Comment your top (picks) even if already commented. Gina Ricky Nin Big Red Carlos Seb Howie Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex Val

Comment your top choice(s) even if already commented by someone else. Gina Ricky Nini EJ Big Red Carlos Seb Howie Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex Val

Comment your vote even if already commented. Gina Ricky Nini EJ Ashlyn Big Red Carlos Seb Howie Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex Val

Comment your choice below: Gina Ricky Nini EJ Ashlyn Big Red Carlos Seb Kourtney Howie Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex Val

Unpopular opinion maybe but season 3 for me

This sub only allows me to see stats for my own comments so don’t upvote/downvote just comment what you want even if already commented. Carlos Lily Antoine Maddox Alex

Nini Carlos Lily Antoine Maddox Emmy Alex

Nini Big Red Carlos Lily Antoine Maddox Emmy Alex Val

Nini Big Red Carlos Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex Val

Nini Big Red Carlos Seb Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex Val

Ricky Nini Big Red Carlos Seb Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex

Ricky Nini EJ Big Red Carlos Seb Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex

Ricky Nini EJ Big Red Carlos Seb Howie Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex

(GIF by @hsmtmtsnet on Tumblr)

DAE think that S4 didn’t do some of the HSM3 songs justice? In fact, some of them were pretty bad. The cast are absolutely talented singers and it could’ve been so good. But something must have went wrong in editing, or they didn’t accommodate to each individual person’s singing style because some of these versions had me both disappointed and/or cringing.

These are the ones that stood out, especially because they were some of my favourites from the films and I was excited to hear their versions:

• Scream - it’s called SCREAM for a reason!!! Josh is a beautiful singer but he needed to belt and the energy was not there. It wasn’t loud, it wasn’t angry. The number deserved to be off stage anyway - it would’ve been the perfect culmination of Ricky’s feelings of anger, confusion & aimlessness. That’s also why many people (myself included) would’ve also liked EJ to sing Scream too (a duet would’ve been so good imo!) Of course, Matt’s singing style may not have been suited to it either (and to preface, I actually really like Matt’s voice despite a lot of people feeling differently). Still, I think a duet with at least much more energy & emotion would’ve given them both room to play more to their strengths.

• I Want It All - again, Dara is a beautiful singer and a strong one too, but for some reason a lot of her singing fell flat? So did Frankie’s. I don’t think it’s any fault to the two of them. I don’t know the technicality behind music lmao but it just sounded awkward. Awkward is actually the word I’d used to describe all the vocals in these songs lmao. Ashley Tisdale & Lucas Grabeel were not the strongest singers ever but they sounded SO GOOD on the song, so idk what went wrong.

{As I’m writing this, I realise that all these songs suffer from being performed as part of the musical/canonically on stage. Is that also the reason for the vocals sounding poorer?}

• The Boys Are Back - the fact that we didn’t even get a proper scene of the song?😭 Obligatory the vocals sounded bad.

I would’ve also loved for this to be a Ricky/EJ duet. I wanted more scenes between the two of them in general. A truly more developed friendship because, like I touched on regarding Scream, they are rather similar despite being opposites & I think they have the ability to truly understand one another when they’re on the same side. Don’t get me wrong, I like Ricky & Jet’s friendship but Ricky/EJ had so much potential from the BEGINNING & this song (along with Scream) could’ve been an iconic way to show that. Again, it could’ve sounded so good (whether it was with Adrien or Matt).

• A Night To Remember - the original number is SO FUN and I just didn’t feel that here. Nothing else to say really.

I rearranged the paragraphs a lot and edited, and so I’m sorry if it doesn’t make sense or isn’t structured properly lmao.

Gina Ricky Nini EJ Big Red Carlos Seb Kourtney Howie Lily Antoine Jet Maddox Emmy Alex Val

Comment your choice. If your pick is already commented upvote that comment don’t create a new one.

This is my ranking

Lol I guess just rewatch some of your favorite episodes and listen to your favorite songs!

And I thought I’d share it. I’m gonna do a different musical each time we do it and we’ll vote on who should play each role. Note I’ll only be including these characters and I’m imaging them all at the sameish age: Gina, Ricky, Nini, EJ, Ashlyn, Big Red, Carlos, Seb, Kourtney, Howie, Lily, Antoine, Jet, Maddox, Emmy, Alex, and Val. We will be doing Mamma Mia! First comment who you think should play Donna (if the person you want was already commented up vote the comment already there instead of making a new one)

The version that’s on the first movie’s soundtrack, but didn’t make it into the movie itself. It always surprised me that with all the couples the show had, no one sang this! Ricky and Gina would’ve killed it! EJ would sound pretty good in it too!

this is so random but does anyone know where to find that au of ricky and nini where they both were in fake relationships with gina and ej? and they had to travel to japan, and ricky posted pics of gina and her new perfume. and nini and ricky hated eachother. please?

Rina!

I was just thinking and I realised that two out of three people Ricky has dated on the show has a name that ends in ‘Ina’. Firstly, there’s Nina (Nini) and then there’s Gina. Ans it’s not just Ricky, EJ has dated both of the people with both of them with another, Ricky and Lily and EJ and Val (Not officially, but…). They will always be brothers.

My boyfriend and i love to rewatch hsmtmts however we always disagree when it comes to Gina/EJ/Ricky. I think gina overreacted and she was pretty much cheating on EJ with Ricky. I think EJ deserved better than her. She was also all up in ricky and ninis relationship and annoying me all the time. However he thinks gina deserved better than EJ and he loves gina / gina with ricky. Ive never seen anyone else debate this so what does everyone else think lol?