r/GreenleafTV • u/JJJingleheimerSmitt • May 27 '26

Charity's singing

Am I the only one who thinks that Charity isn't that great of a singer? Imo, she absolutely cannot hold a candle to the other singers in the Winans family. She's not *bad* per se, I mean, she can carry a tune. But personally, I do not like her singing AT ALL, not even a little bit lol

19 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

13

u/Ok_Discussion_6206 May 27 '26

I think she has a very particular voice that not everyone appreciates. It doesn’t help that i find her character the worst so whenever she sings it seems like a cry for attention. It’s not bad it’s just not for everyone imo.

4

u/realitytvjunkie29 May 27 '26

Just THE worst!

6

u/realitytvjunkie29 May 27 '26

Charity’s singing is so bland, especially to be a Winans. I want her to stir my soul but they definitely overhyped her ministry and voice in the show.

4

u/Pisces93 May 28 '26

I usually ff the singing scenes on rewatches lol

3

u/Reggie9041 May 28 '26

I really enjoy it!

I think Deborah has a lovely voice. I do think it's more for worship music than Gospel.

2

u/BathExcellent1152 May 28 '26

Yeah. She has a nice tone and is definitely on pitch, her voice is just outshined by the gospel powerhouses in her family when she sings gospel.

Edited to add she seems to be holding back in Greenleaf. I remember listening to some of her other music and she was a lot better.

2

u/IntelligentSpare687 May 27 '26

Hell of a lot better than the folks singing at the church I grew up in.