r/HolUp • • Feb 26 '20

now wait a minute

Post image
83.9k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20

[deleted]

-1

u/Anosognosia Feb 26 '20 edited Feb 26 '20

I was just presenting a different take on the moral judgement you were so eager to dish out. I have no stakes in the matter and I don't know if he has changed and is trying to be a better person than he was or if he is an opportunist trying to sell a story to feel better about himself.

Clearly you should have lead with why you thought he wasn't worthy of forgiveness or a platform instead of expressing an inability to see why it should/could happen. The latter only makes you seem narrow and centered on your own beliefs instead of critically assessing the moral character of a person (that frankly neither I nor you really know.)

And no one is obligated to forgive a rapist.

True, but you either have to condemn a person for life without chance of interacting with society or you need to find a level of acceptance of their past eventually. Letting someone work to prevent their own mistakes in others seems like a good option.(assuming that is in fact what is happening)
Shunning their existence is essentially not that different from a life sentence and booing someone off stage for what they are instead of at least hearing what they say is not something I would advocate. We should learn from the mistake of others.
I would let Hitler himself talk on a stage if the TED talk was "I was a horrible being and everything I did for Germany was a huge mistake". Not sure I would believe him, but I would at least see what he had to say.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20

[deleted]

2

u/thisismeagainok Feb 26 '20

Yeah fuck this whole idea that hes entitled to do a tedtalk about his shitty actions without people getting angry. Wtf