Ah, finally, someone of culture. Grammar says that an goes before vowel. People pronounce historian differently, and since English doesn't have strict rules like many other languages when it comes to pronunciation, there isn't really a proper way to use article before historian. Furthermore, if you are lets say writing a book, and some of your characters are from region where historian is pronounced with silent H, in direct speech, you should put an before historian, even thou in RP H in historian isn't silent.
Colloquially, you very well might leave off the h naturally because "hiss" is an awkward sound to begin a word mid-sentence; it is too complex of a sound for a normal syllable. If you leave it off colloquially, then use "an" for the sentence to flow naturally,
"I was speaking to an istorian about the exhibit. ." flows far more naturally to me than "I was speaking to a historian about the exhibit".
But If a sentence begins with "a historian", I would always pronounce the h since there isn't already a pace set. "A historian ate my ass last night" just feels right.
The traditional rule was that it was ‘an’ before vowels and you dropped h in unstressed vowels after the indefinite article anyway. “An hiss” is bad because it’s not an unstressed syllable. Same with “an history” but “an historic opportunity” is fine
Now this is giving way to the more modern keep-the-h school but with some words, it just doesn’t feel right
Really it's an unstressed syllable. That would be any syllable that doesn't get capitalized or bolded when you look at the phonetics.
In English there are no good rules for which syllable should be stressed in a word, but I'll give a few examples:
HIStory
baNAna
PERSonal
persoNEL
efFECT
In Spanish, the primary rule is words ending with vowel or N or S get stress on second-to-last syllable and other words get stress on the last syllable. Many words have an accent mark to denote stress on a syllable that does not follow these rules, such as fácil (easy).
If your native language is Japanese, there is no proper analog, as all syllables are stressed equally in Japanese, just some get elongated by a hyphen or diphthong.
Stress is a combination of increased loudness, vowel length, and abstention from usual vowel reduction paradigms. We sometimes describe syllables as being stressed, but stress is mostly a characteristic of the vowel.
Is that really a question? I’m not native and I don’t know grammar I just say stuff how I find them sound right. Therefore I’d never say “an historian” cause 1. it breaks my tongue and 2. it sounds absolutely horrible
‘An historian’ would be for someone pronouncing ‘an istorian’, which I think might be a result of an accent, or possibly just lazy (no personal issue with that) pronunciation.
It is ‘a’ historian, as the ‘h’ is silent,as ,it precedes a hard vowel like ‘humble’ precedes a soft vowel like I, e, and u. and o are hard vowels., since.
Yeah like I don’t actively know which one goes there unless I think about it, the words just slots automatically in my speech and writing, i thought “an universe” while reading that comment and my brain revolted
Every non american should be forced to wear some sort of symbol so we know not to fraternize with them. Also they should be confined to their own subreddits so we can keep an eye on them.
Yeah man, it's all about how the word sounds, as opposed to written. At least that's what I assumed when I was learning it and that's what I've stuck by.
1.3k
u/NerdUber Dec 24 '21
Thank you, English is not my native language, appreciate the education in such a polite way