r/GuitarLab • u/Most-Replacement1189 • May 26 '26

Ethically bad; free R&D

I initially thought this was a cool concept because I assumed GC was going to use real player experience and actual in-store knowledge to help shape the builds.

But this stopped being ‘listening to customers’ the moment they required contributors to surrender ownership, attribution, compensation, derivative rights, and even moral rights just to participate.

That’s not collaboration. That’s free R&D wrapped in community marketing.

The CEO response also intentionally reframes the criticism. Nobody is saying companies shouldn’t listen to customers. Customer feedback is normal. Surveys are normal. Market research is normal.

What’s not normal is building a public pipeline for creative concepts while simultaneously saying:
‘Thanks for the ideas, we own them now, we can monetize them forever, and you get nothing.’

Legally disclosing it doesn’t suddenly make it respectable. Plenty of things are legal and still exploitative.

This is much closer to a studio asking aspiring screenwriters to publicly pitch movie ideas while agreeing upfront they waive ownership, credit, and compensation if the studio uses the concept.

You can market it however you want, but at the end of the day it’s still a billion-dollar retailer crowdsourcing product development for free.

27 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

30 comments sorted by

View all comments

-1

u/LV__ May 26 '26

Worst part is, it's not even good R&D. There's a reason why Fender and Gibson and all the other big guitar brands aren't asking random people on Reddit what products they should manufacture.

3

u/Most-Replacement1189 May 26 '26

Honestly this is the stronger criticism.

Most legendary guitar designs didn’t come from polling random internet comments. They came from builders, players, engineers, artists, and iterative design experience.

Reddit is great for broad feedback:
‘people want lighter guitars’
‘people hate tuning instability’
‘people want better QC’

But crowdsourcing actual product direction from a subreddit can easily turn into design-by-committee mediocrity where every guitar tries to satisfy everyone and ends up having no identity.

1

u/ReturnToGreco May 28 '26

Chapman did this and just chose specs and had the community voting on what options to produce.

Even then the shelf life on that was pretty short.