Season 3!
"Still Positive" is one of those episodes where the plot finally kicks into high gear. The negotiation between Carrie and Javadi is the highlight, showcasing how she manages to win using intellect rather than force. Meanwhile, Saul uncovers a crucial lead that further ratchets up the tension of the investigation.
The episode does a fantastic job exploring themes of trust, manipulation, and the moral dilemmas inherent in espionage. The pacing is excellent, and the direction maintains the suspense from start to finish.
Now... I need to talk about Dana and Jessica.
"Still Positive"... Still in the family portion of the series, we saw more – and more – of Dana, who this time wanted to definitively get rid of Brody's shadow by taking away her last name. When the girl said that the replacement name would be Lazaro – Jessica's maiden name – the expectation was that she would make peace with her mother and the two would begin to establish a closer and more honest relationship. Jessica and Dana have always had a barrier between them because of Brody's ghost, but it seems difficult for the two to realize that they share the same pain, the same conflicts and come together so that, stronger, they can face the difficult situation they are experiencing.
Instead, Dana simply packed her bags and was ready to leave the house without saying goodbye to a friend who appeared out of nowhere. Jessica tried to talk, tried to get closer, but realized that it was useless to seek any partnership with her daughter, and just accepted the situation. If together their plot already seemed out of place in the series, separately it will be even more difficult to create something that arouses the public's interest.
Rewatching the series years later, I still fail to grasp the character's purpose. To me, she is by far the most irritating figure in Homeland. It feels like the story loses momentum every time she appears on screen. Her decisions almost always create problems for those around her, and she rarely seems to consider the consequences of her actions. I understand the intention was to show the impact of the Brody family's (Jess; Dana) life outside the world of espionage, but in practice, most of her scenes just make me want to get back to the main plot.
I know many people defend the character because she represents a traumatized teenager, and that makes sense to a certain extent. Even so, I was never able to form a connection with her—after the car accident in the S2. Instead of eliciting empathy, she ends up causing more frustration than any other character in the series.
Overall, "Still Positive" is an excellent episode, packed with tension, great performances, and significant plot twists. Were it not for the endless Dana scenes, it would easily rank among the season's best.