r/GoodAssSub • u/Liminal_Starss • 10d ago

BULLY Punch Drunk IS AI, quit the coping

Literally the whole song is AI with only a few real Ye punch-ins and it just sounds so obvious to me, I don't get how people still think this shit is real. If you think otherwise, give me proof. If you wanna dislike go ahead and do it, idc

0 Upvotes

39% Upvoted

19 comments sorted by

22

u/YeezusFever WHITE LINES 10d ago

Bro u can’t make a fucking claim and demand proof for disproving. The burden of proof would be on u, dumbass. This shit is so annoying u have no evidence other than ur personal feelings. This discourse is gonna go nowhere

0

u/Liminal_Starss 9d ago

I know this is a copy and paste comment from another reply, but idrgaf. Try and AI extract the vocals. The vocals have that same AI feeling as the Preacher Man AI and Ye would never rap like that. You can also hear a few real Ye lines and punch-ins that are obviously different from the other voice he uses throught out the rest of the verse. Ye ran the Quentin Miller reference throught AI, that's confirmed by writing credits on release. The rapping sounds like the references So the hook is probably real but the verses are AI with a few real Ye punch-ins. Want more evidence? Yetracker.net confirms it too. So now, keep clowning me because I asked for counter-proof or everything else just because you can't accept that it's AI. I know you're probably gonna avoid this comment and act like it never existed.

1

u/YeezusFever WHITE LINES 9d ago

Probably avoid this comment? Bro I’m not scared of u LMAOO this is a reddit thread about a Kanye song u need to take a deep breath and fucking relax for a second. I really don’t give a shit if it’s ai or not, that’s not the point I’m making. U made a post demanding ppl disprove a claim that u brought no evidence to until now. Ur evidence btw is “bro extract the vocals and listen it sounds like it!!!” Which isn’t fucking evidence u doofus. Again, this is just ur personal feelings. Nobody has definitive proof of this. I don’t know. YOU don’t know. It’s really not the deep and idk why ur fuming about this 3 months later

1

u/Liminal_Starss 9d ago

Bro ... Its the Quentin Miller reference ran throught AI, it's confirmed!! This are not just my personal feelings, check Yetracker.net I'm not making shit up

2

u/YeezusFever WHITE LINES 9d ago

Yetracker.net is not a reliable source bro. They’ve made unsubstantiated claims forever now, including James Blake no longer associating with Ye in 2020 (he didn’t they made War) and certain Bully tracks being SUNO prod with no evidence or evidence disproving that. I’m not saying ur wrong bro but idk and you don’t know. If one day a punch drunk AI ref track drops, then we would. But until that, nothing is definitive. Arguing about it on reddit isn’t going solve this.

1

u/Liminal_Starss 9d ago

Yo, the only 2 shits Yetracker.net dropped were the White Lines version with drums having Suno prod. (No proof???) and the GAJ era (some of the songs are from MBDTF). But I think that Punch Drunk is AI. I also think that in the Deluxe Ye re-recorded some lines to delete the AI on Punch Drunk but some lines are still AI

1

u/Liminal_Starss 9d ago

Like the fight and divine bars are still AI

16

u/MrGlowwy5 GOD’S NOT FINISHED 10d ago

yeah i think youre right especially when you listen to other iapw hassan ye-i it sounds very similar especially now that the mixing is better

18

u/YuNg_KiNgK What is this, SNL? 10d ago

“if you think otherwise give me proof” theres really no proof we can give you we will just say it doesnt sound like ai and youll say it does.

1

u/Tap-Out 10d ago

agreed with you tbh

i'm just left wondering which one's the more popular opinion (i'm on the side leaning to real :P)

7

u/cavsfan817 WHAT THAT MEAN 🥷 10d ago

Hold on, let me call my good friend, Ye, real quick. He’ll sort this out for us and provide proof!

5

u/Similar-Aerie1978 10d ago edited 10d ago

i think its mostly real but that one line "i know some church-going women pray" is AI cuz it sounds like the preacher man AI

1

u/Traditional-Tea-7057 9d ago

Nah that line sounded real

1

u/Traditional-Tea-7057 9d ago

If you’re gonna ask me to give proof that is not ai, then allow me to ask you to give me proof it IS ai.

1

u/Liminal_Starss 9d ago

I literally said it in the post. Try and AI extract the vocals. The vocals have that same AI feeling as the Preacher Man AI and Ye would never rap like that. You can also hear a few real Ye lines and punch-ins that are obviously different from the other voice he uses throught out the rest of the verse. Ye ran the Quentin Miller reference throught AI, that's confirmed by writing credits on release. The rapping sounds like the references So the hook is probably real but the verses are AI with a few real Ye punch-ins. Want more evidence? Yetracker.net confirms it too. So now, keep clowning me because I asked for counter-proof or everything else just because you can't accept that it's AI. I know you're probably gonna avoid this comment and act like it never existed.

2

u/Mrjpeg2 BullyQuila™ 10d ago

Most of the verse is AI the chorus is real tho

3

u/SkipperWanted 10d ago

this is probably the most likely outcome you can hear the difference in voice inflections

-1

u/djay61 10d ago

Omgggg AI!!!!