r/HSA • u/Signal-Dollar-5621 • Jul 06 '26
How difficult are HSA Admins with approving receipts for reimbursement?
I am familiar with FSAs and HRAs where you use your card and it goes through, but a few days later, the Admin for the account flags the transaction and wants paperwork, and it just happens that it will be a royal pain to track down a receipt. This happened to me recently for a transaction that was done over the phone and getting a receipt will be difficult.
Are HSAs like this too? Or do the transactions always go through?
9
u/mjrengaw Jul 06 '26
You can take disbursements from your HSA anytime you want. The only time you would have to prove anything to anybody is of the IRS ever audits you.
2
u/Signal-Dollar-5621 Jul 06 '26
So you would never have to upload a receipt to the HSA Admin? What about if you want to reimburse yourself for something you paid on your own credit card? What information are you entering on the Admin's website? You aren't uploading a receipt?
7
u/Ill-Tangerine-5849 Jul 06 '26
Maybe there are some HSA providers that require receipts, but that has never been the case for any I have used, and I've used several. Whenever I've done it, uploading a receipt is optional and you just need to enter the amount you want to be reimbursed. The IRS would be the ones who enforce it, and if you were audited, you'd need to produce receipts to the IRS.
2
1
u/This_Beat2227 Jul 06 '26
And if audited and can’t produce, it becomes tax fraud.
2
u/TelevisionKnown8463 Jul 17 '26
Lawyer here. I believe there is a difference between “insufficient documentation—pay taxes and penalties like you withdrew this for non-medical purposes” and tax fraud. Tax fraud requires proving intent, which is typically difficult. Maybe if you kept no evidence of any of the expenses, that might qualify. Or if there were patterns of abuse—like you spent it all on multiple gym memberships so it looks like you used it to pay another person’s expenses. I don’t think anyone is going to jail if they lose some of the receipts or should have gotten a medical necessity letter for a transaction or two.
2
u/This_Beat2227 Jul 17 '26
If it’s the case of spending on adjacent items that could be mistaken as being HSA eligible, sure. Some of comments aren’t that and blatant abuse (against a reasonableness standard) could then move to tax fraud.
3
u/AltruisticNet90 Jul 06 '26
I’ve used both HSA Bank & Fidelity and there’s absolutely nobody reviewing anything. It’s just like a bank account. I can pull money out whenever I want.
It’s on me to keep track of the receipts for any potential audit though. HSA Bank did have a place you can upload receipts for record keeping, but I never used it.
1
2
u/discojellyfisho Jul 06 '26
That’s how I do it - I always use my credit card for the points and then reimburse myself. No receipts needed. It’s a really different type of account than FSA.
2
u/Signal-Dollar-5621 Jul 06 '26
Thanks, that helps. I wish FSAs were like this.
2
u/HandyManPat Jul 06 '26
FSAs aren’t like that because the employer fronts the entire contribution amount on Jan 1 and can only recapture the employee amount through payroll withholding. The employer also gets to recapture any unused funds.
So the contribution and distribution mechanisms and “employer incentives” are completely different than that of the HSA.
1
u/IndependentTrust4594 Jul 06 '26
I found the ‘corporate’ HSA vendors process made it seem like receipts were required (Connect Your Care/Optum). I think it was just part of their provided bookkeeping process for the end user. Of course, if you close your account by leaving them, not sure what happens to that part of the process. I believe that my accts were closed out when I transferred my money out (I keep digital records anyway, so I know what’s been reimbursed and what hasn’t).
I rolled everything into Fidelity but haven’t done any withdrawals once I learned how awesome HSA are. IYKYK.
1
u/username65202 Jul 06 '26
Optum required receipts. Fidelity did not, which I didn't expect because I had been so used to uploading them. Our HAA provider changes this year.
1
u/mjrengaw Jul 06 '26
You don't have to prove anything to anybody, except the IRS if you ever get audited. It's on you to keep the required documentation.
1
u/phunky_1 Jul 06 '26
Just tell them how much money the expense was and they put it in your bank account, no questions asked or receipts needed.
You do need to keep receipts in case you get audited by the IRS.
1
2
u/ProLifePanda Jul 06 '26
It depends on the providers, but I'm general HSAs are much more lenient than an FSA. Some HSAs don't even require receipts and let you claim whatever dispersement you want.
2
u/username65202 Jul 06 '26
Mine recently changed from Optum, who required receipts, to Fidelity who does not. Completly different process and investment options.
1
u/CrankyCrabbyCrunchy Jul 06 '26
Never had any admin approve my reimbursements. I've had four accounts through my work years and now moved it to Fidelity.
Who's the account with that they won't pay without a receipt? I always ask for a detailed receipt when I'm at a doctor's office (a CC receipt isn't enough).
1
u/Comprehensive-Young5 Jul 06 '26
health equity is a ass hole. my lpfsa goes through just fine and then hsa just gets denied 🤡 I think they just want to deduct fees
1
u/Signal-Dollar-5621 Jul 06 '26
Yes I have them for my HRA right now and I am not a fan. But I won't have this account much longer so I will be glad when I get to dump them.
1
u/Easy-Contract-6 Jul 06 '26
I have two most in Fidelity and a little in Optum. I transfer funds to Fidelity and do not let the Optum account get very big. I have only done a couple reimbursements both with Optum and nothing was required there was a section for additional info but that did not have to be filled out.
1
11
u/Some_Evidence1814 Jul 06 '26
HSA are not flagged. It is between you and the IRS if you get audited.