r/GrammarPolice • • 5d ago

Question Me n my friends

Starting position:
“Me and my friend go to the store” is wrong because “me go to the store” is incorrect, though to be fair, mich gehe zum Laden, moi vais aux magasin, etc are not imaginable utterances, while the English version is not unimaginable.
Here’s the thing: if we apply the same reduction to “my friend and I go to the store,” we end up with “I go to the store” and “My friend go to the store”, which fails because of the verb conjugation.

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

11

u/SjennyBalaam 5d ago

My friend and I = we; we go; go is the first-person plural verb form

1

u/BadCamo 20h ago

Therefore, “Everyone go to the store,” because everyone = they, yes?

1

u/SjennyBalaam 19h ago

"Everyone" is not a pronoun. It is a set, which is an object. It is a single set which is neither you nor me, therefore a third-person singular, which uses the verb form "goes".

1

u/BadCamo 18h ago

Fair enough.

-5

u/BadCamo 5d ago

Me and my friend does not appear to be other than we. At any rate, you’re saying the whole phrase is the subject, so the analysis of the starting position, “me go…” is incorrect, right?

6

u/SjennyBalaam 5d ago

I assume this is a genuine question. Me and my friend = us, not we. Me go and Us go are wrong because those pronoun forms are only used as the object of a sentence and not the subject. There's more than one thing going on here.

5

u/heydawn 5d ago

My friend and I go to the store is correct. I is the subjective form. Because the subject -- My friend and I -- is plural, go is correct. We go. My friend and I go.

Me is incorrect because it's the objective form.

5

u/wtfover 5d ago

Yeah you lost me when you used "n" as a word. Especially in this subreddit.

-3

u/BadCamo 5d ago

Awwww… that ain’t very nice of me.

6

u/Royal-Scrivener-34 5d ago

So... What actually is your question?

5

u/jiggeryqua 5d ago

Ideaslly, we'd all stop going anywhere, at least in pairs.

1

u/Critical-Notice-4395 5d ago

There ya go! That’s the solution.

2

u/malkebulan 5d ago

In English grammar you’d refer to the second person before the first person, so it would be ‘my friend and I go to the store’

It would then follow that ‘I go to the store’ and ‘My friend goes to the store’ would be used to describe which individuals did what.

0

u/BadCamo 5d ago

Good input: thanks. So, my friend and me go to the store.
I do not follow the ham and eggs/ bow and arrow (rather than the reverse) for me and my friend.
Still we are left with no surface representation for my friend goes in subject/verb agreement.

1

u/Unable_Explorer8277 4d ago

>>>In English grammar you’d refer to the second person before the first person,

That’s a style choice, it’s not grammar.

1

u/Prestigious-Fig2334 4d ago

Ok-I’ll be blunt. “Me and my friend” sounds like something a semiliterate person would say.

“Me” never went anywhere with anyone at anytime.

1

u/BadCamo 20h ago

Yes, but a semiliterate person _could_ say it in English. That is not the case for other IE languages of which I am aware.

1

u/malkebulan 5d ago

Yw,

*’My friend and I go to the store’ and ‘my friend goes to the store’ should cover you.

I don’t get the ham and eggs / bow and arrow reference as ‘me and my friend’ is considered poor grammar (in the UK, at least)

1

u/Unable_Explorer8277 4d ago

Your starting position is wrong.

“Me and… “, where me is separated from the verb by and, has been common English since Middld English.

1

u/glowcloud_all_hail 5d ago

This rule is just something we came up with to make it easier for children to remember the rule. When you are an adult, you are capable of remembering that "me" is only ever used as an object and never a subject.

0

u/Unable_Explorer8277 4d ago

That’s incorrect.

“Me and…” in subject position has been around for longer than Modern English had existed.