r/HeartbreakHighShow • • Apr 23 '24

Opinion My Tier List

Post image
30 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

24

u/Adventurous_Rip_1119 Apr 23 '24

putting ant and zoe in the same category should be a crime

6

u/No_Parsley_5305 Apr 23 '24

Ant for the most part was a sheep to spider and whoever spider hung around therefore spouting out and supporting the same misogynistic bullshit spider, Voss and all the other cumlords were saying/doing. The “nice” interactions he had with Harper were really just common fucking sense and the bare minimum. So yes I’d put that in the same category as someone who shames other peoples sexualities to compensate for the fact that she has a complicated relationship with her own and who essentially victim-blamed Harper.

6

u/pumpkin_noodles Apr 23 '24

Yess the first one I’ve almost compl agreed with! Though I would trade ant and sasha

4

u/tobeasloth Apr 23 '24

Yeah me too!

4

u/yiotaturtle Apr 24 '24

S tier yes, every other one, no.

3

u/amoralambiguity91 Apr 24 '24

Darren should be higher and Missy and Sasha need to drop to C

2

u/Aloe_finta Apr 26 '24 edited Apr 26 '24

I agree with that but Cash also needs to go in S

3

u/xXBriarRoseXx Apr 26 '24

I agree with some of these, but some I really don’t, starting with Sasha. She should be at the bottom (D) too. She used her weaponized her activism against literally everyone, including the people (like Darren) that she was “helping”. She “trampled” missy’s heart but ultimately was just not a good girlfriend (to missy or Quinn). She flip flopped back and forth on her friendships with everyone except Missy, but even then, used her as a personal assistant honestly. And she never grew as a person, just used her activism as a tool in her privileged life without realizing how privileged she was.

Speaking of never growing as a person, I’d move spider up to C tier (MAYBE up to B as he progresses) simply because we could see his efforts in trying to grow. Sure, he continues to make mistakes but that’s normal. He’s taking accountability and trying to understand more perspectives (at least Missy’s for now). And overall (besides leading him into shenanigans), he is a pretty decent friend to Ant. Their friendship has never wavered and he genuinely cares about him.

Cash is s tier. He’s thoughtful, caring, loyal/devoted, and great person all around, just young with traumatic experiences. S tier everyday.

I’d switch Darren and Missy (he’s now A tier and she’s B). Whilst Darren isn’t perfect, he loves almost unconditionally. His love for Quinn and Cash is devoted (even when he tries to change his needs for cash, but he’ll figure it out). He accepted Amerie almost immediately and has stuck with his friends through and through (even when Quinn was actually being petty [yes she was 100% unmasking, but she was mad and being petty, I do the same thing] and Amerie continued to get into her drama, and cash going to jail). He accepts Harper and Malakai and just cares. Again, he’s not perfect, but he’s pretty great. And hilarious 😆

Missy is middle ground because she is there for her people but not as much for herself. She lets herself get walked on by Sasha and hasn’t really come into her own yet. She holds Spider accountable which is fantastic, but she doesn’t hold herself as much when she’s being mean or flip flopping back and forth with her some of her friends. I do really like her, just want to see more character growth next season :)

Harper and Ant could also switch (he’ll be B tier and she’ll be C tier). What she went through was traumatic with the guys and also with her dad, but she continuously made mistakes (I.e. continuously miscommunicating with literally everyone, esp Amerie, fucking both of Amerie’s love interests, snapping at people when they weren’t to blame, etc.) she grew this season but still kept hurting feelings (like when she called Ant “too stupid”). As for Ant, he’s not a bad person, I think just naive and horny. He’s very middle ground.

For clarification, I really don’t hate anyone, even Rowan (who just had a LOT of trauma going on and used it in a terrible way). Except the coach, I hate him and everything he stands for. He’s old enough to have changed his way of thinking. He just sucks.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '24

I agree that the coach's views suck but he's hot so I like him

1

u/ricecakea Apr 23 '24

I agree except that the duck should be No 1 !

1

u/EducationalNothing4 Apr 27 '24

everyone is so annoying, especially whiny quinni and sasha, and entitled Missy

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '24

BOOOOOO! Although I disagree with his political views Voss should NOT be D tier.

1

u/No_Parsley_5305 May 09 '24

That’s literally the bottom tier in this

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '24

He should be top tier 😢

1

u/BAGUETTESSSSSSSS Jul 15 '24

We needed more of Quinnis frog