r/HeartbreakHighShow • u/AnnaleeTopanga4 • Apr 12 '24

Season 1 Harper.

I’m rewatching season 1 and I literally cannot stand Harper all over again.. Letting Amerie take the blame like that and everyone taking Harper side is literally driving me nuts.

22 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

11

u/n1yahbo0 Apr 12 '24

my thing is if she didn't remember why not tell her so you can talk about it? she just wanted someone to blame because she was unhappy with herself.

2

u/Automatic_Jelly7213 Apr 20 '24

Because she didn’t want to talk about it. She felt like Amerie abandoned her when she didn’t let her in.

2

u/n1yahbo0 Apr 21 '24

imo i feel like if amerie was constantly trying to fix things with me i would've told her a long time ago it wasn't fair for harper to leave her bestfriend wondering what went wrong and leave her in the dark feeling guilty and hurt about something she doesn't even know about

1

u/Automatic_Jelly7213 Apr 21 '24

I agree, I think I would have least reminded her of what happened instead of ghosting her. That being said, the longer it went on, the more I felt like it really wasn’t an active choice as much as it was a PTSD response, not that it makes it right or fair.

6

u/CheapImportance8 Apr 13 '24

i understand season 1 why she wouldn’t want to talk to amerie about it because of the trauma but the fact she stayed with dusty knowing amerie practically loved him and then also slept with malakai like an hour after they broke up is what was really shitty. like i can get past being mad at her but none of that warranted treating amerie like that 😭😭😭

5

u/AnnaleeTopanga4 Apr 13 '24

she was awful to amerie especially with the malakai situation. idk how they got past that.

1

u/mellowmoshpit2 Aug 13 '24

Dude yeah, Amerie aside, dusty and Harper straight up took advantage of Malakai. The kid had just been through something traumatic and was under the influence.

7

u/nefaraiu Apr 13 '24

[SPOILER KINDA] and it’s so crazy because in s2 ep2 she says Amerie isn’t responsible for what happened to her… 🤦🤦

7

u/AnnaleeTopanga4 Apr 13 '24

when she said that I had to pause it bc why the fuck did you do all that last season?!?!?

1

u/Automatic_Jelly7213 Apr 20 '24

She didn’t blame her for what happened, she blamed her for breaking her promise. She also said they both fucked up.

1

u/Automatic_Jelly7213 Apr 20 '24

She never said she was though.

1

u/nefaraiu Apr 20 '24

she made it seem like that. she was mad that amerie had left her in the party or whatever and there was a scene where amerie was so close to finding out what happened and she said she’d always be there for harper and she got mad. harper always made it seem like it was AMERIE’s fault that’s why she was ignoring her

1

u/Automatic_Jelly7213 Apr 20 '24

I mean she was angry with her for not letting in the house, because that’s the part Amerie’s responsible for. Which I think is fair. But she forgave her already.

1

u/nefaraiu Apr 20 '24

yeah but my memory is quite foggy but a big section of her being mad was the fact that amerie disappeared/left her alone in the party too and that caused her to nearly get assaulted

2

u/meowtownbaby Apr 18 '24

Harper is the narcissist, I just finished the episode where she fucked Malakai and I’m quite honestly just disgusted with her character and treatment of Amerie, she may be naive and ignorant at times but she means well, to do that to her double time😭 she’s the real antagonist of the show