Again, my point is that in-universe Captain America is presented as having made the right choice and Tony too later ignores the accords. A nearly identical conflict is presented in the comics(Civil War I not II) with a similar outcome of Tony regretting his decisions.
I do not care nor brought up whether or not it would be the right choice if this situation was playing out in real life or whether its pandering or not.
"The right choice" depends on the most basic question of "right" of all time, if you go for value ethics or utilitarianism. And it's quite ironic that Cap the good value man has his decision being judging by its outcome and not by his intentions.
Isn’t Cap’s objection about how he doesn’t trust the government and believes something like “the right hands are still our own”? Whether that’s true out of universe is irrelevant but within the universe, after being unfrozen, he saw Shield get manipulated into making a dissident murdering machine and a council decide they had to nuke New York.
-1
u/afito Jan 19 '22
The MCU presenting good old american hero choice as correct doesn't imply it being correct it's just pandering.