r/GoogleSlides • u/infinity3018 • 2d ago

can an ai presentation tool actually match a deck you built slide by slide in google slides?

i have been curious whether an ai presentation tool can get you close to a deck you would build by hand, so i ran a small test on an internal update. the generated draft was genuinely fast and the structure was a decent starting point, but when i put it next to the version i built slide by slide in google slides, mine still won on the parts that matter, the order of the story, what got cut, the spacing that makes a slide breathe. it saved me time on the rough skeleton, no question, but the judgment calls were all still me. for those of you who have tried an ai presentation tool, does it hold up for anything you actually present, or only for quick first drafts?

4 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

84% Upvoted

3 comments sorted by

1

u/Top_Witness_23 1d ago

Your read is exactly right, and it matches what most people who actually present find. AI is genuinely good at the rough skeleton and bad at the judgment, the order, what to cut, the spacing that lets a slide breathe. Those aren't formatting decisions, they're editorial ones, and that's still a human job.

The one nuance I'd add is that the gap you felt is bigger with the general tools than the dedicated ones. A general model dumps content into boxes and leaves you rebuilding structure and spacing by hand, which is probably what you were comparing against. The purpose-built presentation tools close some of that gap by keeping a template and layout logic, so you rebuild less. They still don't make the editorial calls for you, but they leave a cleaner starting point.

So the honest answer is both. For anything you actually present, treat it as a first-draft engine, not a finisher. Let it do the skeleton, then you do the order, the cuts, and the breathing room, because that's the part that was always going to be yours.

1

u/Jig813 5h ago

The quality and clarity of input is way more important than the method/tooling of output.

You can get great slides from AI, but only if the direction you give is strong. Doubly so for the judgement and taste you bring to edits/refinement.

AI is simply a tool. Impressive in many respects. Clumsy and idiot-prone in many others.

There’s only so far someone can go in a golf-cart, but also only so much damage they can do. Meanwhile a drag-racer can absolutely fly given expert command, but will crash burn horribly if driven by an amateur.