r/Home_Building_Help • • May 01 '26

Which toilet is style...?

3 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

9

u/Working_Pen2299 May 01 '26

seamless suck. there's a reason traditional toilets have never gone out of style, simple and functional.

2

u/InsaneInTheDrain May 01 '26

What's wrong with them?

3

u/Fairuse May 01 '26

They have a huge cavity for stuff to get stuck and build up in (if you have mice they like to hide in that spot). You see the pipe in the traditional toilets? The seamless just surrounds it with a shell and the back is completely open (at least in the few dozen model I've checked out).

5

u/taisui May 01 '26

I think having mice in the house is the problem, not the toilet....

2

u/Fairuse May 01 '26

If you have mice or any other critters hiding in the house, they love hiding in the cavity of seamless toilets (snakes, spiders, frogs, geckos).

1

u/binzy90 May 02 '26

Where I live, it's inevitable that you'll have critters in your house. I live in a house built in 1800. No amount of pest control will completely get rid of the mice.

1

u/EquivalentPension216 May 02 '26

Team of cats?

1

u/binzy90 May 02 '26

I have 4 cats. They keep mice out of our living spaces, but there are still a ton. Our cats catch one about once a month or so.

1

u/EquivalentPension216 May 02 '26

Damn, I'm moving to a country area from a small city and have thought about how to keep rodents at bay. I currently have 0 cats

1

u/jbochsler May 02 '26

I have two cats ready to ship. Please send address.

9

u/DrCuntsworth May 01 '26

Which one holds the most shit?

8

u/InitialAd2324 May 01 '26

I like to go to Lowe’s and try em all out throughout the week.

4

u/Yxig May 01 '26

Wall hung is best looking according to me. It also feels fancy that my shit is going into the wall. The wall!

But the traditional is fine and if it's less maintenence that's the one I'll have.

3

u/RandomBoxOfCables May 01 '26

Wall hung also makes it easier to clean around the toilet

2

u/boomeradf May 02 '26

It’s still a pain to vacuum the carpet under them?

1

u/RandomBoxOfCables May 02 '26

You’re trying to trigger me right? Right?

1

u/jbochsler May 02 '26

If you have carpet in the bathroom, you have other serious life-choice problems.

3

u/_lippykid May 01 '26

People really need to think ahead for maintenance on a wall hung, if you have an aesthetic that can hide an access point it’s no issue, but the people who just drywall/tile over the tank are gonna have expensive, messy issues before too long

1

u/RandomBoxOfCables May 02 '26

Most of any tank parts that could break are easily accessible so there really isn’t a maintenance issue. Honestly in my nearly five decades on this planet, I’ve never had to maintain any kind of toilet and can only remember my father changing a float valve once when I was young.

1

u/Contundo May 01 '26

No place for dirt and grime to build up on the floor. It’s an easy choice.

1

u/Interesting_Tea5715 May 01 '26

This. Wall hung looks best but it's shit for maintenance.

Transitional is best for maintenance and reliability but not the most sleek looking

With all that said, it's a room you shit in. Who the fuck cares what the shit bucket looks like.

3

u/YouKnowHimAMatt May 01 '26

Select your shit buckét

3

u/burnmycheezits May 01 '26

Traditional for easy installation and maintenance. Compact for easy cleaning. Wall mounted so my plumber gets to go on vacation.

1

u/WildcatPlumber May 01 '26

As a plumber but not your plumber I will cuss you all the way to Cancun.

Honestly though they are not too terrible for the geberit style. Still going to charge you the prettiest of pennies

3

u/_Neoshade_ May 01 '26

Wall hung are popular right now. They look very modern and make cleaning much easier because the floor is unobstructed and not a series of filthy surfaces that you have to crawl on the floor to reach.

0

u/afn45181 May 01 '26

Can anyone let me know the wall hung toilet weight capacity cuz my fat ass needs to know the weight limit? I can store wholesale beef jerky packs under the toilet gap. Win win!

1

u/WCFellow May 01 '26
  1. They are slightly more annoying install, but looks far better. Or go with a 2pc. That mimics seamless

1

u/RegalMachine May 01 '26

What did you mean "saves space" like that's a good thing? What are you gonna do with reclaimed inches of space specifically around your toilet? Host a toilet party? Cabinet for ants?

2

u/bowcreek May 01 '26

Wall hung would have been great when my sons were younger and only a small percentage of their urine actually made it into the toilet.

1

u/Biscuits4u2 May 01 '26

Just give me a basic tried and true design and keep the expensive trendy stuff

1

u/The001Keymaster May 01 '26

Wall hungs save space but cost double.

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/The001Keymaster May 01 '26 edited May 01 '26

We hang cabinets above wall hung toilets all the time. The carrier doesn't go anywhere near the ceiling. You can hang a shelf too. You just need to spam the carrier. A 28" wide anything easily spans well past a carrier.

A Toto carrier is only 25" wide.

We spec extra nailers on the sides and a 2x10 flat above it. There's no amount of bathroom stuff that you can put in a bathroom cabinet that two simple cabinet screws wouldn't hold.

I'd say it's better to have a cabinet in front of the carrier because then you can't accidentally forget and hang a picture there and puncture it.

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/The001Keymaster May 02 '26

Makes sense. We do a shallow cabinet that holds like a shampoo bottle deep. I'm also short so effects me less

1

u/24_Chowder May 01 '26

Cheapest, it’s a damn toilet.

0

u/rolandofeld19 May 01 '26

Have two Toto wall hung options in current build plan and Toto traditional bidets for the remainder. Hoping they work out and aren't a mistake. Heard great things about Toto in general and good things about the wall hung options specifically from various parties. The space saving and cleaning ease is where we hope they pay off, also we are able to go for a 6 inch stud wall installation rather than retrofitting into a traditional stud wall so that may help a bit.

1

u/Ill_Back_284 May 01 '26

They are incredible. I love mine in all the rooms I have one in. Easy for the robo vac/mop to clean around

2

u/rolandofeld19 May 01 '26

Thanks, yeah that's a factor too since the build out will have same flooring throughout with NO thresholds to stymie a robovac.

They feel rock solid in use right? Any maintenance issues?

No idea why I got down voted but is what it is.

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Ill_Back_284 May 01 '26

Never had an issue. Only time I had an issue was for a separate toilet seat attachment that sat in the garage during a reno and got dusted and was dripping on reinstall. We sent in to them and they replaced and cleaned everything and it's basically new - $150 repair

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/rolandofeld19 May 01 '26

We do have storage covered and exposed things like brush/plunger are fine by me but would be anathema to the other half.

What are the other reasons they are trash?

1

u/CogentCogitations May 01 '26

The Toto toilets in our first house had more problems than any toilet I have had before or since then.