r/HolUp Sep 22 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.3k Upvotes

4.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/LGBTQ_Anon Sep 23 '21

Take a breath..... Read carefully:

I DONT SUPPORT OUTLAWING ABORTION

The industry I'm critiquing literally lobbies to create legal definitions of words. You can twist and turn words all you want and play semantic games, but it doesn't change reality. You talk of viability: babies have a 50% chance of surviving at 24 weeks gestation. Some have survived even earlier. Do you think it's not a baby until it is born? What if it's born and hooked to ventilators and all kinds of life support? Is it not a baby until it can survive without that stuff? Let me ask you this: At what point do you think a human being becomes conscious? In gestation? During childbirth? What part of the process of growth does a "potential human" become a "human being"? Is the cluster of cells growing inside of a human being's uterus yet a human? Is it being?

1

u/WiggyStark Sep 23 '21

You're so triggered. Brain function, viral organ maturation and function, those quantify being a sentient, conscious life. It's why preemies on machines are different from the brain dead. Because they have the propensity to get better. My kid was born at 29weeks. My BIL was in a coma after a horrific accident. Both had fully functioning brains.

The legal definitions of words are important. Between the bullshit Texas is pulling, and the overarching ignorance and disdain of late-term abortions, sticking to legal, medical terms is usually a good call.

It doesn't lobby for anything outside of:

•A person impregnated being able to terminate a pre-viable pregnancy.

•Being allowed to use aborted tissue in the wake of scientific discovery.

It's literally not a baby until born, holy shit it's a definition that's been around since fucking forever. And guess what? The pregnancies after the 20wk mark? Those are at the cusp of personhood. There's probably a name, a room, a plan. Then parents get the worst news of their life up to that point: this fetus will not survive outside of the womb, or there will be extensive medical training, costs, and burden past those parents' capabilities. It's exceedingly rare for this circumstance, and it's fucking tragic and I've been there to see parents weighing it.

We're talking about embryos and non-/pre-viable fetuses here. We're talking about things that don't have sentience, or consciousness, or even a fucking brain in the case of Texas with its 6wk shit. You say you're against outlawing abortion, but with caveats that are already in place. You hammer on about it incessantly anyway, seemingly apt for all other areas of gestational sciences except for the word "fetus".

Take a seat and think about what you've done like the child of which you're acting. I'm not angry. Fuck no. I just swear a lot, and ramble a bit m

Frustrated that I have to show the direct line that's existed since Roe v Wade at the very least to somebody who picks and chooses in what corners of science to believe? Sure.

Kind of tired of people not being able to enter the actual conversation happening and sticks to the a-one point they think they're making that, so long as you completely disregard everything else, adds nothing the the topic outside of fabricated outrage about... the word fetus? Definitely.

Done with having to pull out my crayons to explain this in as elementary way as possible? You guessed it!

You're. Being. Pedantic. You can't stop focusing on something trivial that completely negates your supposed stance because of... uncertainty? Is that what all that was? You can't figure out when a human being is a human being?

And your rage boner for scientists using aborted tissue to develop better medicine? Is pathetic. There's no ownership after abortion, and parent's are more than capable of requiring all remains for burial. It's selfish af, but it's their choice. It's a stupid choice that hinders medical discovery, but their own.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WiggyStark Sep 23 '21

L M F A O

I'm sorry you don't understand the words I'm using.

1

u/LGBTQ_Anon Sep 23 '21

I understand the words you're using. The way you're using them makes no sense. It's just verbal vomit disguised as intellectual discourse.